New American Restaurants near Brewster, MA

“Visited for the first time after making a phone reservation more than a week ago - this place is very popular! Super friendly welcome, peaceful and calm atmosphere. We had two pasta mains that were very well made, al dente pasta, flavorful sauce. Very cozy on a chilly night. Service is perhaps a little slow but they want to make you feel comfortable and not rushed. Will definitely come back when we visit cape cod again!“

“Excellent food, excellent customer service. staff was great ....great menu selection!“

“first time there Linda was amazing the food spectacular“

“It was Excellent, especially seeing Chooch. What a pleasure it was. I highly recommend the fish & chips, what a fantastic place, great food, great atmosphere, and most of all great friends. See you again soon!“

“Our experience was excellent. The whole team was wonderful including Antonio. Our waitress was great. It was our anniversary. They made it so celebratory for us!“

“What a beautiful place great food at reasonable prices for a 5 star resort. Everything was perfect.“

“Great service. Food was served hot and quickly. Prepared wonderfully. Excellent , attentive staff. ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️“

“So much fun! Great staff and great food“

“Sunbird is one of my favorite breakfast spots on the cape. The food is unique and wholesome. My favorites are the breakfast tacos and chai latte. I love the picnic tables and patio in the back - such a relaxing spot to enjoy quiet or a catch up with friends!“

“Such a varied and interesting menu! My meal was outstanding.“

“We happened to be in Orleans and decided to grab an early dinner at The Barley Neck. We started with a dozen raw oysters and a bottle of French Chardonnay. The oysters were so fresh and delicious we ordered a second dozen. My husband had a lobster pasta dish for his entree and I had a Thai style tuna steak. Both were delicious, but a special thumbs up for the tuna. It was without a doubt the BEST tuna steak I’ve ever had! We finished with the pineapple upside down cake special! O.M.G. Everything was consistently amazing. The service was attentive and welcoming! From beginning to end the experience as a whole was on point! 10 out of 10!“

“Very friendly waitress named Deborah. Loud restaurant. Our scallop dinners were good. The mushroom risotto a bit undercooked. Clam chowder tasted great. Never had a blueberry white chocolate bread pudding. That was delicious and enjoyed by both of us! The tea service was elegant with a pot and cup in one.“

“8/6/21 Had breakfast here today. Got seated right away about 9-9:15am Waiter took order, BYO Breakfast sandwich with short stack, and 2 Scrambled eggs with sausage and home fries, and a popover. Saw other people come in after us, order, and be served. 🤔 After about 45 minutes, got up to ask where breakfast was; “it should be out soon” 🤷🏼‍♀️We we’re seriously contemplating getting up and leaving !! (Again, a breakfast sandwich, and 2 scrambled eggs!🤔) And it still wasn’t too busy in there. Our waiter didn’t come bring the food to the table, 2 other people did, never asked if things were ok. When he came to bring the bill, again never spoke to us, but, was talking to the table behind is. 🙄🤷🏼‍♀️ It came HIGHLY recommended, but, we weren’t fans. Oh, and also on my “breakfast sandwich”, I got charged separately for the English Muffin!! 🤷🏼‍♀️ it’s listed in the description as coming on an English Muffin, so, again…. Why being charged extra?!!🤷🏼‍♀️🤔 The popover was totally burnt and cold , and sausages over cooked and burned. 2 people- $34, Thanks, but no thanks! Service wasn’t that great! And 45 minutes for a breakfast sandwich and 2 scrambled eggs?!!🤔 We aren’t tourists, we are local to Chatham, and was trying to keep it local, but, …….“

“Perfect spot right on Glendon Rd, only 2 min walk to the beach!“

“Monday night’s is industry night @9:30 pm Dj“

“The lobster nachos were excellent! Highly recommend ✅“

“While we live about a mile away, we've never dined here and decided to do so for a holiday treat. Upon entering the Wequassett grounds, it was somewhat difficult to locate twenty-eight Atlantic. Most of the signage pertained to lodging/room numbers. We did eventually locate three signs (all on one post together) for three different dining venues. Unfortunately those signs were in front of multiple entrances and none of those doors were identified as restaurants. We walked around for a bit and eventually were able to ask for directions to our dining room. The menu offered only 6 entrees, along with a couple of surprising choices we thought would be found at their other casual restaurants. The two fish choices were salmon and monk fish tail, along with chicken, lamb, beef and a vegetarian choice. Our food (salmon and lamb) was average and we would have preferred more menu choices. Our meal presentation was lovely, and the service impeccable. A jazz trio provided festive ambiance and the decks were lit with holiday lights with fire pits blazing. We may return in the day time to enjoy the view, and hopefully next time we'll find the place easier!“

“We attended Supper on the Bay. The meal prepared by the chef on the lawn was perfectly executed and so special.The absolute stellar service from the wait staff was second to none. I wholeheartedly recommend this dining experience to everyone.“

“Joey at Paradise created pre - wedding specialty wraps and grinders for my grandaughter's wedding on 9 / 27 - We chose the wraps - from a varied menu - were fresh and delicious served on the many different colored wraps - tomato basil - spinach and many more - The presentation was colorful and lovely for the bridesmaids and bride - we also ordered large grinders for the grooms and again they were fresh and varied with more than generous portions - We recommend Paradise Pizza without reservation of any kind - polite service - all that was promised and more - Sheila Leonard - Worcester Ma and West Dennis Ma“

“Always a terrific experience! Nice selection of wines (incl by the glass), creative cocktails and a wide variety of meals - sizes and tastes. Highly recommend!“

“Monday night’s is industry night @9:30 pm Dj“

“very cute place in Chatham connected to a gorgeous inn. Food was great and service was wonderful!“