Tally Fish House & Oyster Bar
CLOSED$$ •
About Tally Fish House & Oyster Bar
Recent Reviews
We visited Tallahassee for a quick 24 hours and had the opportunity to visit Tally Fish House with family. Our server was attentive & accommodating and the food was very good. We will visit again when in town.
I love this place! They cooked everything just the way I like it. The manager and the staff checked on us as they went by. Kept the water glasses full. Have enjoyed this place several times even though I live in Crawfordville. Ross - Silverado Band
One of the best experiences I've had in a long time at a restaurant! Great food, awesome atmosphere & customer service. Will definitely be visiting more often.
Tally Fish House & Oyster Bar offers a great selection of beer and a welcoming atmosphere. Customers appreciate the $1.00 oysters on Tuesdays and the kid-friendly Thursday nights with free meals for children. The seafood dishes, including broiled salmon and coconut shrimp, are praised as incredible, though some guests have noted that the food can be good but not always great. The service is reported to be good, with some standout experiences like the phenomenal bartender, Sean.
The restaurant features daily specials, with Thursday being all-you-can-eat shrimp and half-price wine, beer, and mixed drinks during happy hour from 3-7 PM. Guests enjoy the perfectly fried shrimp, which have a fresh taste and great texture, along with sides like slaw and hushpuppies. The cheese grits are made with coarse country grits and are flavorful, although some customers have experienced inconsistencies with their orders. The restaurant has good accessibility, with parking right outside and tables spaced comfortably apart. It has had ups and downs since opening, and while many visitors have had positive experiences, some have pointed out concerns about pricing and portion sizes. Special offerings like whole Maine lobster dinners on Wednesdays for $24.99 and various bottomless mimosa options add to the appeal. Tally Fish House & Oyster Bar is a place that locals and visitors alike are encouraged to try.