11 Best Burger Restaurants in New Albany

“The food is so good. The owners are great people. My 2026 goal is to support this business more. My only regret is I wish I’d bought a 2nd burger for later“

“This place is legit my favorite fast food place in New Albany. Partially because they don’t ever mess up my order and it’s always warm, and partially because the staff is always in a good mood and Over the top friendly.“

“My Husband and I were there Monday ,March the 16th and I can't say enough about Tasha M.She was the best waitress,Very on top of her job..Mark Feed Store has the best BBQ ribs and bone in wings..We will be back..“

“seriously the nicest people and most delicious food!“

“I visited Burger King, store #3533, and received excellent service. My order was prepared in under two minutes and served promptly. The dining area was clean and well maintained, and the overall appearance of the restaurant was neat and welcoming. The windows and glass were spotless, and the staff demonstrated strong food safety practices by wearing gloves while serving food. Customer service was friendly and professional. I would definitely recommend this location and look forward to visiting again. Thank you, Burger King.“

“The Hangover is such a delicious sandwich! We love all the great events they throw here and the staff is so cool!“

“I stopped by Rally's after hearing so much about their famous seasoned french fries. I was expecting something unforgettable, but honestly, they were just okay for me personally. I even bought a frozen bag of the fries months later to bake at home because I kept thinking maybe I had missed the magic the first time around.

That said, Rally’s is still a very well-known American fast-food brand with a classic drive-thru experience and a bold, recognizable style. The building design itself stands out immediately with its retro red, white, and black look, giving it that old-school roadside burger stop feeling. The drive-thru service was quick and convenient, especially if you’re passing through and want something fast and affordable.

Even though the fries didn’t completely live up to the hype for me, the rest of the menu may be where the real flavor shines for many people. It’s one of those iconic fast-food spots that feels very connected to American road-trip culture and quick comfort food.“

“We had not been since Fall, and the server remembered us! Consistently quality food and service 😃 2/6/26“

“Great atmosphere,great owners I met. very helpful. Deck was beautiful outside. loved the outside decor and vibe. can't wait to go back. especially when it warms up more.“

“The best of service in the local area's. Debbie is the best manage hands down and very compassionate about her customer's but yet very professional.“

“One of the items I got from there today was a large strawberry milkshake. The milkshake was literally sour. I spoke with Makayla Bishop. She said she put my name down for a free large milkshake, but said that was the only option. She was friendly about it, but I could not imagine serving someone a sour milkshake, and telling them the only option was to try another one of our milkshakes. I think if I buy a soured milkshake from your company, and I want my money back, because I will never buy another milkshake there again, I should have that option. She did say that she made the milkshakes fresh today. but that doesn't mean that it wasn't sour. This is a really poor business practice, especially for a two-star restaurant. You need to start listening to your customers. I think she handled it the best she could. but there are obviously unethical people telling her they can't give money back, even if they are served inferior products. Due to your unethical policy, I will be reporting this incident to the health department. You really think I want a free milkshake? I came for good service, not replacement food. y You policy suggests that you think you are doing someone a favor by replacing dangerous food that you serve. I only visited, because my son wanted a milkshake, and now he said he will never want to go there again either.“