6 Best Caterers near Winter Park

John Michael Catering and Weddings Caterers • $$
1836 Crandon Ave, Winter Park

“My husband and I had John Michael be our vendor for our 10/15 wedding at the Harry P. Leu Gardens. To start off Brian was amazing to speak to throughout the process in the beginning.The food tastings were very warm and welcoming. The staff was always phenomenal whenever we went to the events and the food was just pristine. The wedding guests LOVED the beef brisket and the Tuscan Chicken was my absolute favorite. We hired an officiant, DJ, and a last minute day of coordinator through them as well. DJ was amazing fun, and meshed with the crowd, he was so polite and full of energy. We couldn't have asked for anyone else! The only issue we truly came across was our officiant. We were in contact with the officiant the entire time and yet somehow she seemed to delete our wedding off of her schedule. Well that was the excuse that was given to us. When we were finished and ready and I was waiting to line up and have my bridesmaids ready. Our coordinator, Giselle, comes over to me and tells me that somehow the officiant was not there. I did my best to keep calm but I was extremely livid. My now husband and Giselle both had to call her to ask her where she was. She was still home when she answered. She was over an hour late and made us have to rush through the ceremony and make us have to shorten our schedule of the cocktail hour and also shortened my photographers original time. When the time came Giselle was phenomenal and was to figure out a way to give my photographer an extra hour and was extremely professional during the situation. We knew what the officiant did is not the fault of the caterer whatsoever, but it was embarrassing for me, my family, and I couldn't help but also feel bad for the staff if they had any troubles when this occurred. But with Giselles quick action and the team that was provided to us it definitely saved the rest of the day. After the ceremony it was smooth sailing. Thank you John Michael for being our vendors for our special day. You were professional, kind and made everyone enjoy the rest of the day when there was a hiccup during the beginning of the day. 10/10 would recommend for any event!!!“

4.8 Superb76 Reviews
Aloha Productions Luau Caterers • $$
3592 Aloma Ave, Winter Park

“We were very impressed with the Longwood Luau and how well and organized the event was as well as impressed by the kindness of all the event planners“

4.9 Superb25 Reviews
Cuisiniers Catered Cuisine & Events Caterers •
5470 Lake Howell Rd, Winter Park

“I was having trouble finding someone to cater my casual wedding reception at Rockpit brewery. After experiencing Cuisiniers at a charity event a few weeks prior I reached out to them. Within a day they confirmed they could help me out and whipped up a menu in my budget. The food was amazing — people commented a lot on the salad and the little chicken salad biscuits. Staff was very good and friendly. Great communication. Would 100% hire them again!“

4.7 Superb24 Reviews
4 Rivers Catering Caterers • $$
2810 W Kennedy Blvd, Orlando

“Sarah and the entire 4Rivers team was so amazing to work with!! From coordinating our tasting(and last minute getting us a dessert sampler) to the day of execution, everything was absolutely perfect. The food was so amazing we barely had any leftovers when the night was over. The mac and cheese bar was worth every penny!! Our guests were OBSESSED and are still talking about it after the fact. Sarah answered every email/phone call so fast and was incredibly helpful. If you want a stress free planning process for catering and bar service 4Rivers is it!!“

4.3 Superb50 Reviews
Black Tie Catering Caterers • $$$
501 W Fairbanks Ave, Winter Park

“Luis the Chef and Owner is amazing. Just went to a wedding and the food was amazing! Staff was very kind. The owner was also serving and ensuring everyone got what they wanted and needed. Super kind, and again amazing food!!! I can’t wait to use them at our next big event!!“

5 Superb5 Reviews
Tibby's New Orleans Kitchen Cajun • $$
2203 Aloma Ave, Winter Park

Customers` Favorites

Jambalaya Crawfish Pie & Chicken Filé Gumbo
Half 12 Napkin Roast Beef & Gumbo
Shrimp & Andouille Cheddar Grits
Half Fried Shrimp PO Boy & Gumbo
Chicken & Andouille Filé Gumbo
Walter’S Spicy Southern Club
Shrimp & Alligator Cheesecake
Beignets with Brandy Sauce
Etouffee Shrimp or Crawfish
Country Fried Pork Chops

“Today we came in and had an early dinner. We are visiting the area while my husband works disaster relief. This was my favorite dining experience here. Hands down. We had the pleasure of being served by Tyrese . I ordered half muffuletta that was so huge I couldn’t even take down half of a half! My husband ordered Blackened Chicken served over grit cakes…. Everything that came to our table was nothing short of perfect. Tyrese was very pleasant and informative on the menu. We 10 out of 10 recommend. Thank you for the great service .“

4.6 Superb345 Reviews

Enjoy More Tastes In Winter Park