10 Best Sandwich Shops in New Haven

“Was visiting New Haven last weekend (from Brooklyn) and had the pleasure of eating at Olmo not once, not twice, but three times!! For breakfast, every morning of my visit. The bagels so good, the menu so mouthwatering, the people so kind and welcoming— I couldn’t stay away! And I’m still thinking about it a week later…

The first morning I got the Hot Pastrami. It is, and i cannot stress this enough, DELICIOUS! A generous helping of pastrami—rivaling that of Katz Deli—paired with a mind-blowingly yummy spinach-artichoke schmear and some pickled onions sandwiched between a sesame seed bagel. Cannot recommend enough.

The next morning I had to try a new schmear (the schmear selection is thrilling). I went with beet and dill veggie on an onion bagel. Crunchy, refreshing, sweet. Yum.

I am a creature of habit so, despite my desire to try the basil feta schmear, the third morning I went with the Hot Pastrami again. Turns out lightning can strike twice, it was just as delish the second time.

This is a place that clearly loves their clientele and their craft. They were communicative, efficient, and so friendly. You immediately feel welcome. A must visit for any bagel lover who finds themself in New Haven!!“

“Been going here for yrs for the subs which are top notch but i tried a chef salad yesterday it was the Best Chef salad ive ever had!! do yourself a favor and try one! Believe me you wont regret it“

“Usually their salads are delicious. But today i came by, right when they opened up (prob a mistake) and ordered a crispy chicken salad … My salad was done in about 5 mins …. ( how can chicken be cooked that fast?) Anyway, i tried to eat the salad for dinner. My croutons were stale, the bread was stale and tomatoes along with the cucumbers tasted like theve been sitting out from the night before. I doubt chicken was freshly made. I’m so disappointed. Next time i know not to come right when they open up.“

“First found Ninth Square at CompassionFest! Food SO delicious & healthy - now that we’ve found their New Haven place we can get the food more often. The pictures & videos make my mouth water!!!😋“

“They make the best sandwiches and chicken in the Ville and the prices are good Hats off to people choice for not giving a greasy steak sandwich..the owner is always pleasant and knows his customers ........Wonderful.. a great variety of everything“

“if you like a good deli sandwich this place KILLS it. also offers some hot food options which are always phenomenal. easy on/off from the highway. little bit hard to find at first but ALWAYS worth it“

“Finally, a coffee shop where the baristas are as excellent as their coffee. Great spot.“

“The food is always made fresh right in front of you. William and Freddy are both friendly and excellent at what they do! Highly recommend!“

“I have recently visited Subway and had a really positive experience. The rotisserie chicken was tender and flavorful, and the tuna fish was delicious, making for a satisfying meal. The male employee who served me was exceptionally friendly and efficient, enhancing the overall experience. The ambiance of the place was also welcoming and positive. I'll definitely be coming back!“