49 Best American Restaurants near Siesta Key

“Fabulous food...best in the village! Fabulous service and location...can't say enough! 5 out of 5 stars..Beau our server rocked!!!“

“First time here , Attentive Staff ,Food was presented well and Tasty,The only complaint was it was a chilly / windy day and they would not close the doors, when asked because they said people would think they were closed.“

“Best place to have a meal on the island! Amazing ownership & staff!“

“Muy buenooooo Excelente atención“

“Food was great and drinks were great. Service was terrible, waitress (young blonde girl) never checked on us, always on her phone and asked for a box and she sat at a table and got on her phone instead.“

“We are from Tampa and came to Sarasota just for a couple of days to celebrate Valentine’s. Andrei!!! the waitress was awesome, he knew the menu and was able to recommend different alternatives, food was delicious and service was great, definitely coming back. My husband and I did not have a reservation but we were able to wait for a table at the bar which was also good 😊“

“Michael's on East (MOE) is one of the best fine dining establishments in Sarasota and has been in business for nearly 40 years. Ive been a customer for nearly 30 of those 40 years and despite its maturity, MOE is still hot, hopping and a crowd pleaser for those who enjoy great food, wines and service. During its nearly four decades, MOE has been wowing patrons with its fine cuisine, decor, and outstanding service. Don't be surprised if you see actors, comedians and musicians who might be performing at the Van Wezel during the winter season, sitting next to you because the concierge at their hotel recommended MOE as one of the desirable restaurants for a sensational meal, wine and service. MOE is rich in Sarasota heritage and is the perfect choice to celebrate a special occasion with that very special guest or guests. It's a delight in every way.“

“Beautiful romantic upscale place is nearly all vegan with a few options for carnivores. This worked out well for my friend and me, and she loved all the things we tried. I have got to attempt making rice tots. Great wine list too. We liked it so much that we did a delivery a few days later, and it was amazingly fast. Very creative sushi. And we took home the blueberry cheesecake, so decadent. What a lovely downtown Sarasota has.“

“We had dinner last night and can’t stop talking about how much we enjoyed the food and service! We were celebrating my husband’s birthday and the host treated us to prosecco while we waited for our table. The filet, the halibut, the lobster tails, the desserts (especially the chocolate cake!) was all absolutely delicious!! Our server was wonderful as well! Very personable and had great menu recommendations. We will be back!!“

“James provided excellent service at Oak & Stone. He was attentive, friendly, and made sure everything was perfect throughout our meal. The restaurant itself has a great atmosphere, delicious food, and a fantastic drink selection. You can tell the staff really care about the guest experience. We had a wonderful time and will definitely be back. Highly recommend Oak & Stone, and if you get James as your server, you’re in great hands!“

“Love the food and the service“

“Amazing spot for large groups! We hosted a networking happy hour here for a group of 50! The service, atmosphere, drinks & food couldn't have been better!! Thank you Jason, Troy, Dana & bartending gals for your wonderful hospitality! Everything about your venue was a hit! Thank YOU!“

“Our favorite restaurant when we come to Siesta Key. Had dinner last night, my husband had the skirt steak, I had the pork tenderloin..Both were perfection. Be sure to make a reservation.“

“Having an stellar sandwich and excellent coleslaw, a must try if you are downtown SRQ.“

“Great casual fare. We shared the delicious recommended Shrimpy fondue and followed with their dry rub ribs (The best in a long time) and a Cap'n Shannen's Pineapple Boat filled to the brim with deliciousness. A very friendly staff and 5 stars to our server Missy. Her recommendations were right on! The service she provided was top notch!“

“Sage never disappoints and we love how the chef always loves to change it up. Not only is the inside beautiful but phenomenal rooftop bar. And the wait staff are always top notch.“

“Great food. Good customer service. Good prices“

“Great food and ambience. Very professional and courteous staff. The Ribs and Salmon were both amazing!“

“We had the BEST dinner thanks to our fabulous server, Marissa! The food was absolutely delicious, and Marissa went above and beyond to make sure our evening was perfect. We will definitely be coming back and will be requesting her again, wish I could give 10 stars!“

“the grilled fish sandwich with regular tartar sauce, fries and mushy peas. everything was wonderful“

“This place is just amazing!“

“What an enjoyable night. The risotto was outstanding. Very busy and a little noisy but our server Traci made the night so fun and and enjoyable. Her attentiveness was outstanding“

“5 stars on the food, in fairness to everyone this is my 'go-to' place for a real homemade style hamburger & fries.
I've personally not had anything else on their menu. I've heard the Cuban sandwich is a 5 also.
Everything I've seen come out of their lil kitchen has looked delicious. But 5 stars 🌟.. the staff always friendly, the owner always making his rounds, saying hi and helping the staff.
Atmosphere, eclectic is the first word that comes to mind, paper towels, not napkins.. remember it is what they call it; an Old Packing House made into a café! Enjoy your visit ans thanks for supporting small, locally owned businesses.“

“Our server, Amber, was knowledgeable, professional and put the “S” in service. She made our time very enjoyable.“

“Station 400 is hands down my favorite breakfast spot in Sarasota. The food is always fresh and delicious with fun twists on the classics. It has that Cheers vibe—friendly, cozy, and family owned, so you always feel welcome. Megan and Austin are awesome servers and make every visit even better. If you want great food and a place that feels like home, this is it! Try the Lemon Curd & Fresh Blackberry Pancakes and Blood Orange Mimosa.“

“My husband and I recently had the pleasure if dining at Sophie’s, in Saks Fifth Avenue in Sarasota. What an amazing experience. The decor both inside and outside so chic. We had Matty as our waitress. She was spot on with top notch service and a wonderful personality. We started with a bread basket of assorted toppings, delicious. He had the Tai chicken. Well prepared and perfect with seasoning. I had on of the best burger ever. Cooked and seasoned perfectly at medium rare with tasty fries. The manager checked on us several times, a nice touch you don’t see anymore. If you happen to be in the area at the mall, I highly recommend this restaurant. You will not be disappointed. We will be back.“

“A wonderful experience. Great atmosphere and food.“

“It’s such a fun place to go! Food is great! Our bartender Mackenzie was AWESOME!!!“

“I’m so happy to have found Post! Went for the first time tonight to celebrate me and my husbands anniversary and we had a wonderful experience! When we were seated we were welcomed with a complimentary glass of champagne. They made our night feel extra special and the food was delicious! To top if off, they even gave us a complimentary slice of mouthwatering cheesecake! Thank you, Post! We can’t wait to come back! ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️“

“You could easily pass by here and not realize what you are missing. Great food, well made drinks at crazy low prices. They also currently do a Queen of Hearts drawing every week on Thursday nights...so some excitement in potentially winning a lot of money.“

“New favorite restaurant acquired. Pretty sure Zayna is a super hero that can read minds. She helped me and my wife navigate the menu and make choices that were gluten free and delicious! Wife got salmon i got steak and we both got the AMAZING Mac n cheese and Kung pow cauliflower. Also the green chilli queso dip was legit..... and the pudding.... and the cookies. Did i say the portions were actually worth the price??? 🥳🥳🥳 I will be coming back 10000%“

“Came From Ohio. to eat with the mother in law. I bring down every year.. 1st time here Excellent. Food and service.... And Drink are on point“

“Finally! Real Maine Lobster Rolls in FL. Priced well for the size. No skimping on the meat, they nailed the toasting of the bun. The butter and classic dressing were both perfection. 10/10. I only wish they offered a larger size roll option. Amazing!!“

“Love the atmosphere! visit every time I'm in town.“

“This is one of the BEST restaurants in Sarasota and that’s saying a lot with so many fabulous seafood restaurants to choose from. The sunset views are incredible- as if you’re standing on the beach without all the people. The best part of this restaurant is the incredible service! Service like this is hard to come by these days and definitely something that sets this restaurant apart from others. Once you try it for the first time, you’ll have to return every visit.“

“Absolutely amazing experience today! Delicious food and cocktails! Thank you Danielle for exceptional service. You made my day“

“prime rib special was delicious. reservations were at 6:15. it was so loud in the restaurant we couldn't talk to our friends at the table next time, I'm eating outside Then a couple came in with a southeastern guide dog who laid down by my leg I really didn't appreciate this since I am not a dog lover and it is an expensive place to eat.“

“We had a great meal on the day after Thanksgiving. Abdullah was our waiter and he was the sweetest most helpful waiter we’ve ever had. We have 4 young kids and he took such good care of us.

Food was good. Prices were fair and view was fantastic.“

“Hi this is the first time I had wrote a review on a restaurant because it's totally worthy it's the best pizza in Manatee County hands down fantastic homemade dough real quality mozzarella brick oven beautiful it's worth driving 30 miles for in my opinion University and whitfield's Sarasota 👍“

“Had a great experience at Mattisons SRQ, fast and friendly service from Alex S got me in and out with plenty of time to board my flight. The restaurant was busy, Alex was very knowledgeable and attentive. I will definitely will be back when flying out of SRQ. The chicken burger is amazing !!!!!“

“CW Prime at the St. Regis is an absolutely stunning restaurant with a beautiful atmosphere, perfect for a special celebration! As someone who has learned about the unimaginable horrors of the meat, dairy, and egg industries, I was initially hesitant to step foot in a steakhouse. However, I attended for a birthday celebration and was pleasantly surprised to find a premium plant-based option that was not only available but absolutely delicious!!

I had their grilled sweet potato dish, and let me tell you—it was loaded with flavor, filling, and truly satisfying. While the majority of the menu isn’t aligned with my values, it’s encouraging to see a restaurant like CW Prime offering a premium plant-based option that stands out in quality and taste! With so many people learning about the health benefits and transitioning to a vegan lifestyles, I hope this inspires more restaurants to expand their plant-based offerings!

For anyone like me who chooses compassion and health, or for those curious about trying something new, I wanted to share this experience. It’s proof that even at a steakhouse, you can enjoy a delicious, cruelty-free meal. 🌱✨ Thank you CW Prime, well done!“

“Stayed in and ate here on a Tuesday night. I just got a salad and came out quick. The place really got busy, and Paul could hardly keep up. They really need a second person for these busy times as there was always someone waiting at the counter or on their food.Ate here again and pizza was very fast!“

“Great facilities, location and staff.“

“We dined here a few days ago, and WOW, the food was amazing! I had the maple-glazed salmon with sweet potatoes, and it was absolutely delicious. I was equally impressed by our server, Kara. She truly went above and beyond. When I asked if the brownies had nuts, since I do not care for them, she made a point to ask if I had a peanut allergy to make sure I would be safe. It showed a level of care that you rarely see. The owner also stopped by our table to greet us, which was a very nice personal touch. Between the excellent service, the quality of the food, and the owner's presence, this restaurant creates a wonderful dining experience. We will definitely be returning again and again!“

“The best dining restaurant in sarasota florida me and my family went this past Christmas we love the food the drinks and the live music and bartenders and waitress are so charming we love this place wow 🌴🇺🇸😘🌞“

“Great experience at Culver’s! From the moment we walked in, everything was welcoming and very well organized. I especially want to mention ANA, who took our order — she was incredibly friendly, attentive, and patient, and made the whole experience even better. The entire team was polite, professional, and worked together perfectly. The restaurant was very clean, the atmosphere was pleasant, and the food was absolutely delicious and fresh. We will definitely be coming back. Thank you to ANA and the whole Culver’s team for such excellent service!“

“Amanda is absolutely amazing!! Always have a great time when she’s our server“

“Love this place. Great live music.“

“Nice atmosphere & food was delicious“