16 Best Italian Restaurants near Yorkville

“We finally had the chance to try Italian Soda House in Yorkville, and wow...what a great experience!
The restaurant itself is absolutely gorgeous, and from the moment we walked in, our waitress greeted us with a big smile and made us feel welcome. The service was friendly, attentive, and added to an already enjoyable meal.
I ordered the Mama Lasagna, and it was incredible! The flavors were out of this world, with a rich, hearty meat sauce that was absolutely packed with meat. Every bite tasted homemade and comforting. Oh, we had the stuffed mushrooms for an appetizer...so good.
My wife had the Pesto Gnocchi with Chicken, and the portion was huge! They definitely don't skimp on the gnocchi, and the creamy pesto sauce paired perfectly with the tender chicken.
One thing we really appreciated was the generous portion sizes, you definitely get your money's worth. They also have a fun selection of refreshing summer drinks that are worth checking out.

If you're looking for delicious Italian food, generous portions, excellent service, and a beautiful atmosphere, I highly recommend giving Italian Soda House a try. We'll definitely be back!“

“Tried somewhere new tonight…UH MAY ZING!!!! Everything was delicious and the service was top notch. Complimentary dough balls for the kiddos to play with=all screen devices were left untouched! The cheese curds were so creamy, the supreme pizza had a fabulous smokey flavor and crispy crust, the fettuccine Alfredo with parm crusted chicken was fierce, and the fench onion soup of the day is our son’s new favorite soup EVER!! Didn’t get a chance to taste our other son’s bacon Mac and Cheese with parm shrimp, but he kept silent while stuffing his face. WE WILL BE BACK.“

“We ordered a family custom thin crust pizza (extra spinach, extra garlic, onion & bacon). It generally tasted good but it was somewhat overdone (think black bottom at edge) and ingredients were not evenly distributed to theI outer edges which meant that edge pieces were pretty much crust and sauce. we liked the sauce.“

“Food was okay fortunes have gotten quite small compared to what they used to be but I get it still more than enough. Gets to be kind of a roadblock to get to the bathroom with all the gamblers.
Waiter was attentive and didn't bother us but was there when we needed something without waiting can see your table and keep drinks full and pleasant person“

“This is my favorite Olive Garden!! Food is always good and the service is excellent!“

“Great food and generous portions. Best baco i ever had“

“We have always been happy with Rosati’s in Sugar Grove. My son is a pizza-holic! :) He has very high standards for his pizza and his favorite is Rosati’s. I have always been treated with friendliness and respect at this location. There are a lot of pizza places to choose from in our area and a Rosati’s 9/10 gets our business. 5 stars“

“Don Walker's has been serving our family for four generations (now 5!). Most recent with a signature Italian Beef/Sausage Christmas Day feast. Ditch the chain and get back to this A-Town OG! Thank you Don Walker's!“

“Had a Philly cheesesteak for lunch today and it was delicious!!“

“Nice kids meals, good food“

“I have to give a shout out especially to the young staff working on the evening of February 14, 2026. They were slammed with orders, but every one of them was working extremely hard while displaying patience, politeness, and professionalism. My order was correct, food was well prepared, and I received my order just 5 minutes past the promised time, which is amazing considering how overwhelmed they were. To those kids, I want you to know you did a fantastic job and you should be proud of yourselves.“

“My work ordered this pizza the other night and I think it’s the most delicious pizza I’ve ever eaten.“

“Of all the Rosati's locations I've visited, Oswego is certainty the best location. I only get one slice of pizza but that slice is always hot and fresh... ALWAYS! I live in Channahon but would go out of my way to get a slice, or whole pizza, from there. I feel like im getting more value for my dollar there.

I want to be clear that the other Rosatis locations are still very good but Oswego is exceptional.

Plus the service is great. The young lady that works the front, I think her name is Susie, is a pleasure as well. There is always a movie playing which gets me in the mood for movie nights with pizza so fantastic location.“

“Lovely atmosphere, personable outstanding service and delicious entrees. Had the Aurora Street and Amore Mio brick oven pizza this time. Made and cooked to perfection!“

“The Best thing about living in a haunted house around here is Rosattis Pizza of Montgomery , The other thing is Patti's Free Fallin BBQ Sauce but you can get that everywhere“

“Pizza is good as long as u don’t order PEPPERONI there very cheap with the pieces I had to actually look for them my pizza look dam near like a cheese pizza … the wanna be manager has bad customer service his response was ORDER EXTRA NEXT TIME smh glad I don’t order pizza that often cause they don’t deserve my money … time to find another pizza place it’s that simple … so treat your customers right“