20 Best Ice Cream Shops in Pensacola

“This is the best gelato I’ve had outside of Rome. I would fly back to Pensacola for this gelato. It’s that good.“

“The best homemade ice cream in town! Great flavors. I love all the staff and how they take care gluten free me.(who knew hot fudge contained gluten malt? they did!) I bring everyone I know.“

“We love Wild Honey and we are so happy that it is closer to us now. We attended multiple events in 2025 and decided to start 2026 off with a sweet treat. Bonnie (Bonnie Bee on the receipt) was less than nice and professional unfortunately. Telling me to calm down because I didn’t know if my kids consistently picking up their cups off the scale, I had to ask her if she was able to get the weight of them…. Very disappointing but we do love coming in. We will be frequenting the pace location instead, as they are friendly and much better at communicating when they have the weight logged so I don’t have to sit there and explain to the kids to stop grabbing for their sweet treat. Kids will be kids but your customers are most likely with children so Bonnie needs better training in communication so parents are not just waiting until they have to ask for the total or ask if their product has been weighed.“

“They make a great burger. I'm a fan.“

“the best apple fritter I have ever had....glad I found this place👍“

“Had a coupon so I stopped by to check it out with my little one and I would 10/10 recommend. Clean, friendly staff, delicious frozen yogurt and so many toppings to pick from. Our first time I. But definitely not our last!“

“Kilwins is a sweet tooth’s paradise! 🍦🍫 From the moment you step inside, you're greeted with the heavenly aroma of fresh fudge and chocolate being made right in the store. The ice cream is rich, creamy, and comes in a variety of classic and unique flavors that are perfect for cooling off while strolling through downtown Pensacola. Their handmade fudge and chocolates are simply divine—whether you're grabbing a quick treat or putting together a gift box, you can't go wrong. The friendly staff and nostalgic atmosphere make every visit feel special. Kilwins is a must-visit for anyone with a love for sweets!“

“We went in late Saturday night after touring through Pensacola. The atmosphere and smell is amazing. The sprinkle pool and photo booths were a beautiful experience. They have bulk candy and other souvenirs. I can’t wait to go back and try other flavors. It was two beautiful girls in the shop that night that took our photos. Thank you for an amazing experience.“

“A nice place and everything is delicious, staff good except no mgrs around and riff raff was in the store creating a lot of turmoil for the customers, esp the kids. The staff said they could do nothing about it, so we as customers had to remove them from inside as they were loitering, yelling, throwing things, fowl language, it was not a good experience.“

“We went in late Saturday night after touring through Pensacola. The atmosphere and smell is amazing. The sprinkle pool and photo booths were a beautiful experience. They have bulk candy and other souvenirs. I can’t wait to go back and try other flavors. It was two beautiful girls in the shop that night that took our photos. Thank you for an amazing experience.“

“Great ice cream shop. Can sit inside or outside and enjoy my favorite ice cream - Graham Central Station.“

“We just left there shortly before closing and the girls working there were fantastic!
They were sweet and phenomenal with my daughters even though it was late in their working day!
Great job Chloe P. and coworker!
Thanks for the great experience ladies.“

“Staff came right outside when I hit “Im here” on the app! Usually the staff open the box for you to see the product but this time it was just handed to me. The box had cookie crumbs on it when it was handed to me. One of the cookies was cut by the box lid when I opened the box and one looked like it had been moved around in the box, they both still tasted good, but luckily this order was for me to enjoy personally!“

“Delicious! Creamy. Amazing. Friendly staff! Quality all the way. Highly recommend!“

“Mocha shake was delicious! Definitely will be back for more“

“ordered a 8" birthday cake. yellow cake, Graham cracker, cheesecake flavor ice cream, mix in fudge and raspberries. this cake was delicious creamy ,flavorful and fresh. would absolutely order again. we don't even live here, visiting from WI. highly recommend.“

“I found my new favorite place to get wings and ice cream! Food and Customer service was a 100/10! We will most definitely be back!“

“yummy ice cream and clean place“

“We love our neighbor Bubba’s Sweet Spot! Their staff is wonderful, knowledgeable and friendly. They have amazing handmade chocolates and caramels. We love pouring our espresso and olive oil over their ice cream! 😍“

“I finally made it to Nolita’s for some ice cream with a friend and we will be coming back for more!! I got the tiramisu sundae and it was exactly what I needed and more! The presentation was beautiful, the flavor was great and I believe there was tiramisu and coffee at the bottom of the ice cream! The staff was super sweet, the owner, Hylene, actually brought our ice cream outside to us and the fun vintage decor was refreshing! Also the bathroom was super clean! Can’t wait to try more from them!!“