10 Best Seafood Restaurants in Fenwick Island

“I have been missing some good seafood from my country and I say let’s try this place. No regrets. The food was great, pretty laid back ambiance. Customer service was A1. Keep doing you Rusty Jimmy.“

“Food was amazing as well as their service“

“We dined at One Coastal over the weekend. We had four people in our party and everyone ordered a different item on the menu. Food was fantastic! I enjoyed a simple pasta dish that was the most delish meal I’ve had in years. I shared with everyone at the table and everyone loved it. My husband had the pork chop and reported that it was delicious. My daughter had the scallops and said they were perfect. Her boyfriend had the flank steak and it looked terrific. But my pasta was PERFECTION!“

“Our food was delicious, but what was also great was Colleen. She couldn’t do enough for the four of us to make our lunch 👍 great.You have a jem of a server. Lynn 1/27/24“

“Our first visit there. I had shrimp and grits that were excellent. Very original Louisiana flavor. My wife had crab cakes with a house made sauce that was awesome. Our server, Luke, was fabulous also. Will definitely be returning.“

“What a great place to eat and enjoy the scenery! We visited on a Thursday afternoon/evening during the off season (October) so, it was likely a little quieter than what it may be on other days. The interior of the restaurant was very spacious despite the tables being kind of small for the 4 of us. Loved the decor and the overall ambiance and aesthetic of the place. It was overall very inviting and fun. The exterior patio area was also very spacious and it is right on the water so the scenery was beautiful!

The service was impeccable! I believe our waitress’ name was Layla and she could not have been more pleasant, quick and efficient , clear and concise, very professional and just a pleasure to have wait on us!

The food… mine was absolutely delicious!! I had the seared spicy tuna on crispy rice and it was divine! It was honestly better than I had even anticipated and I will definitely get it again in the future! My mother got the boom boom shrimp and although we both liked it she did complain that it was just a little too greasy for her taste (but we all have different tastes). I will say it could have used just a little more sauce but also I believe had we asked for a side of it we could have gotten that and been perfectly fine. My step-father got the shrimp salad sandwich which he stated he really enjoyed and would definitely get again in a return visit. However, he was a little sad to see that it came on a burger bun when he though it was supposed to have come on a Kaiser roll. My grandmother got the French onion soup and said it was also very good but she complained that there were too many onions (it’s onion soup lol not sure what she expected 😂) but none the less she really enjoyed it and just shared the onions. The muffins (coconut and blueberry) and raisin bread that were provided for the table upon arrival were delectable! They were a perfect little treat to start the meal off! The only other thing that had us a little disappointed was that our entrees did not come with a choice of side/s although I am sure we could have asked, it would have cost more. I thought it was a bit strange that they didn’t come with at least one side that was included in the price of the meal. Don’t get me wrong we all left full and happy but for the cost, it was a bit surprising. As a side note, I got the best mango margarita I think I’ve ever had!! Definitely can’t wait to return here and would 100% recommend this restaurant to anyone looking for delicious food, great views and wonderful service!! Thanks so much!!“

“This was a take out order and it was fantastic! I had the halibut and I cannot stop thinking about how great it was. My husband had the pork chop & it was amazing. I wouldn't just recommend this restaurant, I say it's a must go if you're on Fenwick Island!“

“Wings are Amazing!! I got the Mango Habanero (hot but not killer) Trying the Reapers next!“

“Food is amazing and people are great! Had recent health diagnosis and can’t eat corn; asked if they could scoop with little corn - they picked corn out for me! Seafood is always fresh and top notch! 5 of 5!“

“Service great. Sticky bun was a bit dry. Pancakes were good, but mangos, peaches and pineapple are from a can so not the best fresh fruit. Garbage plate omelet is good, lots of vegetables and meat. The home fries are sliced potatoes. Fast with coffee and teas. Lots of pastries available and wish we had room to try more.“