12 Best American Restaurants in Madison

1 The Dining Room

5.0 Superb 45 Reviews

146 East Washington Street, Madison

• Delivery

“Every single bite is astounding — a great bar. I’ve never tried steak tartare before, but this looked like the place to try it. Sprinkled with a variety of herbs, topped by a quail egg 🤌 The executive chef changes the menu every week — within the area of Madison, Monroe, and Covington, it’s rare for a menu to change in 6 months. This is the finest, high-end dining experience I’ve ever had.”

2 Town 220 Restaurant

4.6 Superb 267 Reviews

220 West Washington Street, Madison

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“We had a rehearsal dinner for Giovanni and Natalie Taddei,the service was excellent and the food was very delicious ,thank you!!”

3 Farmview Cafe

4.3 Superb 177 Reviews

2610 Eatonton Road, Madison

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“I look forward to stopping here anytime I’m in the area! I wish I had a location near me! Great selection of local produce and prepared foods, plus unique items. I always get some of the vegetable soup, collards, and pimento cheese to take home. And the meals from the Chef’s Farm Table are out of this world!”

4 Crowe's Open Air Bar-B-Que & Catering

4.6 Superb 239 Reviews

1320 Eatonton Road, Madison

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Great Food, Friendly Staff, and awesome specials each week!!!”

5 Original Scoops Madison

4.6 Superb 126 Reviews

123 West Washington Street, Madison

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“The staff was friendly, welcoming, and provided excellent service. They have delicious milkshakes and ice cream, and the child-friendly atmosphere made it a great place for families. Our family had a wonderful time, and we'll definitely be back!”

6 Madison Drug LLC

4.5 Superb 101 Reviews

213 North Main Street, Madison

• Take-Out

“Went there to pick up paper towels while on vacation. I just so happened to have an ingrown toenail so I asked the lady cashing me out if they advised anything. She asked the pharmacist who not only recommended local places I can go, but gave me a card telling me if I get there soon she will get it filled right away for me. What an awesome experience. Can’t say enough nice things about ALL the employees there. Will be back next vacation! Awesome, awesome, awesome!”

7 Lollipops Grill

4.5 Superb 17 Reviews

213 North Main Street, Madison

“Amazing food and staff! I brought friends from out of town and they are asking when we can have lunch again there. Thank you Leslie, you always have a smile that warms my heart!”

8 Captain D's

4.0 Good 216 Reviews

1910 Eatonton Road, Madison

• Delivery

“The food was great. The catfish I thought would be that mud like taste so I only got one piece, but it wasn’t and it was great very flaky and flavorful. I haven’t been to captain d in years. So I expected the taste to be different and poor flavor. Cod, okra and corn was really good. But I also tried the funnel cake stixs with sugar, I loved those. I also want to think the staff their were pleasant and fast with the order. I came on a Sunday when they first opened 9/6/26. Thank u for my making my experience so great.”

9 Cracker Barrel Old Country Store

3.8 Good 588 Reviews

2003 Eatonton Road, Madison

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Recently had a family reunion at Hard Labor State Park had Cracker Barrel Carter the event. Food was delivered in timely manner, food was excellent, didn't the first complaint, only problem turned out to be to many left overs because of no shows. Would highly recommend Cracker Barrel as the caterer for an upcoming event.”

10 Waffle House

3.8 Good 231 Reviews

1941 US-441, Madison

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Great staff. Thank you for taking care of us”

11 Madison Chophouse Grille

3.9 Good 471 Reviews

202 South Main Street, Madison

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Great service and food, I always eat there when in town. I highly recommend! I give them 5-stars”

12 Waffle House

3.6 Good 194 Reviews

2050 Eatonton Road, Madison

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Everyone was very nice and the food was delicious”