23 Best Bakeries near Garden City

“I love Acme Bakeshop! Their sourdough bread is my favorite - fluffy and delicious. I frequently buy loaves at the Co-Op and they are always high quality. I have also gone through the bakery for their holiday orders and the process was easy with no issues for pick-up. Their ciabatta rolls and cranberry sourdough loaf are amazing seasonal items I love having at family gatherings during the holidays. I'm happy I get to support a local business that consistently bakes the best bread!“

“A hidden treasure, excellent baked empanadas with a delicious and wide range of fillings. Nice wine and beer selection too. The atmosphere is relaxed and service excellent. Highly recommended and hope to see them prosper. Since the Kiwi shake and bake shut, I’ve felt a little lost.. hopefully we can watch rugby here too!“

“Nice local bakery I like to support. Pies are their strength, both fruit and cream pies. Fillings are plentiful and locally sourced. I hate to admit their rolls and bread items need improvement. Simply put, they taste as if they had no salt added. Bland. Salt is essential in order to make flavors really great. I don’t know why the lack of salt, but it’s why the rolls aren’t excellent.“

“I ordered a cake for my mom's birthday and it was absolutely gorgeous. My mom was thrilled with it and the taste was to die for. I'll be ordering again for sure.“

“Always a great experience here! The customer service is top-notch everyone’s friendly and welcoming from the moment you walk in. Orders are always ready quickly, and the cookies? Always fresh, warm, and delicious. It’s the kind of place that keeps you coming back!“

“EXCELLENT. . . This donut shop is the best in Eagle! Everything is so fresh. Their donuts, eclairs, and smoothies are amazing. I definitely recommend this donut shop 1000%…. Must try. 5⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️“

“Our little Remi loved his cake! They were super easy to work with and was able to get it done for us within a week! Will definitely order more cakes from them in the future! 🩵“

“Bluesky Bagels is hands down the BEST hidden gem in town. Not only are the bagels fresh, soft, and ridiculously delicious, but the prices are unbeatable — where else can you snag two whole bags for around $3.50? 🤯 Every time I walk in, the place smells like heaven, the staff is friendly and welcoming, and I leave wondering why I ever bought bagels anywhere else. Honestly, grocery store bagels don’t even compare — these taste like they were made with actual love. 🥯💙 If you haven’t been here yet, do yourself a favor: stop what you’re doing and go. Your mornings (and your toaster) will thank you.“

“This is the only cafe in the US that I have been to that makes pastries as well as they do in Europe. The quality and presentation are amazing, and the staff are very kind. I tried the lavender latte which was wonderful, and I will definitely be back to try their other amazing drinks and pastries :)“

“I went for the second time 10/15 around 9pm and the lady was great! Patient, helpful, and had some good conversation. Wish I had gotten her name to add but she was fantastic. The cookies were great and we left with smiles on our faces. Great place to check out!“

“I wanted a sweet treat so my daughter and I made our way to Crumbl. This shop is conveniently down the road from us. I have frequented the Franklin location a few times but finally made it to the one closest to me in my area.

I did check out the the cookie options online and noticed they have the Dubai chocolate cookie as an option. I was sold! I never got a chance to try the Dubai cookie the previous time they had it so I was looking forward to trying it. There were also some other great options so I was excited to get my 4 pack.

Each Crumbl location looks consistent with each other. The cookies they had on display all looked fabulous. The cookies looked better on display than online. Trying to choose 4 was hard. But I went with the Dubai chocolate, Oreo, brownie batter and the chunky chocolate chip.

My 4 pack looked divine! All my cookies looked so good in my pink Crumbl box! I did try the Dubai and brownie batter when I got home. Both were so good! I look forward to sharing the Oreo and chocolate chip with my husband when he gets home. You can never go wrong with a classic chocolate chip cookie. And I'm sure the Oreo cookie won't disappoint either.

The staff here was a smidge friendlier than the Franklin location. They greeted us as soon as we walked in. The gal that handed me my box was nice. But that was all the interaction we got. I just know not to expect too much from the staff. They all rely on a tablet to deliver their customer service. My only expectations from Crumbl is a good product and that was delivered. My cookies were fantastic. I look forward to seeing what kind of goodies they will have around Valentines. Hopefully there's a lot of red and pink. Red and pink makes everything taste that much better.“

“Love the pastries and atmosphere at Janjou. Owners are friendly and welcoming. My favorite place to go for pastries.“

“Bluesky Bagels is hands down the BEST hidden gem in town. Not only are the bagels fresh, soft, and ridiculously delicious, but the prices are unbeatable — where else can you snag two whole bags for around $3.50? 🤯 Every time I walk in, the place smells like heaven, the staff is friendly and welcoming, and I leave wondering why I ever bought bagels anywhere else. Honestly, grocery store bagels don’t even compare — these taste like they were made with actual love. 🥯💙 If you haven’t been here yet, do yourself a favor: stop what you’re doing and go. Your mornings (and your toaster) will thank you.“

“We only buy our bread here, Every week plus cookies, blondies, chocolate cake, brownies, muffins, cinnamon rolls. It’s always a treat. Buy sandwiches occasionally.“

“Delicious!! Not a single crumb left.“

“I recently ordered my baby's first birthday cake from this talented lady, along with Cupcakes and Cake pops! I couldn't be happier! Everything was not only visually stunning but also incredibly delicious. Every layer was moist and flavorful, and it was evident that she uses high-quality ingredients. Beyond the amazing treats, the baker was an absolute pleasure to work with—so kind and accommodating. I highly recommend her for any special occasion!“

“We love Gaston's. Highly recommend! We will be back again!“

“a fantastic bakery. everything we have bought and served is fresh and amazing.Thank you“

“Very friendly people also very good food and it's a good place to learn how to make bagels“

“This is an elevated donut experience. You can tell the ingredients are quality. Their chocolate icing has a delicious and decadent dark chocolate, the fillings are rich and light. The atmosphere is a great calm cafe that has good vibes. The hot chocolate could have been a little more rich with the chocolate flavor, but the donuts are the real star of the show here, so that doesn’t matter as much. The only donut I wasn’t a huge fan of from the ones I tried was the hipsterberry, it tasted like they added lavender or something off, but otherwise we loved all the donuts we tried. If you’re looking for casual donuts, this is not that. These donuts are an elevated experience.“

“Some good bargains. Lots of 5 for and 3 for. Bread is "day-old" but still good for toast and sandwiches. The store has a "loyalty" hole punch card, where you can collect 7 punches free products. They have daily specials and military discount Wednesdays.Only problem is the customer restrooms are always "out of order" and have been since 2020! (Hmmmm! Interesting timing.....COVID 19?!!??!)“