22 Best Sandwich Shops near Caseyville

“The food is usually good but for some reason my last sandwich was soggy and I didn't even order no sauce on it so I won't be eating there again and there's a weird smell in the gas station almost like sewage but the attendant is attentive to your “

“Lovely spot Great chicken salad & soup“

“The staff is amazing. I’ve lived in the area for 2 years now and this is the best customer service that I’ve experienced since I’ve been here. Very warm welcome, very patient, and helpful. I found a new Subway after visiting 4 other stores around that were a total let “

“Everything is so fresh and always Proportioned the same every time I go there. Just delicious 🙌🏼“

“Huge shout out to the JM in Shiloh! You all are crushing it today for Special Olympics. We had a large preorder today and it was spot on prefect. Extra thanks to Daniele for always going out of her way to make sure everyone is happy!“

“Very friendly staff and amazing food always!!!!! I dropped my fries and they were amazing enough to replace with no charge!!! I insisted but the staff wouldn't let me pay!! Always friendly and so nice!!! Thank you guys as always for providing amazing service!!!“

“Updated 5/5/26 Thank you Hunter for calling me today and making this right. I don’t try to get over on anyone and only want to be treated fairly.

Update on 5/4/26 - I literally purchase sandwiches at least 2-3 times a week if not 4. Same thing, Number 8, Sub Club Mike's Way with pickles. This location is closer to me than others but they are not consistent. This time the cheese and meat were cut so thin, I couldn't taste the cheese and the meat was lost amongst the bread and vegetables. At $12 a sandwich, this is disappointing yet again.

3/25/26 I purchase sandwiches from this shop almost weekly. Today, I received the most disappointing service. The guy with the red beard and hair made like I annoyed him because I didn’t want my Mike’s Hot Italian to be heated. He said you don’t want that then, you want the regular. I said no because I want the meats and everything I just don’t want it heated because I drive 25 minutes there and back home. He throws my sandwich together by the grill where I couldn’t see. Something told me to check my food before leaving. He didn’t add the pickles, onions, or mayo but gave me wilted lettuce and soft tomatoes. He threw the pickles on, I received a side cup of onions and mayo packets. Didn’t bother to cut my sandwich either. I felt disappointed and dismissed while others after me were treated pleasantly. I’ll spend my hard earned dollars elsewhere!“

“Good and prompt service.“

“My most recent order here a bit ago was made with extra love and effort thank you to whoever made this pregnant lady an amazing sandwhich XD my son who likes black olives had to help me there were too many for me yo handle .... I think something went wrong with how I ordered tho on the app, the app didnt show all the extras I wanted so my note related to olives and mayo for the pregnant lady lead to even more extra mayo and olives than expected but other things weren't extra and the app showed everything not updated to have the extra so and so stuff .... but the sandwhich was really good and made me happy and my son and the baby baking currently“

“One of THE BEST subways to go to. The customer service is great! All the workers are kind and very polite! They always make my food perfect and I never feel rushed. Clean store, clean cold table, and they take coupons. I've gone in at lunch and I've gone in the evening and the customer service is great! One of the biggest things for me is a girl switched gloves when making my sandwich! She washed her hands and had gloves on but when she contaminated them by touching something else she immediately switched gloves. Thank you to whoever trained this worker!“

“I was in a week or so ago with my family and we are still talking about how good it was. Josh took our order and he was so kind and polite and personable. It was one of the best outings we've had all around in a while. the cooks did a great job the food was amazing, and Josh was geeat. Great team!!“

“The sandnwiches are really good. Very disappointed thst they are no longer selling flat bread at this location.. that is my breakfast go to sandwich the other breads are to much bread. Please bring back the flat bread. Si ce they didn't have flat bread anymore I didn get a sandwich.“

“I really enjoy your chicken Philly. I get it with Swiss cheese grilled onions and lettuce. But it seems when we get it to go they forget the lettuce.“

“The employees of this certain Penn Station are always so welcoming and nice, showcase a good work ethic, and are good and quick at their jobs. I’m usually not one to leave reviews but this staff is the real deal. Thank you guys for your hard work and friendly faces.“

“I can generally get in, order food, and get back out really quickly. The workers are nice and were kind to my daughter who was ordering her own sandwich for the first time. I've always found the food to be fresh and my family and I have never had any complaints.“

“People were pleasant and greeted us when we first arrived. Sandwich was made our way and correct. Sandwich had lots of meat and veggies, making it very tasty. Would recommend, plus the place is clean with seating for small and large groups.“

“I give this location a 5 star rating, The restaurant was very clean, the two gentlemen that waited on me had great teamwork and were very friendly. The food was great and the helpings of meat and toppings I felt were generous portions. Another plus for me was that the equipment in the store was well cared for. Also they asked me if I had any coupons which was a plus for me because at some different locations I felt that the use of coupons were frowned upon.
I will be continuing to use this as my main go to local location for future. Thank you to the team working and operating this location.“

“friendly people Yummy food! share if you don't like leftovers! everything we ordered was huge!!“

“I am very pleased with the service Christopher extended to us after our Sunday service. He was attentive to not only my Husband and myself, but he graciously attended to other families that were dining in the place. Our salads were delicious with fresh greens and season fruits. The Arnold Palmer was mixed just right and I will return and recommend dining in to friends and family in the area.“

“Came in to buy my 3-year-old daughter the best home cut fresh made fries around because she loves fries and as a surprise, the general manager bought. Very friendly woman working the register offered a cookie. I did leave a tip in the tip jar. This place is amazing, great food, great menu, great staff. They even have a Reuben and they're never busy. I would highly recommend to someone wanting to try something different and becoming a regular.“

“We placed an order, and they called to ket us know they just sent the driver out with a lot of orders, so it would be a little while. Due to the wait, they wanted to check if we still wanted the order or if it'd be too long. I cant express how much we appreciated that, and how thoughtful it was. Seriously. Thank you!“

“I got the Beach Club and the sand which was yummy but the cucumbers were a bit too much. The employees were awesome and freaky fast! Lol

Dietary restrictions: That have lettuce wraps and the option of removing extra bread from the inside of the loaf before they make the sandwich.“