12 Best American Restaurants in Brookline

Prairie Fire New American • $$
242 Harvard St, Brookline

Customers` Favorites

Brussels Sprouts Pizza
Wood Oven Half Chicken
Lemon Meringue Tart
Roasted Cauliflower
Farm Greens Salad
Margherita Pizza
Fennel Spaghetti
Roasted Oysters
Mushroom Pizza
Mushroom Toast

“What an amazing place. In these times when we are still not comfortable dining indoors this place rocks. The chef behind these dishes knows a thing or two about bringing beer garden food to a totally new level. Thank you chef and staff in front of the house.“

4.6 Superb163 Reviews
Grainne O'Malley's Tavern Irish Pub • $$
201 Harvard St, Brookline

Customers` Favorites

Beer Batter Fish N Chips
Bangers and Mash
Sam Adams on Tap
Beer Selection
Buffalo Wings
Fish and Chips
Irish Nachos
Steak Tips
Beet Salad
Pub Steak

“Solid fish and beet salad dinner. Really appreciate their proper style of fish batter - light and crisp. Popped in for an early Saturday night dinner, and I'm glad we got there early as it filled up fast. Strong drinks, great pub food options, and a bustling atmosphere.“

4.6 Superb81 Reviews
The Abbey American • $$
1657 Beacon St, Brookline

Customers` Favorites

Pappardelle Wild Mushroom Baby Spinach & Truffle Sage Cream
Spicy Tomato Bisque Grilled Cheese Panini
Truffle Fries with Roasted Garlic Mayo
Sriracha Deviled Eggs Crispy Bacon
Fried Buratta with Prosciutto
Grilled Chicken and Salad
Grilled Flatbread Pizza
Bison Bolognese Pasta
Bacon Cheeseburger
Pork Schnitzel

“This review is for the Brookline location of The Abbey. The Abbey doesn't do reservations or call ahead. We showed up around 6:00ish on a Saturday night and were told there was a 20 - 30 minute wait. We were welcome to sit at the bar, but there was no place for four people to sit together, so we lurked near the door and chatted, ducked customers walking in and out and staff taking orders, running food and clearing plates. It's a small space when all the tables are full and people are a few deep at the bar, but that just added to the ambiance. I was seated facing the wall so I didn't see quite how busy it got, but the noise was at "lively" level. We could still have a conversation but needed to speak up to be heard across the table. We were able to snag a table after about 30 minutes. The basics first: The drinks, food and service were fantastic! This is our second time here, the first being ages ago when they had the covered tables outside early in the pandemic. I've been wanting to come back forever, but don't usually get to this part of Brookline. I need to change that or head to Cambridge too! I started with a winter sangria (red wine, brandy, spiced rum, apricot and allspice) that was delicious. They have a pretty extensive gluten free menu, which is nice. My friend wanted the GF pasta Bolognese, but she is dairy free to so that was not an option. We ordered two of the slow-braised short rib "French dip" egg rolls with gruyere, horseradish aioli, and red wine demi for the table. Loved this! I never finish apps and I inhaled this. I was fine with that, I could just put my main in a take home container. We also got the black kale & Brussels sprouts salad, avocado, pepitas, Crispy bacon, and a fried duck egg. Even if you think you don't like kale and or Brussels sprouts, get this dish! I got the "Thanksgiving" panini (house roasted turkey, cornbread stuffing, cheddar, arugula, cranberry aioli, hand-cut fries). It was delicious and can't wait for the leftovers. The hanger steak frites came topped with watercress and a madeira sauce. It was the most tender steak that I've ever had. For sides my friends also ordered shredded Brussels sprouts and pan roasted cauliflower with capers and pecorino as sides. Not to be missed are the hand cut fries that are the embodiment of French fries perfection. They are a must order, either plain or with truffles and cheese. Fried potato nirvana! As I said, the place was packed, but service was attentive and Ty (sp?), our server made sure allergy info was provided to the kitchen. He made great suggestions for items to try. The Brookline location does not serve dessert (sad panda) but the Cambridge location does. Good to note for next time! Did I mention that the kitchen is open until 1:30 AM every night? Perfect for late night bites.“

4.5 Superb109 Reviews
Busy Bee Restaurant & Diner American • $
1046 Beacon St, Brookline

Customers` Favorites

Eggs Anystyle w Meat Toast & Homefries
Pancakes Plain Blueberry Choc Chip
Eggs over Easy with Ham
French Toast with Syrup
Spanish Omelete
Side of Bacon
French Toast
Plain Omelet
Home Fries
Hash

“My recent visit to Busy Bee Restaurant for breakfast left me feeling like I had stepped into a cozy home. The warm ambiance set the stage for a delightful dining experience. The staff, especially our waiter, went above and beyond to ensure our satisfaction. Their genuine friendliness and proactive service made us feel truly valued. Now, let's talk about the food. It was delicious! Generous portions at reasonable prices, cooked to perfection. Overall, Busy Bee Restaurant exceeded our expectations with its welcoming atmosphere, impeccable service, and mouthwatering food. Highly recommended!“

4.5 Superb94 Reviews
The Washington Square Tavern American • $$
714 Washington St, Brookline

Customers` Favorites

Pan Seared Local Sea Scallops Sweet Corn Chowder House Cured Bacon
House Charcuterie Plate Seasonal Pickles
Crispy Fried Ipswich Clams Sorrel Aioli
Seared Salmon over Rice
Seared Scallops
Steak Frites
Burger
Fries

“Great spot for casual dinner or date night. Tastefully decorated with a picture window through a book case for the kitchen or a turn of the century bar top. The staff were friendly and attentive. Food was comfort items overall and also well done. There was some variability in the salt of each dish, but it was on the side of needing a little extra salt for our taste which was easily remedied.“

4.4 Superb45 Reviews
Hemlock Grill Burgers • $
1281 W Roxbury Pkwy, Brookline

Customers` Favorites

Nashville Hot Chicken
Fried Fish Sandwich
Fried Chicken

“I've lived in the area for 29 years and this is my first time here had an awesome experience with Joe the bartender.. I learned about the history of the golf course, And the crispy chicken sand which, i can't wait to come back ? And try the golf range and the Bochi “

4.7 Superb30 Reviews
Zaftigs Delicatessen American • $
335 Harvard St, Brookline

Customers` Favorites

Challah French Toast with Maple Syrup
Bagel with Cream Cheese or Hummus
Banana Stuffed French Toast
Matzo Ball Chicken Soup
The Pastrami Scramble
Corned Beef Sandwich
Empire Eggs Benedict
Pastrami Sandwich
Corned Beef Hash
Western Benedict

“Got catering for a party following a great in-house dining experience and Zaftig's was a hit! Their catering portion sizes are generous, traveled well, and everything was delicious. Will certainly be reaching out to them again in the future.“

4.1 Good155 Reviews
Garrison House Bar • $$
6 Harvard Square, Brookline

Customers` Favorites

Thai Chili Chicken Wings
Wild Mushroom Pizza
Truffle Fries
House Nachos
Power Bowl

“This is a great place to go with a crowd. Lots of variety on the menu and reasonably priced. Service was friendly and attentive. They did not have a record of our reservation for 8 people, even though I received multiple confirmations. Luckily it was not an issue as the restaurant wasn't crowded due to snowy weather. Drinks were great. Lighting was definitely very dim, almost too dim for my old eyes to read the menu! This was definitely a hike for our son and his friends, who all go to BU, but the walk didn't seem to bother them, and usually the green line will take you nearby (we didn't know it would be closed when we made the reservation). Food was okay, I found the fried chicken sandwich to be enormous (the chicken filet was way bigger than the bun) and the coating to be too thick and crispy for my taste. The Brussel sprouts side was delicious and we liked that they had a variety of sides to choose from that were on the healthier side.“

3.8 Good112 Reviews
The Bistro – Eat. Drink. Connect.® American •
40 Webster St, Brookline

“Nice area, looks like some upgrades have been made to hallways and rooms at the hotel since my last visit. Downside is housekeeping. Forgot to clean the room on a day when it was requested. The old days of daily housekeeping seems to be gone unless requested. $40 a day to park, be aware.“

3.5 Good11 Reviews
The Publick House American • $$
1648 Beacon St, Brookline

Customers` Favorites

Grilled Chicken Panini
Publick House Burger
The Mac & Cheese
Moules Frites
Truffle Cream
Pretzel Flight
Caesar Salad
The Mac
Fish

“We had the pretzels and beer cheese, which were very good, but could have used some mustard. Similarly, the servers were very nice and helpful, but the service was a little slow for the time of day. The beer menu is the real draw though, and was very nice. Similarly, the atmosphere was excellent!“

3.9 Good57 Reviews
Hamilton Restaurant & Bar Cocktail Bar • $$
1366 Beacon St, Brookline

Customers` Favorites

Buffalo Chicken Flatbread
Grilled Chicken Sandwich
Truffle Parmesan Fries
Beacon Street Burger
Tempura Cauliflower
Impossible Burger
Guinness Beef Stew
Mashed Potatoes
Chicken Wings
Clam Chowder

“Was staying nearby for a week over St Patrick's weekend and we were in everyday. Greg and his staff couldn't be friendlier and treated us really well, helping us with recommendations for places to visit and things to see. They would let us in early for a Irish breakfast and nothing was ever too much to ask. The food specials were great and they even showed the rugby internationals from Europe on the Saturday, this was great fun as the place was buzzing.“

3.6 Good97 Reviews
Coolidge Corner Clubhouse American • $$
307 Harvard St, Brookline

Customers` Favorites

Boneless Wings and Buffalo Chicken Dip
The Turkey Clubhouse Sandwich
Turkey Reuben Sandwich
Pulled Pork
Lobster Roll
BBQ Ribs
Steak
Nachos

“Didn't get any food, just hung out with friends. They did have one of those big TV's with all their beers on tap. I saw the big juke box on the wall and played one song and that got a good laugh from my friends. Would go back some other time for food and beers.“

3.5 Good73 Reviews
Loading...

Discover More Cuisines In Brookline

map Map