26 Best Pizza Restaurants near Burns Harbor

“If there were more stars to give, I would happily award them to Angelica! From the moment we stepped into the restaurant, her warm smile greeted us, setting the tone for a delightful evening. Angelica's impeccable hosting skills transformed our dining experience into a memorable occasion.Her attention to detail was exceptional. She ensured that every guest felt valued and attended to. Her ability to anticipate our needs and preferences was truly remarkable. Angelica effortlessly navigated the flow of the evening, orchestrating seating arrangements with grace and efficiency.Not only was Angelica professional, but she also exuded genuine warmth and hospitality. Her cheerful demeanor and friendly banter created an inviting atmosphere, making us feel right at home. It was evident that she genuinely cared about our comfort and satisfaction throughout our visit.Angelica's dedication to her role as a hostess is commendable. She went above and beyond to accommodate our requests and ensure that our dining experience exceeded expectations. Her passion for hospitality shone brightly, leaving a lasting impression on us.In conclusion, Angelica's exceptional service elevated our dining experience to new heights. Her professionalism, warmth, and attention to detail were truly outstanding. We are grateful for her contributions to making our evening unforgettable. We can't wait to return and experience her hospitality again!Thank you, Angelica, for being an exemplary hostess and for making our visit so special!Warm regards,Phil“

“Amazing pizza. The brickie bread is second to none. Fries were great. Super friendly staff. They helped us keep my 2 year old entertained. My family has been coming here for decades and we just love it. 10/10 will be back.Kid-friendliness: Our server brought out crayons and a coloring/activity sheet to help us entertain our 2 year old. She loved it!“

“My son and my son-in-law brought me here last weekend. We did a tasting which was absolutely amazing. We had some pizza and some spinach dip and that was to die for. I left very tipsy but with a jar of sipping cream and apple pie shine. Such a lovely atmosphere and friendly staff. I hope to make it back again soon.“

“First time I have been here will not be the last. The food is outstanding, better than Olive Garden, IMO.The place is so popular, we were told there would be a 45 minute wait.30 minutes later, we were seated and waited on very quickly. The spaghetti and Lasagna is great! I really enjoyed the presentation of a dessert tray, which allows you to pick out what you want and prepared for you. The waitresses are very friendly, professional and very good at what they do.“

“This restaurant originally from Chicago is my boyfriends favorite pizza in the absolute world. He would talk about it constantly, he lives out of state now and I live a few hours away from Chesterton. We decided to take a trip for my birthday and get some food. We ordered pizza, and shrimp Alfredo. The bread that comes as a side with the pasta is delicious and the pizza was too. We’ll be back!“

“I love the sauce on their pizza. A hint of sweet. My favorite is pocket pizza, aka calzone. Wings never disappoint. Good selection on sauce, great flavor.Another great place if you're in hotels by I-80 or 94. Order for delivery. You won't be disappointed with this Small business local spot.“

“Was looking for a new pizza place to try in the area and ended up giving Another Round a shot. I really liked it, it had a nice crust and the sauce was just right. Is this pizza my favorite, no, I'm more of a deep dish guy, but would consider this one of the better pizzas in the area for my family.“

“The guy that waited on me was really nice, however when I came back to pick up my pizza, that young lady showed me she did not want to be bothered, I told the guy she should be in the back with that attitude. Still gave 5 because pizza never disappoint, However if I go in again and she gives me that attitude, good pizza want matter.Parking: You park in back which not alot of space, or you can park in the next business lot, some people park on side that taking a chance you can get side swiped.“

“Lyndsey is amazing & so friendly, attentitve and knowledgeable. Food is top notch. I’ve had the skirt steak sandwich 3 times this week, that’s how good it is. Wings are also extremely good. They really know what they’re doing here ???“

“After a day of hiking through the Dunes, we were happy to find a restaurant with 4+ stars. The ratings were true. Our waitress was very kind and patient with our questions about the menu. She was prompt on refills and a delight to talk to. The food was good and we will definitely stop back by when we return in the summer for a new Dunes experience.“

“Excellent food. Especially the pizza any day and Ribeye Steak Saturday nite or Ribeye steak sandwich Saturday or Sunday. Wide variety of food and drinks. This just isn't a bar.... it's a local gathering spot. You would expect this quality in a much more expensive place. Classy all the way. The staff is TOP NOTCH.“

“As always, another delicious meal by Shoe's pizza. Got a sausage pizza, veggie pizza (you select what you want), and shoe's bites (garlic breadsticks cut up in bite size pieces) and enjoyed every bite.Just a suggestion, wish they had spinach and garlic to add to their pizza topping choices. As someone who primarily eats vegetarian, I wish they had spinach as an option.Even still, their pizza is outstanding and budget friendly and can't wait to get pizza again soon!!“

“We pick-up pizza from here about once a month since we're outside the delivery area. It's a bit of a trek from Chesterton, but it's worth it. We always get the Detroit-style for the yummy crispy edges. The pepperoni and BBQ chicken pizza are our favorite two pizzas. The Jet's Bread is a must for a side. The new Popcorn Chicken is fine, but not worth $10 imho.“

“I was so excited to find a Fazoli's, hadn't had it since I left college 25 years ago. It's still the same reliable, quick, budget-friendly pasta I knew all those years ago. And the breadsticks are FIRE, just as I remember. I'll gladly stop by whenever I'm in town again. Thanks for the memories!“

“My wife's been wanting to come try this place out. We ordered some delicious cocktails. The crab cake and hot wing appetizers were also very good. The egg plant parmesan was really good but the lasagna was out of this world. It has some really unique and delicious flavors I wish I knew how to replicate because it's the best lasagna I've ever had!! I've heard their pizzas are delicious as well. I can't wait to come back to eat more.“

“1st time here, so kinda limited in what we tried from the menu. Great pizza! The crust is a bit crunchy, but soft inside. Wonderful!! The toppings were nice and fresh and plentiful. A good amount of cheese on the pizza too. Not skimpy, but not overwhelming either, just right.Also tried the Spinach Galette, which was awesome!!! and the onion rings are good, but the onions themselves (inside the onion rings) were a bit tough to bite through. Good flavor and crunch on the breading though.2 kinds of Italian sausage ( 1 mild, the other slightly spicy), but with big containers of crushed red pepper on the table, a bit more heat is never TOO far away!Vegetarian options: Like most pizza joints, options for vegetarians are plentiful!!!!!“

“We ordered heart-shaped pizzas here for Valentine's Day. It's a tradition I've had with my daughter since they were little. The pizza was incredibly good, the cute gift bag with the glass and candies was such a sweet touch. Truly made our Valentine's Day so much more special. Thank you guys so much!“

“Ordered pizza for pickup tonight. Got large sausage and onion and bread sticks. It was one of the best pizzas I had in a while. Very great taste from the sauce to the crust. Bread sticks were good also.Service was great also no problem as it was on time. Did order pickup but the ambiance looked good . Will definitely order again when I am on the area. If you want a good pizza and price to go with it. This is the place. Thanks team.“

“I've been coming here for years and enjoy their food but for a couple of years it seemed like no one above the age of 12 work there. Our credits got backed up were never used we were supposed to be credited at least 10 times but we are not Petty and will pay for our food. I'm happy to say that yesterday the manager was very professional very understanding and went above and beyond for us and even refused to take a tip. I will gladly come back and you whoever you are the new manager I take it you're doing an awesome job“

“This was an "accidental" visit. We were traveling on Christmas Eve and they were open. How lucky for us! I knew exactly what I wanted, so I ordered a small sausage/mushroom/ onion pie. My husband couldn't decide so he had our server choose from 3 options. She came back with a meat lovers with bbq sauce instead of pizza sauce. Both pizzas were excellent, and the service was super. I don't know if I'd have been so cheerful if I were working Christmas Eve. She kept our (very large!) cups filled with pop and checked on us a few times during the meal. And the price wasn't too bad! We'll be adding Gelsosomo's to our routine when traveling back and forth between Michigan and Wisconsin. Thank you so much!“

“I ordered from them every weekend and there's not a weekend where the pizzas outstanding The taste is great the price is great and so is the service I love these guys I feel like they're family thanks for your good service you're good “

“First time ordering from here since we moved to Portage nearly 4 years ago from the Chicago area. With that being said we don’t order pizza very often at home; but we’ve tried them all. So far, this has been the best pizza we’ve had delivered hands down. We ordered 2 large: one pepperoni and one veggie along with baked mostaccioli and salad. No serious complaints, it was hot and actually tasted like “normal” pizza“

“Come here every other week with my grandfather, and the place is always exceptional.The food is great and well priced for the portions. The staff is always super helpful and kind, all while being able to interact personally with everyone. All while creating a nice, warm, and welcoming atmosphere.“

“The service was great! Our waitress was training and was so very friendly. The food was alright. I got the Chicken Parmesan sandwich...not too much flavor unfortunately. I'd like to go back and try their pizza! The breaded mushrooms and ranch were delicious however.“