24 Best Pizza Restaurants in Carmel

“Good pizza place, love noble roman’s“

“perfecto para largo partes“

“Solid pie and kids plate. Good service. Good beer selection (although they often “just ran out” of the one I order).“

“Best burgers and smoked wings in Carmel no doubt.“

“Yummy lunch drove a little out of my way in route home to Michigan.“

“Easily one of my favorite pizza places in the Indianapolis area. It’s the dough that really stands out to me, but the toppings and cheese are also fantastic. The employees are always friendly. It’s so nice having a little pizza place so close to my home and heart. My family and I love coming here and I hope people support Tony’s not just because the pizza is delicious, but because it’s important to support the little guy in a sea of chain pizzas restaurants.“

“Good food and customer service.“

“We love Pizzology! Good food and drink. The staff are friendly and keep you updated on your meal. Pizzology is our neighborhood go-to.“

“Haven't even ordered yet, but I'm looking forward to it. Nothing better than calling a store, talking to a human, and the person/staff member is actually pleasant and informative!

Thank you, Grace! You earned our business tonight.

Kent and Jill.“

“Came here after the Indy 500 after we realized the sports bars were packed because of the Pacers game. We love our Jets at home and really just wanted to eat some warm good food after being out all day long.
THIS PLACE WAS BUSY. Wait time said 25 minutes and it was just about right on. The guy at the counter asked everyone who came in what they were waiting on, checked it, and gave an update. The line was working quickly and you could just tell everyone in there was ON IT. Bake, toppings, and accuracy were just as good as we get at home. A nice finish to a long exhausting day. Good management and good staff are refreshing to see - keep up the good work guys :-)“

“Delicious food, from the salad to the spaghetti. Shared a Tiramisu and it was the best we ever had! Friendly staff and great service.“

“Came in for lunch and experienced great customer service. Great atmosphere and even better food. Greeks FTW!!!“

“Not a bad place for lunch. Decent pizza and a nice salad. I got the \"Lunch Box\" which is the special. Along with that you get a reusable cup and two tootsie rolls (which was kind of cute). My biggest complaint was the music was a weird electronic smooth jazz. Other than that, it was a nice stop.“

“My favorite hobby is trying local joints from places I travel too. This adventure led me to this joint. I had the Spicy Bee & Bazbeaux Special (half & half). Both were good, but would totally get the Bezbeaux Special again…so tasty! If you enjoy light beers, I recommend Daredevil from a local brewery. My only con is the bottom crust wasn’t as done for me, but that is a personal preference (I typically ask for well done pizza). Would completely recommend to anyone looking for a pizza joint with a vibe!“

“Was feeling a bit under the weather today my second time having strep throat in three weeks. Yuck. . So Jack picked up some pizza for dinner. And I have to say for a casual pizza place Domino’s was really good. I was very impressed. And I know that the location is locally owned by a Carmel Family. Everything was hot and fresh and the toppings were plentiful. The crust was soft and tasty. I was very impressed, even with it being a more affordable pizza place. …..I thought they did a really good job …so a shout out to them. 🍕 🍕 🍕“

“Hunt Brothers Pizza is a great pizza for anybody searching for really good tasting food the employees are always very respectful their Pizza is also never undercooked or overcooked it is always just right with a perfect amount of toppings“

“This pizza ? is really yummy. So Manny toppings to pick from. The crust is done to perfection, it has a slight mouth watering crunch to it. The Garlic Knots are so delicious that you do not need any sauce for dipping. I give this place 2 ? thumbs ? up!! Go grab yours tonight, you will not be disappointed!“

“I eat at the blaze a lot when I’m in town probably too much. Quality and choices to build your own pizza at the price point is great service is usually quick and friendly unless they are slammed during lunch on the weekday. Prepare to wait 30 minutes with all the online and go orders as well as the walk-ins.

My only complaint is that the Caprese side salad was a fraction barely enough to pick up with a fork. Which is OK I guess if you got a little bit of pizza to go with it

The guy who was running the oven today with the glasses and curly hair at lunchtime, deserves a raise!“

“I recently dined at puccini's and it was an incredible experience! The pizza and pasta were absolutely delicious—authentic flavors, fresh ingredients, and cooked to perfection. The atmosphere was cozy and welcoming, making it the perfect spot for a great meal.But what really stood out was the exceptional service. Our server, a lovely young woman whose name I unfortunately didn’t catch, was outstanding. She was attentive, friendly, and made sure our dining experience was top-notch and even gave my kidos stickers at the end of our meal. Her recommendations were spot on, and she had such a warm and genuine personality that added to the overall enjoyment of our meal.“

“I don’t know who answers the phone at the Downtown location. But she is so nice and so professional. She helped me with the situation and was as kind as I would ever want to expect from somebody. Thank you so much. Also, we found this place by accident recently and we have fallen in love with Pizza so we really do enjoy going here.“

“I'm a fairly critical reviewer because I expect quality and I expect to get what is advertised and what I ordered (I also work hard for my money!). Seems a bit too much these days. But, I'm a fair reviewer as well. We've been ordering at this Hotbox for the last three months and it has been amazing!!! The skinny crust is incredible. We do like it crunchy and have to put that in the special instructions. But wow, they nail it and they do not shirk on the toppings, and the ingredients are really fresh. The pizza is always hot and fresh when delivered. I have to say, it's one of the few places that gets our order right and doesn't "forget" anything, i.e. cheese sauce, etc. They also certainly have the best breadsticks and cheese sauce. I never thought that HotBox would become my go to here in Carmel for pizza as there is a lot of great competition. Keep it up and we'll keep ordering! Thank you!“

“Absolutely fantastic pizza, probably some of the best I've had in my whole life. Our table had the Yeah-Yeah and the Sun-Dried Tomato and both were fantastic. The pizza took a bit to come out but was perfectly cooked and packed with fresh and tasty ingredients, absolutely worth it.

Vegetarian options: The Spicy Sun-Dried Tomato pizza is a fantastic option for vegetarians.“

“Pamela R. is a blessing. She recommends and describes specials, makes us feel at home, is so positive and upbeat. We really enjoyed the lasagna, fettuccine, and spaghetti and meatballs, and fresh salad. Thank you for a fun night out!!“

“Carmel Greek’s Pizzeria is under new ownership, and WOW—what a difference! The service is unbelievably fast and friendly, and the food is absolutely delicious. Whether you want delivery, dine-in, or carryout, this spot is perfect for families and anyone craving great food. I highly recommend stopping by and checking it out for yourself—you won’t be disappointed!“