50 Best Ice Cream Shops near Brookhaven

“The custard is always great BUT the Oreo ice cream cake is phenomenal. If I could leave this place 10 stars I would. The entire group said it was the best ice cream cake they’ve ever had!! Thanks for being the best and most consistent dessert venue! Highly recommended 💯“

“Such a great ice cream shop. Look close you'll almost miss it, but it's so good there were people waiting outside to get in. LOL The flavors were incredible and the best vegan Ice cream I've had. Thank you.“

“Went there tonight. Wife had a custom banana pecan and I had there peanut butter special. They were not amazing 🤩“

“I was going to give four stars because they were out of fudge dipped waffle bowls and only had the Halloween themed overly sprinkled waffle bowls HOWEVER she made a mistake and thought I wanted the fudge dipped waffle cone which I didn’t, but I became a fan of the fudge dipped waffle cone on this night so all is well lol“

“I highly recommend this ice cream bar! From the moment I arrived, I received a warm and welcoming greeting. Since it was my first visit, the staff took the time to explain the menu and share details about the offerings and the neighborhood. They provide both soft serve and vegan ice cream options. I chose the coconut soft serve in a matcha waffle cone, which was absolutely delicious! I can't wait to return for the ginger beer float—yes, you read that correctly! I plan to use the coconut ice cream for that as well.“

“Awesome Ice Cream. Period. 👍👍👍“

“This place is a gem. I stumbled upon it as I was grub hubbing and couldn’t leave because the smell of goodness grabbed my nose and wouldn’t let it go, lol. The owner is a beautiful soul and the ice cream is the BEST I ever had!!!!! Swear!!!!“

“buy local, the ice cream is 👍“

“This is always a wonderful treat! Just had Gingerbread and White Chocolate Peppermint! Excellent on their own, and even more amazing mixed in the same cup! The fire pit was warming up the courtyard, so it’s ready for the cooler weather!“

“My family loves this place! Very few places are able to make great ice cream AND great boba but Roll-O-Coaster does! So far everything we’ve tried, we’ve liked but my absolute favorites are the Matcha ice cream as well as the Thai Tea with regular boba. The owners and family are awesome too. Highly recommend!!“

“I've been coming to this ice cream shop for more than 5 years now and every time, their flavors are as fresh and delicious as the very first time. Consistency and quality shines through, and it’s clear that the team behind the counter takes great pride in their craft.

If you haven’t yet visited this gem, I highly recommend stopping by, you'll become a regular, just like me!“

“Our favorite date night dessert spot. The. Best. Gelato. PERIODT!!!“

“Absolutely delicious strawberry ice cream i’m waffle cone 👌🏾“

“I had an amazing experience with the Glaciers Italian Ice Boys it’s black owned the flavors are GREAT and I love the way he helps out the community and young men around I most definitely will support again“

“I think the size I order is considered a pint. I got butter pecan with extra, extra, extra pecans! The man who took my order was so kind and had the most pleasant smile. He was so considerate with asking how far did I have to travel and when I told him the distance, he wrapped my container of ice cream up nicely in Saran wrap and advised me to put it in the freezer as soon as I reached home. I should have left a tip, but I usually don’t leave tips for to go service. I will be back there again and if he’s there I will leave a tip, because of all the times I’ve ordered my ice cream, no one has gone above and beyond like he did. Thank you for your thoughtfulness!“

“Their ice cream is AMAZING, and they are amazing to work with!! They were a hit at our daughter’s wedding this past Saturday, the hottest day of the year so far. Thank you so much for everything you did to make the process seamless.“

“Absolutely delicious strawberry ice cream i’m waffle cone 👌🏾“

“This is my favorite ice cream spot. Please bring back the cashew ice cream!! 🥺 They have this cashew nut flavored ice cream that I enjoyed so much. It was nothing short of unique - I’ve never tasted anything like it. Unfortunately each time I go they don’t have it and I’m afraid it might not come back on the menu. Nevertheless they have lots of other unique flavors to try!“

“EXCELLENT customer service! We are on vacation and stopped in after tasting a sample. The staff was extremely friendly and treated our family very well! Seriously, over the top! We will definitely come again on our next trip. The food was also very good!“

“The Honey Vanilla Bean was very tasty and the service was excellent. Thank you Andrea for your kindness and great customer service.“

“I highly recommend trying this gelato spot. I was able to sample several flavors, and the service was excellent. The owner took the time to answer my questions and made the experience even better. I chose the pumpkin pie and pistachio flavors, and both were light and fluffy while still rich and full of flavor.“

“To be honest this place is elegant but has a refreshing Taste palate. Not only does it make you feel like your having an honest great experience 1st hand of gelato or not to mention that it's not something you'll have every day so they make the experience more desirable than anything“

“Always delicious ice cream, and it smells incredible inside with the waffle cones. 🍨“

“Unique flavors, kid friendly, stays open late but most of all the employees are awesome! #HBCUstudents“

“Waffle cones elite 💥. We love this place“

“Really tasty. We've gone to both this location and the Decatur one and been happy both times. The nondairy chocolate is especially good (and there's a good selection of both dairy and nondairy flavors). The Norcross location staff were wonderful as well.“

“Delicious!
A little over priced but thats a regular every where are increasing prices.
I got a ezquite ( corn, sour cream, mayo, lime and powder chili)
Dubai chocolate churro, ice cream. Doritos fixed with cucumbers, mango, Valentina and many other good things!
100% recommended“

“I NEEDED this treat today! New Orleans Praline Pecan ice cream for the win.“

“The gelato is amazing and the waffle cone in a cup makes it even better. The service was great. I recommend coming here if you want some ice cream after walking around the market. The only problem was there wasn’t much seating and we had to walk a while to find seating.“

“This Ice cream was probably the best I’ve ever had! And they had vegan options for my niece!“

“Paolo non vende solo gelato ma pasta ,salse biscotti tutto italiano e biologico …e tanto altro ancora . Per tutta la mia famiglia è un ottimo punto di riferimento ad Atlanta 👍“

“Yes interesting menu and great flavors“

“The pizza is fire!! We had the margarita, margarita w/pepperoni & the lasagna pizza. The crust is perfect! All ingredients tasted so fresh!! Best pizza in Atlanta imo. 😘“

“Absolutely incredible. The food was so fresh and delicious; you can taste it before even the first bite. A simple vanilla icecream taste so rich and decadent. I will certainly be returning-a fantastic gem.

Vegetarian options: There’s veggies, falafel, potatoes, veggie wraps, salads

Dietary restrictions: They have all types of options for vegan, vegetarian and pescatarian

Parking: Plenty of parking in the lot in front and across the store

Wheelchair accessibility: Storefront is ground level with wide spaces“

“The weather was nice, the friends were out for a stroll after a morning of volunteering, what better reasons to stop into Big Softie for a cool treat! LoL. As I walked in my senses were attacked by fresh smells of sweet cream and fresh waffle cones. To say I was instantly excited would be an understatement. I was overjoyed by the instant memories of childhood and the local ice cream parlor. The nostalgia was free with my order. Ha! Walking up to the cashier to order, the young lady was very nice and greeted me with a smile. As I was the last of the group to order I knew what I wanted. I partook in a small vanilla on a cake cone with rainbow sprinkles (jimmies where I’m from). I placed my order, provided my name, and stood to the side. Once my order was ready, my name was called and my excitement started all over again. The ice cream was perfectly sculpted. It looked as if every sprinkle was perfectly placed and the ice cream to cone ratio was perfecttttttttttttttttttt. I’m one who bites the top of the swirl off first and upon FIRST BITE… I was planning my next visit back. LoL. Fresh Ice Cream Fresh Cone Super Fresh Sprinkles And best of all, the cream to sugar ratio was algebraically perfect. It’s official. I’ll be back in two weeks for my next fix. Dare I say, Big Softie is now in my Top 5 for Ice Cream, and #1 for Soft Serve. Do yourself a favor and get you some. 🥳“

“The food and drinks were fantastic, though a bit pricey. However, their matcha ice cream machine wasn’t working after I ordered it, and no one informed me until I went to the counter to ask about my order. I was sitting there waiting for nothing.“

“LOVE this Rita’s! Barbara is awesome and was super patient with my little one in helping her decide which flavor she wanted. Custard is AMAZINGGGGG and the ice flavors are so delicious. None can compare!“

“Really great cookies! Satisfies my sweet tooth 😁“

“Visiting from Tampa. Great experience. Helpful staff, delicious treats! Had their strawberry shortcake ice cream bowl and it came with an entire slice of cheesecake in it! Delicious! Thank you!“

“Muito bom o local, milkshake de cook & cream é fantástico, vale a pena provar“

“Very tasty! Love the gelati“

“Soooo happy Andy’s is finally here! This location is clean, has friendly customer service, and the ice cream is somehow better than other locations. I can’t wait to come back :)“

“Be prepared for a long line, but my partner and I love this place because their flavors are always interesting and yummy, and they have multiple options that are simultaneously dairy free and gluten free, and one is real ice cream (not sorbet!!!).“

“More than perfect experience. They were so kind. All smiles when I walked in. Sanaii was so sweet giving great customer service and the GM was just as kind. Thank you all for making my experience a great one. Loving River Street Sweets in Atlanta!“

“All natural flavors make me crazy. Thanks being in Atlanta.“

“After doctor, went here for a panini and iced mocha, so delicious and such friendly workers! 10/10“

“Mocha Pops are to LIVE for!! Absolutely deliciously made, juicy, and flavorful!! Beyond Beyond! My first experience was several years ago at an event. I saw this 3 year old with a juicy red popsicle with melting popsicle on his face and shirt. I inquired. He pointed to MOCHA POPS… so a tasty love affair began! So many choices! Truly the best popsicle ever!“

“I love this place Good stuff Thanks 🙏“

“Fave ice cream and buttery fresh baked cones/shells since first visit in ATL 11 years ago! They taste like they smell! Tried opaque tonight and it was delightful! So happy to have closer to home in SC!“

“Super Clean spot! Ice cream is house made and perfectly balance for flavor and sweetness. I hate ice cream that be extra sweet and barely taste the flavor. This is authentic. I love to have Bionicos, mix of fruits cover in a sweet milk mixture w shd coconut, granola, and rasins. Everything is yummy and there is one girl who is the nicest. Love it here“