50 Best Seafood Restaurants in Fort Myers

“Our waiter Kitch was awesome! There were 4 of us and we all had amazing dinners.“

“Come for the oysters stay for the swordfish BLT. We had a dozen East Coast oysters and four West Coast, absolutely outstanding. Additionally they have a bottomless Mimosa, and the swordfish BLT was large enough for my husband and I to share, knowing we were going to order the homemade donuts for dessert. This place is a must visit. Everything was so delicious!!!!“

“Potentially the best NYE restaurant experience ever !!! The wait was minimal, the restaurant was buzzing, the food was prompt and delicious, staff were attentive and professional! The management clearly had this planned and executed perfectly !! 10/10!! Congrats and Happy New Year“

“I took my Wife here for a B’Day dinner.. The service was great, food amazing, we loved the Sangria. Nice vibes and an overall nice and different experience..“

“IF YOU DON'T GO THE PIRATE YOU ARE MISSING OUT ON SOME GREAT FOOD!! I WISH I WAS HERE LONGER I WOULD GO AGAIN!! THANK YOU PIRATE SEAFOOD AND CHICKEN!! AND YOU ARE SO KIND !????“

“The food is excellent! We really like the shrimp tacos and lobster chowder. The three waitresses all worked together and gave top notch service.“

“Delicious food, great atmosphere and amazing service! Best hush puppies around.Sweet and sour shrimp sooo good. mashed potatoes and green beans amazeballs!!“

“1st time going, hands down best fried clams I've ever had. Wings, fried okra , hush puppies, and coleslaw were all on point. Staff was friendly and quick.“

“While vacationing in Fort Myers, FL, my wife and I stopped at Pinchers near Fort Myers Beach. The service was excellent and our server (Wendy) was THE best! My wife had the Fish & Chips and said the fresh fish was great. I had a sauteed soft crab which was good (soft crabs are particularly challenging). the hand cut fries were excellent, and the cole slaw was very good. I would definitely eat there again if I'm in the area.“

“The osetra caviar is decent. Momma Mia Oysters are great. I don't like bluepoint. The lobster roll is massive and they did an ok job on risotto. I prefer it over Gordon Ramsey. I would rather go here than Hell's Kitchen Las Vegas.“

“My family had the most wonderful meal for their last night in Fl. My husband and I have wanted to eat here for years and finally made it happen. We were treated so wonderfully by Tess, who was most amazing! All our meals were excellent including the soups and salads we all enjoyed. It is such a beautiful place and we were totally happy with the experience. I would totally recommend The Prawnbroker!“

“Great food but most importantly, great people make this restaurznt the best of it's kind anywhere in SW Florida. Shrimp portions are generous and if you like real southern cooking. Their authentic gumbo and creole jambalaya will warm your heart. If you happen to want an even warmer heart, you can up the heat with the ghost pepper version. You will encounter some great cooks and some attentive servers who will make your visits habit-forming!“

“Great specials always great food and plenty!“

“I’ve been all through NE over the years refining my repertoire of Chowder and Lobster joints. It’s not Red’s of Wiscasset but SO much closer. No wait at lunch today and it was 2 hours last time at Red’s! I’d recommend this place for sure. Fresh. Clean.“

“Some of the freshest seafood I have ever had and delicious food as well. Everything on the menu is 10 out of 10+ the service and presentation of the plates is amazing They are very Friendly And welcoming 100% recommended to anyone that has not tried it“

“One of the best restaurants I’ve been too in a long time !!! Food is fantastic!!“

“Great atmosphere and friendly staff. Also had live music. Food was Ok.“

“We stopped here for an early dinner. The staff seated us promptly and got our drink order going. The place has a nice Florida vibe atmosphere. I had some wings (hot) which were pretty good. I wasn’t a fan of the blue cheese dressing. My wife had the Haddock fish dinner which she said the fish was very good. I took a pic of her food, but it was too blurry to post. We dined here on 11/22/25.“

“Been coming here for years with my family. Everything is tasty. Always get the small pangasius fish sandwiches. The large one is more than we can eat at one sitting.“

“went there for the first time very clean staff was great food was awesome hot fresh will be returning soon“

“We had such a lovely evening last night at The Silver King Ocean Brasserie in Downtown Fort Myers. We elected the Chef Experience with wine pairings. Five courses and five wines curated and shared knowledge from Willie our server and level 2 sommelier and amazing Chef Jeff! Wonderful service. We had great food and everything was on point! Loved the beets and duck, oh and the gnocchi!!“

“Amazing Food& Dranks Definitely 10/10 I love the seafood and the twisted wings are beyond good overall 10/10“

“Nice place, food is great, but the music is way too loud, is hard to keep a conversation without having to raise your voice. Music needs to be tuned down.“

“Best Seafood in the area. Wholesale only.“

“wow! we went for the first time last week, and I wish we could've gone again the next day! staff were friendly and food came out fast. can't wait to visit again!“

“The food is outstanding and fresh! We visit every time we come down to Florida!“

“First, kudos to our waiter Lee. He was very enthusiastic, knew the products, and made very good menu recommendations which we ordered. I enjoyed my grilled scallops and my companion enjoyed her chicken trio. He also introduced us to the $10 carryout which we also ordered. The only thing that wasn't spot-on was my overcooked broccoli.“

“We always enjoy the wine dinners!“

“Sabroso todo 😋 muy amables l@smeser@s“

“The Maryland style blue crabs were hot, sweet, salty, tender, and paired oh so well with that dreamy, drawn butter! I devoured two crabs in one sitting! Drew was our server and he was the BEST! He was funny, had attitude (in a good way), and was one of the most attentive servers I've ever had. Great job, Pinchers!! 🦀🍽🍷 Ps..the 2 for 1 sangrias were amazing!“

“Excellent meal last night started with Outstanding coconut martini, Chilian sea bass, and finished with coffee and baklava. Excellent service, going back on Sunday with my friends to introduce them to this wonderful restaurant.“

“On April 6, 2023 our family came in to celebrate three birthdays - 88, 61, and 27, plus there was all ages younger, older and in-between. Our waitress, Karissa P, was better than awesome. Handling things for a 3 year old to the 88 year old. She made the evening better and fun. Just wanted to say thank you and appreciate her great job!!!!!!“

“Fresh great tasting food. Im never disappointed“

“I couldn't decide between the lunch sushi (pick 2 rolls or 3) and a hibachi plate (steak, but I'm sure they would all be good) and since they were both so reasonably priced, I got both. I am so glad I did. I was astounded how good the sushi was, in particular the spicy salmon. I also got a tuna avocado roll. They packed a lot of tuna in there, very big pieces (not too large to be cumbersome, just saying they weren't chintzy, definitely above average amount of tuna). The hibachi steak was so delicious. The meat was tender and flavorful, and also precut to nice bite sizes pieces leaving room for some veggies and/or rice in a forkful if you wanted. I really appreciate places that do that. The veggies were crisp and also flavorful. Very generous portions. If I wasn't sharing my sushi, I couldn't have ate it all and gone back to work (and I have a pretty large appetite). This meal hit the trifecta: reasonable cost, delicious, and abundant. Thank you Hinachi House!

...service was good as well“

“The best restaurant in Lee county!!! The food and the service is great? Chef Dale is the best in the state of Florida!?!“

“Everytime I come here service is great. I just moved here from New Jersey and ive got accustomed to being a regular. Mike and Jersey are amazing. On top of their game. They offer good suggestions with food and drink and try to stay engaged with their customers. I sit at the bar every time just because they are there. Amazing bartenders, good food, and bloody mary to die for.“

“It’s good for great food in a family atmosphere“

“Lisa was so great! Awesome food and good atmosphere.“

“Just a quick shout out to Dyana and the Mango Team. I meant to post this earlier, but we enjoyed their service, food and entertainment offered on stage for.the evening of 9/27. A great time was had by all. Menu prices are very fair compaired to other venues. Kudos to all! We will be back for sure.“

“Good good. Good service good atmosphere“

“The restaurant has a great water view. We were there for Mother’s Day and they had a buffet brunch. The food and service were both good. We’ll definitely be back for their regular dinner menu.“

“The Capital Grille of Fort Myers is here and delivering the highest level of food and service. I was greeted by Norby in the warmest and most professional way possible. Our service by Alyssa was phenomenal, she anticipated anything we needed before we realized we did. She was also incredibly warm and professional without being stuffy or uptight. She kept the whole evening lively and relaxing. The lamb and filet were cooked perfectly, and the sides were piping hot and delicious. This is the perfect place for a celebration, a date night, or even a cocktail after work. I can't thank the team enough for my fantastic experience.“

“We tried it for the first time last week and everything was great! The food was fresh and flavorful, and the service was spot-on!“

“Purchase 5 lbs fresh caught shrimp and took then to visit my son ans family in Tennesse. They were outstanding. Recommend you buy your shrimp from them , you will get none better and very good prices“

“I would like the home delivery meals to be served a little more, for example the rice is very little and please make the chicharrones bigger and put more in the order because I saw few of them compared to other restaurants and you pay them for the price what they put“

“good food good atención service“

“The food was absolutely delicious and the service was great! Large portions and reasonable prices, too. I will most definitely eat here again.“

“Went to the Boat House on a Saturday in Florida. Very crowded, but we got a table by the pool. Very good service, polite employees, great food. We will be back soon! Thank you to Alex and all his employees.“

“This was our first time eating at Bahama Breeze. We went for lunch and had a salad and a pasta dish. Both were very good, and filling, The grilled chicken salad and the mushroom pasta were filling and our non-alcoholic beverages were adequate. Stacey, our server, was attentive and positive. We would return for a dinner to explore more options.“

“Love Rusty’s bar and grill. Great food and drinks. Michelle is always attentive and a lot fun. My favorite“