10 Best Seafood Restaurants in Fenwick Island

“I have been missing some good seafood from my country and I say let’s try this place. No regrets. The food was great, pretty laid back ambiance. Customer service was A1. Keep doing you Rusty Jimmy.“

“Food was amazing as well as their service“

“Our food was delicious, but what was also great was Colleen. She couldn’t do enough for the four of us to make our lunch 👍 great.You have a jem of a server. Lynn 1/27/24“

“Our first visit there. I had shrimp and grits that were excellent. Very original Louisiana flavor. My wife had crab cakes with a house made sauce that was awesome. Our server, Luke, was fabulous also. Will definitely be returning.“

“Delicious Creamsicle Crush! Great server, meals came out quickly even though they were busy. I enjoyed my coconut shrimp especially because it wasn't greasy and the orange dipping sauce was enjoyable. My husband ordered the shrimp salad in a tomato. He did say it needed a little more seasoning so he asked for some Old Bay to add to it. We love coming here, but you need to arrive early or you will have a long wait!“

“We dined at One Coastal over the weekend. We had four people in our party and everyone ordered a different item on the menu. Food was fantastic! I enjoyed a simple pasta dish that was the most delish meal I’ve had in years. I shared with everyone at the table and everyone loved it. My husband had the pork chop and reported that it was delicious. My daughter had the scallops and said they were perfect. Her boyfriend had the flank steak and it looked terrific. But my pasta was PERFECTION!“

“Love this place. Great refresh of a beach classic. Love the pantry where you can grab coffee, breakfast and pastries and provisions. The happy hour is great in the main restaurant. I can’t say enough about this gem. Also, Fridays they host a farmers market.“

“Wings are Amazing!! I got the Mango Habanero (hot but not killer) Trying the Reapers next!“

“Food is amazing and people are great! Had recent health diagnosis and can’t eat corn; asked if they could scoop with little corn - they picked corn out for me! Seafood is always fresh and top notch! 5 of 5!“

“Love going here. Staff is friendly, atmosphere, food and service is great. Still love it after dining here for 18 years. They won Top Bakery in Fenwick Island for 2025 certified by Business Rate. Their Danish pastries are loaded with filling as are their other items. Love their eclairs and cream cheese Danish as well as their scones, ricotta and last but not least their sticky buns. Love their pancakes and breakfasts. Grilled cheese and Reubens are especially good. Love the decor because it reminds me of my Mom's kitchen.“