23 Best Pizza Restaurants near Carlisle

“Our pizza was top notch tonight!! We were even lucky enough to get a delivery from the Big Boss himself!!“

“First time at Pete’s Pizza and we loved it! The thin crust was perfection and a real frosty mug … swoon worthy.“

“Love Truman’s! They hosted us last night for my birthday celebration and they did not disappoint. They never do! The food alone is delicious, their menu has something for everyone, plus some unique pizzas that I have tried to replicate. (Theirs was better 😉) Their service is always great too. Friendly staff, always helpful, and the dude who hosted our party of 26 last night was awesome and made sure we all had a great experience and had what we needed throughout our time there. Thanks for helping make my celebration so special Truman’s! I’ll be back soon!“

“stopped by on Saturday and loved the atmosphere. clean, friendly, outgoing. food was good. had a calzone, stromboli, and onion rings. decent prices for the amount of food. we had to take some home. all good , for dinner. our waitress was Baylee, very nice, helpful, and attentive young lady. DEFINITELY RECOMMEND.“

“The service was amazing. The place was clean and decorated so cool. Options to buy by the slice or order off the menu. Outside and inside seating. We had the Chinese moz sticks and the loaded potato pizza and both were SO fire! If we ever come back to town we will definitely be back!“

“We heard many good things about their Pie…we were in town & decided to stop…we ordered a 1/2 & 1/2 & both choices were excellent…our waitress as well was very friendly & never missed a beat…we will definitely be a return customer!…“

“I REALLY LIKE WINN'S. HAVE BEEN GETTING FOOD FROM THERE FOR YEARS AND HAVE NEVER HAD A BAD EXPERIENCE. GREAT PEOPLE TO BE ASSOCAITED WITH. THANKS TO ALL OF YOU AT WINN,S“

“This might be the greatest place I’ve ever been. I’m not kidding….“

“On December 20th, 2025, at 6:58pm, I ordered a large hawiaan pizza and two orders of breadsticks for delivery. I was told 1 to 1 and a half hours at 1 hour 50 minutes I called to find out where our food was. I was told that they tried to deliver our food but were unable to deliver our order but they could not do so. I then asked why it was unable to be delivered and "the manager" stated that they tried to call me, no one ever did call me and I can prove it. The "manager" could not provide a reason the order was undeliverable. I then told them that my husband would be coming to pick it up and that they needed to make it right by refunding part of our order NOT all just part of it for the inconvience (not being nasty at all). The "manager" stated "I am canceling your order. Go somewhere else." When asked why he said "You are being rude." I told him he had poor customer service skills and hung up. My husband and I ended up going to the Altoona Northern lights and they went above and beyond for us. I will always go to the Altoona store over Hubbell. I highly recommend that you do not go to this store unless you want to be treated like crap.“

“My biggest problem with Northern lights is that they deliver it fast so it always arrives hot. It also never gives me indigestion so they must use good ingredients. This has made me addicted to their pizzas. In fact writing this review I suddenly want one. And it is 9:30am. Damn you Northern Lights!“

“Good friendly service,very clean atmosphere and food is delicious 😋❤️“

“Came to Des Moines for the home show and thought we would have an early lunch. We were not disappointed as the service and food were top notch. Service was perfect as they were attentive but not bothersome. We will be back for sure. Thanks to the Pizza Bar“

“first time there. I spent New Year’s eve night there. Fantastic food great drinks great service great people. HIGHLY RECOMMEND! I think jay is his name. Great bartender. All I know is if you haven’t gone…you’re missing out!“

“We wish you a merry Christmas miss you we enjoy being with are children in Arizona but miss all you and your kindness want to say merry Christmas blessings to you and your family“

“So far I’ve only had the sugar cookies and I’m in love. I guess that’s why they are called Love Drops 😍😂 Great customer service as well! 10/10 would recommend 👍🏼👍🏼“

“My family loves Scornovacca’s. Been going there for years. Great food and great friendly service. One of the best pizzas in town!“

“We stopped here quickly on our drive through the city. Food was quite good and also reasonably priced. Restaurant looked clean, and service was friendly. Easy vegan options are much appreciated. So glad we decided to eat here instead of the usual fast food place we were considering.“

“Best spot in the neighborhood💯🖤“

“I’ve loved Paul Revere’s since as long as I can remember. Pizza is always fresh, hot and delicious! I tried the new BBQ chicken and bacon last night and of course the garlic breadsticks - AMAZING!!“

“shout out to my Dominos y'all always do me right. food is delicious hot and reasonable! The Whitney family thanks u. Khloe our four year old loves Joel! 💙💜 we appreciate u! shout out to Kevin I believe it was the prepared our food cuz its fire AS ALWAYS! AGAIN THANK YOUV“

“This is a good experience overall for bulk flour delivery. It does take a bit longer than preferred to get authorized for delivery, however, the fast unload time makes up for it. My favorite thing is one usually overlooked, and that is access to a outhouse; now running water would be better, but I'll take it and be happy.“

“Everything I have ordered here has been amazing! Best pizza place hands down for my family and I. Thank you for always being cheerful, and courteous!“

“So om stuck in a hotel and havent eaten so i called pizza hut starving not knowing if i was in range for delievery and jamie was super helful and attentive. And when I realized i was in the wrong spot i called and spoke with the lovely manager amber went above and beyond to help me and made me a very happy customer tonight.“