19 Best American Restaurants in Lake Mary

1 The Vineyard Wine Company

4.6 Superb 273 Reviews

1140 Townpark Avenue Suite 1260, Lake Mary

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“I like sit at table by bar with my wife and sit at bar other day. wife make comment about new bar man and how he make inapropriate pleasure motion with hand when shakes drink. she have espreso martini after man shake and was good just look bad. girl shakes martini and look better. friend bar woman laren not there during visit and her espreso martini much better and pretty. i iunderstand my english not best. my wife miss better service and she say drink need look better. drink be best when laren make. blad man make drink good. she and him good bar friends. food good. hummus remind of home. cheese chips good. sorry bad english”

2 Another Broken Egg Cafe

4.6 Superb 993 Reviews

920 International Parkway, Lake Mary

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Had breakfast recently on a Sunday morning. Sat outside and had the best food server named Alli. Very attentive, great personality and went over and above. Food was good as usual. Atmosphere was terrific.”

3 Duffy's Sports Grill

4.3 Superb 488 Reviews

Colonial Town Park, 951 Market Promenade Avenue, Lake Mary

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Great food and Tony our waiter is the Best. We are at Duff’s every Wednesday night for Trivia…Fun place.”

4 Fresh Kitchen

4.5 Superb 466 Reviews

3793 Lake Emma Road, Lake Mary

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Can’t rave about this place enough, specifically their catering. They are as reliable and accommodating as it gets and makes my job easier when catering lunch for work. Madisen in particular has been so helpful and great to work with. Highly recommend this location for all your catering needs!”

5 Gator's Dockside Group Inc

4.1 Good 21 Reviews

1331 South International Parkway Suite 1291, Lake Mary

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Huge rave!!!! I just got home from dinner and have never been more pleased. I have Celiac Disease and a wheat allergy. My server, Sydney C., was knowledgeable about the GF options and even double checked with her manager. She even brought up cross contamination before I did and assured me it would not be an issue. I was actually able to enjoy a meal with my family at a restaurant, which is not something I have been able to do in a long time. Thank you so much for being so accommodating. We will definitely be coming back.”

6 BurgerFi

4.4 Superb 584 Reviews

3801 West Lake Mary Boulevard, Lake Mary

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Upon arrival, there was an atmosphere in the room that the food was going to be an experience out of this world, from the customers service, knowledgeable employees, and a taste that you can tell that it comes from the farm not the lab. You can tell the fries/sweet potatoe waffle fries are handmade 10/10! & burgers delicious !”

7 TooJay’s Deli • Bakery • Restaurant

4.4 Superb 485 Reviews

3577 Lake Emma Road Suite 101, Lake Mary

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“as always-- a very good meal. Brittany was very attentive even as the restaurant became more crowded during lunch time. Great job!”

8 347 Grille by Coach Shula

4.0 Good 465 Reviews

2974 International Pkwy, Lake Mary

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Server was friendly and sweet, but not very good about serving, for example, appetizer arriving but no share plates, dessert arriving but dirty dishes still in front of us including plates that needed a doggy bag. Also, one person asked for steak medium well and got medium rare if not rare. And I ordered the fish and chips special with beer-battered haddock, and the server asked me how I'd like that cooked, rare, medium, or well done? That was...interesting. It only comes battered and fried! So it was funny, but the server was genuinely clueless.”

9 First Watch

4.3 Superb 439 Reviews

218 Wheelhouse Lane Ste 1000, Lake Mary

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Just had the best Breakfast at First Watch! Sarah (and Nicole, one of the Hosts who helped Sarah as she had the large table by our booth!) were excellent! They took great care of us! Awesome food as always! Thank you!!!”

10 Topgolf Lake Mary

4.3 Superb 386 Reviews

1010 Greenwood Boulevard, Lake Mary

• Delivery

“I am NOT a golfer, put-put was the extent of my experience with a ball and a club. For my 35th highschool reunion out class rented some spaces and we all had a blast. It was great fun, the atmosphere was relaxed and the service was outstanding! Great deal for some good times with old friends.”

11 Gator's Dockside Lake Mary

3.9 Good 415 Reviews

4349 West Lake Mary Boulevard, Lake Mary

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Huge rave!!!! I just got home from dinner and have never been more pleased. I have Celiac Disease and a wheat allergy. My server, Sydney C., was knowledgeable about the GF options and even double checked with her manager. She even brought up cross contamination before I did and assured me it would not be an issue. I was actually able to enjoy a meal with my family at a restaurant, which is not something I have been able to do in a long time. Thank you so much for being so accommodating. We will definitely be coming back.”

12 F&D Kitchen and Bar

4.2 Good 491 Reviews

1541 International Parkway, Lake Mary

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“We kicked off the night with the Japanese milk bread, and to say it is superb is an understatement. It arrived at the table warm, boasting that impossibly pillowy, cloud-like texture that tears apart easily. It has just the right hint of sweet and salty creaminess, elevated beautifully by a swipe of whipped lemon butter. It is the kind of bread that makes you want to cancel the rest of your order and just ask for more bread. I had the long bone pork chop with a side of Brussel sprouts. The pork chop was tender, juicy and flavorful while the crisped charred Brussel sprouts had the right amount of savory and sweetness. My friends who attend along with me ordered the steak frites and the salmon and found it to be delectable. Between the exceptional food, warm hospitality, and inviting atmosphere, it was a memorable dining experience from start to finish.”

13 Friendly Confines Sports Restaurant

4.2 Good 304 Reviews

7025 Co Rd 46A, Lake Mary

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Great food and service ! It’s a whole vibe!”

14 1501 Kitchen & Bar

4.1 Good 76 Reviews

1501 International Parkway, Lake Mary

• Delivery

“Just wonderful. The Christmas buffet was amazing. So much to offer. Something for everyone. The servers and omelet station people were so friendly and accommodating. Making sure we were very well taken care of. Great job.”

15 Nice-N-Easy Sports Bar

3.9 Good 89 Reviews

101 North Country Club Road Suite 125, Lake Mary

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Great service - convenient location”

16 Orlando Marriott Lake Mary

3.9 Good 276 Reviews

1501 International Pkwy, Lake Mary

• Take-Out

“Great atmosphere, nice spacious rooms and amenities. Just relaxing!!”

17 Chili's Grill & Bar

3.9 Good 449 Reviews

4565 West Lake Mary Boulevard, Lake Mary

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“ToGo is super easy. Mary Beth made transaction happen with no wait. Super quick. Ty”

18 Links of Lake Mary

3.3 Good 206 Reviews

550 Timacuan Boulevard, Lake Mary

“Great place. Course has tuned the corner as is a good spot”

19 Steak 'n Shake

3.2 Average 406 Reviews

4325 West Lake Mary Boulevard, Lake Mary

• Take-Out
• Delivery
• Drive-Through

“Good place for the family”