12 Best Ice Cream Shops in Bloomington

“Wonderful ice cream and great service!“

“Best cookies and the best service! I had ordered a delivery that didn't make it, and Crumbl didn't hesitate to make it right and send another order - which did get to my coworkers for their birthday celebration! I very much appreciate the extra effort that was made!“

“Danelle and her team at Jiffy Treat West made custom boxes of ice cream for our company retreat! 8 boxes of different flavors each packaged in their own sample size for a team of 12! It was amazing!!! Cannot recommend them enough. Thank you, Jiffy Treat West!“

“If you are here in the fall absolutely ask for a sample of the Apple Butter and Pumpkin Flavors!!! We absolutely LOVED Both! We got a scoop of each and split it! So delicious! Our daughter enjoyed her vanilla cone. The candy eyes were a cute touch 🥰

We’re supposed to leave town tomorrow morning and are already contemplating coming back before we leave!! So Soo Good!“

“Kinda hard to find the correct door to go in and the "lobby" is tiny... But they are very good at describing what types of drinks you can get and offer free samples before making your selection. The custard and Italian ice combo is surprisingly refreshing!! Not too sweet.. and just the right mix of flavors. I'm definitely going to have to come back a few more times to try a couple other kinds!!!“

“Fantastic! Food was amazing service was great,best burger I’ve ever had in my life!“

“I order the peach cobbler with extra crust … omg. It was amazing.“

“Great customer service and awesome ice cream! Banana split was the bomb 😂“

“I got 3 of their crunchy gyros, some feta fries, and a large Mediterranean dip for my family and I while we were visiting Bloomington. We don't have a lot of Greek food up where we are, save for King Gyros, so this was a great treat. Everything was incredibly flavorful, the gyro meat was thick and tasty, and the dip lasted us several days. We will be coming again, if we're ever in town!“

“Quick service with friendly staff. Excellent Burgers especially the new chili Burger 🍔.“

“Sheffield insomnia cookies is Really lovely clean, warm & cosy place on division st (near fountain precinct/city hall) and really nice welcoming and friendly staff. Delicious vegan 🌱 cookies only 2 options currently but really good! I can’t pick a favourite one. 🍪 They also have 2 vegan ice creams too. Lovely staff here especially Alice & Saf & all the team made me feel welcome as a vegan too which was really nice. Only note is No vegan 🌱 friendly deluxe or festive /special cookies 😞 They only have a simple generic coffee machine for hot drinks so its only espresso or americano , black or with oat milk (oatly minis) for hot drinks but its still better than no hot drinks especially in the cold weather! 🥶 Hopefully they can get a proper machine for any alt milks latte, capucinno etc and oat milk in hot chocolate etc in the future 👍🏽 Thanks ☺️“

“BEST place for a dessert, pastry, or chocolate in Bloomington“