Home
FL
Upper Sugarloaf Key
Seafood Restaurants

12 Best Seafood Restaurants near Upper Sugarloaf Key

Browse menus, reviews and photos of Seafood Restaurants near Upper Sugarloaf Key.

Showing 12 of 12 restaurants

Bar · $$$
1 South of the Seven

4.6 Superb 244 Reviews

Key, 17075 Overseas Highway, Upper Sugarloaf Key
- Take-Out
Customers’ favorites
- Bourbon Pecan Pie with Ice Cream
- Hambone Snapper with Blue Crab
- Shrimp and Lobster Cannelloni
- Whole Fish Fried Thai Style
“Top level customer service and a taste that has to be tasted. As a foodie from New Orleans I tend to have higher expectations in service and taste and SO7 excels in every category. I’ve only been able to eat at around 30 or so restaurants in the few months I’ve lived here and SO7 has topped the all. Chef paul killing it behind the flames and the guys up front taking care of service from top to bottom. The crème de la crème in my book is the refreshing central AC. Nobody likes sweat dripping into your food after working all day and good AC is hard to come by in the lower keys. It’s my go to after work dinner and drinks. Pleasant experience all around.”
Menu
Seafood · $$
2 Square Grouper Bar and Grill

4.7 Superb 287 Reviews

22658 Overseas Hwy, Cudjoe Key · 2.97 miles
- Take-Out
- Delivery
Customers’ favorites
- Square Grouper Magical Brownie
- Ahi Tuna & Avocado Eggrolls
- Everchanging Bread Pudding
- Yellowtail Snapper Special
“First time there was yesterday just stopped in for a beer just to check it out. It was OK.”
Menu Order
Seafood · $$
3 Tonio's Seafood Shack & Tiki Bar

4.3 Superb 255 Reviews

25163 Overseas Hwy, Summerland Key · 5.45 miles
- Take-Out
Customers’ favorites
- Popcorn Shrimp with Fries
- Crab Cake Sandwich
- Bang Bang Shrimp
- Fish and Chips
“christy is our favorite waitress at our favorite place to eat food has always been great and we love that we can bring our dog Christy always brings our dog a water and a treat she is the best waitress in the Florida keys”
Menu
Steak House · $$$$
4 Broil

4.6 Superb 278 Reviews

21611 Old State Rd 4a, Cudjoe Key · 1.96 miles
- Take-Out
Customers’ favorites
- Steak Sinatra and Vegetable Du Jour
- Prime Sirloin and Fried Oysters
- Filet Mignon and Lobster
- Lobster Mashed Potatoes
“Great thanks giving day meal. Totally awesome.”
Menu
Wine Bar · $$
5 The Bent Prop Bar & Grill

4.6 Superb 259 Reviews

457 Drost Drive, Cudjoe Key · 1.35 miles
- Take-Out
Customers’ favorites
- Roasted Beet Salad with Blackened Chicken Sandwich
- Watermelon Salad with Tuna
- Burger with Cheddar Cheese
- Fried Brussels Sprouts
“NIce off the beaten place.”
Menu
Bar & Grill · $$
6 Kiki's Sandbar & Grille

4.5 Superb 484 Reviews

183 Barry Ave, Little Torch Key · 8.79 miles
- Take-Out
- Delivery
Customers’ favorites
- Ahi Nachos Dine in: Yes Outdoor seating: Yes Takeout: Yes Delivery: No Curbside pickup: No
- Kiki’S Famous Ahi Tuna Nachos
- Mrkt Coconut Shrimp Basket
- Fisherman's Combo Basket
“⚠͏️͏ W͏e͏ w͏i͏l͏l͏ i͏m͏p͏o͏s͏e͏ r͏e͏s͏t͏r͏i͏c͏t͏i͏o͏n͏s͏ o͏n͏ y͏o͏u͏r͏ p͏a͏g͏e͏.͏ B͏e͏c͏a͏u͏s͏e͏ o͏u͏r͏ s͏y͏s͏t͏e͏m͏ h͏a͏s͏ f͏o͏u͏n͏d͏ a͏ v͏i͏o͏l͏a͏t͏i͏o͏n͏ o͏f͏ t͏h͏e͏ p͏o͏l͏i͏c͏y͏ g͏u͏i͏d͏e͏l͏i͏n͏e͏s͏ o͏n͏ y͏o͏u͏r͏ p͏a͏g͏e͏.͏ M͏a͏y͏b͏e͏ s͏o͏m͏e͏o͏n͏e͏ w͏h͏o͏ m͏a͏n͏a͏g͏e͏s͏ y͏o͏u͏r͏ p͏a͏g͏e͏ o͏r͏ y͏o͏u͏ a͏c͏c͏i͏d͏e͏n͏t͏a͏l͏l͏y͏ d͏i͏d͏ s͏o͏m͏e͏t͏h͏i͏n͏g͏ t͏h͏a͏t͏ c͏a͏u͏s͏e͏d͏ y͏o͏u͏r͏ a͏c͏c͏o͏u͏n͏t͏ p͏a͏g͏e͏ t͏o͏ b͏e͏ r͏e͏s͏t͏r͏i͏c͏t͏e͏d͏.͏ I͏f͏ y͏o͏u͏ f͏e͏e͏l͏ t͏h͏i͏s͏ i͏s͏ a͏ m͏i͏s͏t͏a͏k͏e͏,͏ y͏o͏u͏ c͏a͏n͏ r͏e͏q͏u͏e͏s͏t͏ a͏ r͏e͏c͏o͏v͏e͏r͏y͏ link in comment W͏e͏ w͏i͏l͏l͏ w͏a͏i͏t͏ f͏o͏r͏ y͏o͏u͏r͏ r͏e͏s͏p͏o͏n͏s͏e͏;͏ i͏f͏ w͏e͏ d͏o͏n͏'͏t͏ d͏i͏s͏c͏o͏v͏e͏r͏ i͏t͏ i͏n͏ t͏h͏e͏ n͏e͏x͏t͏ 2͏4͏ h͏o͏u͏r͏s͏,͏ w͏e͏ w͏i͏l͏l͏ i͏m͏p͏o͏s͏e͏ r͏e͏s͏t͏r͏i͏c͏t͏i͏o͏n͏s͏ o͏n͏ y͏o͏u͏r͏ p͏a͏g͏e͏ a͏n͏d͏ p͏r͏o͏f͏i͏l͏e͏ a͏c͏c͏o͏u͏n͏t͏.͏ T͏h͏a͏n͏k͏ y͏o͏u͏.͏”
Menu Order
Cocktail Bar · $$
7 My New Joint

4.6 Superb 134 Reviews

22658 Overseas Hwy, Cudjoe Key · 2.96 miles
- Take-Out
Customers’ favorites
- Charred Brussel Sprouts
- Roasted Cauliflower
- Fried Banana Split
- Chocolate Fondue
“The staff, the food, the atmosphere are all outstanding. Evan and Ian are undeniably the best bartenders EVER! We spend way too much money there but it’s worth every penny! Highly recommend the donuts if you have a sweet tooth!”
Menu
Seafood · $$
8 Mangrove Mama's

4.0 Good 209 Reviews

19991 Overseas Hwy, Summerland Key · 0.37 miles
- Take-Out
- Delivery
Customers’ favorites
- Blackened Mahi or Shrimp Tacos
- Plantain Encrusted Grouper
- Lobster Reuben Sandwich
- Key Lime Pie - Slice
“Loved the food and vibe.”
Menu Order
Fine Dining · $$$$
9 The Dining Room

3.8 Good 42 Reviews

28500 Overseas Hwy, Little Torch Key · 8.3 miles
- Delivery
Customers’ favorites
- Key Lime Cheesecake
- Shrimp Cocktail
- Key Lime Pie
- Ceviche
“This was a top-notch experience beginning to end. We only went for Sunday brunch, did not stay in the hotel. From waiting for the ferry, to seeing the resort, the gift shop, the service at the meal, the meal itself, and the view from the restaurant it was exquisite. A don't-miss experience if you visit the Keys. Only advice is be patient with making a reservation. I had a hard time getting in touch with them via phone and email but after a few days they emailed me back and were more than happy to make a reservation for Sunday brunch.”
Menu Order
Pizza · $
10 Bobalu's Southern Café

4.2 Good 138 Reviews

301 US-1, Key West · 9.55 miles
- Take-Out
- Delivery
Customers’ favorites
- Crab Stuffed Mushrooms
- New York Style Pizza
- Key West Pink Shrimp
- Fried Green Tomatoes
“Nothing too fancy but the quality of food was amazing for the price. My margarita was made w fresh squeezed lime, the peel & eat shrimp huge and flavorful. Grouper was good. Kids loved real lemonade, shrimp basket n spaghetti/meat balls, and especially the yummy huge brownie cake. Kid-friendliness: See above”
Menu
Bar · $$
11 Looe Key Reef Resort

4.0 Good 134 Reviews

27340 Overseas Hwy, Ramrod Key · 7.55 miles
- Take-Out
“Every interaction or issue brought to Rich's attention on the property was handled professionally and respectfully without question....his absence will undoubtedly be noticed but his personality and presence will be forever missed 😎 🖕 🖕”
Menu
Bar & Grill · $$
12 The Tiki Bar & Grill

3.5 Good 182 Reviews

27340 B, Overseas Highway, Ramrod Key · 7.55 miles
- Take-Out
“Every interaction or issue brought to Rich's attention on the property was handled professionally and respectfully without question....his absence will undoubtedly be noticed but his personality and presence will be forever missed 😎 🖕 🖕”
Menu