17 Best American Restaurants in Milledgeville

“This has quickly become one of my favorite places to settle in, exhale, and let the words flow. Whether I’m dreaming up something new for Quill of His Will or picking back up with a project already in progress, it’s the perfect little spot to write, think, and create.
The tea is always delicious, the lemons are plentiful, which matters more than people realize, and my glass is never empty. Alisha has a gift for reading her customers. She knows when you’re ready for a little conversation and when you’re deep in thought and need to be left alone with your words. That kind of hospitality is a gift.
And the food? Listen. My favorite is the tomato basil soup paired with the Grilled Cheese Cheeseburger, four slices of American cheese, tangy bacon sauce, and a juicy beef burger tucked between freshly toasted potato bread. But apparently I believe in eating dessert first, because the Triple Chocolate Meltdown made a perfectly respectable appetizer.
Good food, wonderful service, endless tea, plenty of lemons, and a comfortable place for creativity to flow. Quill of His Will officially approves.“

“Met our future son in law for dinner. There was only 1 server working tonight and she was running the best she could. She did keep our drinks refilled, so she gets an A.

The chicken tenders that 2 of us ordered were good. I opted for Salad Bar special. Loaded Potato soup was good, but the bowl was barely half full. The restaurant was not very busy and there were multiple items that were out on the salad bar. Never saw them put eggs out at all, along with 2 of the salads.

I hope everybody eating there tonight tipped the server well. She was doing her best, being there by herself.“

“I selected that I would recommend The Buff BUT I came here to say I had the worst meal there yesterday. I love their burgers and sweet potato fries among other menu items. I go there fairly often. Had a delicious burger two weeks ago. Yesterday the burger was dry and I think it had been cooked a while before I ordred it. Did not complain since main concern was the sweet potato fries. Ate burger since I was hungry. The fries , each one, were burned. Therefore they were tough and inedible. Literal black on ends and the sides of each one. She brought a "fresh batch" when I complained. They were still hard but main issue was they were LOADED with salt. I can eat salty food but these were also inedible. I asked her to take upgrade charge of $2 off fries and after consulting someone she did remove the charge. My lunch companion's food (which included regular fries) were fine along with the fried pickles appetizer. I was very disappointed and no effort from anyone there to apologize or offer any explantion.“

“Amazing food, incredible pricing, outstanding service (ask for Alyssa) has made this our new date night favorite. The steaks are out of this world and the best in town!“

“I got to go to Country Buffet today!!Since I moved to another town, I hardly ever get the chance..It did NOT disappoint.This place has the best "Soul Food".Thursday is actually my favorite day, and today is Wednesday, but I wouldn't get another chance tomorrow.. If you enjoy country food, in a cafeteria style setting..Stop by..“

“Food was great. The Philly cheesesteak eggroll was amazing. The honey lemon pepper wings were too! Fries are what you are expecting. The front register person was not very personable. She let my food sit out after being ready for a while and was on her phone instead of calling my name and telling me it was ready. Usually don't care, but I have a limited lunch time. Otherwise, delicious food.“

“I’m gonna tell y’all what. This place is so good. I live an hour and a half away and drove to Milledgeville for the day. As someone who normally eats the Mediterranean diet due to health reasons, I was concerned about what I was going to eat for the day and we chose this restaurant. They have so many options depending on what type of food you’re looking for. I had the seafood basket with blackened shrimp and fish with the power veggies, and it was delicious. Can’t wait to go back and eat here again.“

“I'm always satisfied with my order from AJ's! Wings are tastee! !!!“

“Fantastic Mgr Fantastic food Fantastic service Fantastic Food“

“Great service! Loved the Buffalo Chicken Dip! The Hogzilla and Gourmet White Calzones were so good!“

“Our family dined here after the Georgia College December Commencement Ceremony 11 Dec 2021. Yes, it was packed! BUT, what I remember most is the PREMIER service received from Manager Jeremy Polack! Saluting Mr. Polack and his amazing team of professionals for their awesome energy, commitment to Service Excellence and delectable dishes! Thank you for adding to our new memories. -Bwell- #StayImpactful“

“I’m from Illinois just moved to the area came here 8/18/22 in search of some good home cooked /soul food it definitely hit my soul I highly recommend you try this restaurant I even doubled back for round 2 I appreciate good service and food“

“Food was great! Except... I Ordered the 3 for me deal... Do not ask for butter without first checking to make sure it's just butter... I received garlic butter and it ruined my entire meal. I mentioned it to the waitress and all she said was... I'm sorry! Then that made it my worst meal for the day!“

“Be helpful if they actually get a cook , that knows how to cook and prepare eggs . I mean, it's basic cooking skills 101. If you can't properly prepare an egg , then you don't need to work at a place that sells the majority of breakfast style meals“

“Absolutely my favorite waffle house, Ann and Hailey are hilarious people and the rest of the staff is extremely freindly and made jokes with me and my family made us feel like family, food also since I guess that is important is absolutely delcious as usual love it! Thanks again Hailey!“

“Good food, fast service, great sids“

“The atmosphere was good and our server John was very good. My only complaint is that I paid extra for queso to dip my fries in and it was barely any at all plus it had hardened cheese on top like it hadnt been stirred before being given. It was a 2oz cup that barely even had an ounce in it. Otherwise it was fine“