17 Best Italian Restaurants near Douglas

“I don’t eat a lot of pizza but decided to splurge yesterday and it was a fantastic decision. Easily one of the best pizzas I’ve had in a very long while, maybe ever!“

“Our family-owned restaurant was a treat!

We devoured so much food, and everything was absolutely delicious. The main course (which I didn’t get to photograph) was generously portioned. The appetizers were also fantastic, and the desserts were a sweet finish. The oysters, which I had for the first time, were huge and incredibly good. I highly recommend it, whether you’re dining with family, friends, or on a date, if you’re a fan of authentic Italian cuisine.“

“Last Friday is the first time I’ve tried their fish and chips, although I’ve eaten there before and never been disappointed. Take out Fish and chips- 2 large fillets of Fish, coleslaw and fries- EXCELLENT!“

“We had a wonderful experience here! The portions are very generous and everything tasted incredibly fresh. We tried fried calamari, shrimp cocktail, and their fresh made pasta was absolutely delicious. We finished with a blueberry lemon cake that was the perfect ending. Highly recommend!“

“Gia Ristorante Italiano Hubby & I had an amazing dinner last night at Gia's in Uxbridge! It was a last minute decision to go there, but so glad we did. It was a quiet night, cold outside, but inside they had a beautiful fire roaring, smelled so good. We both had amazing meals, waitress was very helpful, answering all our questions. They even made a few changes to a dish so my husband got exactly what he wanted. We will definitely be going there again soon! Highly recommend them for a nice Italian dinner 😋“

“Picked up a Bolognese pizza for takeout from Pizzeria Bruno in Sutton & wow — comfort food done right 🍕✨ A rich, slow-cooked meat sauce spread generously over a perfectly crisp base, bubbling mozzarella, & that unmistakable just-out-of-the-oven aroma that fills the car on the drive home. Every bite was hearty, savoury, & seriously satisfying — the kind of pizza that feels like a warm hug after a long day. Simple, indulgent, & absolutely worth the takeaway run. Sutton, you’re lucky to have this spot. 🤍🔥“

“Really good food and great experience at J. Anthony’s Italian Grill.

I had the Chicken Bruschetta and it was delicious. The chicken was juicy and cooked just right, topped with fresh tomatoes, melted cheese, and pesto. Everything tasted fresh and well balanced. The baked potato was hot and soft, and the sides were very good too.

We also had a pesto risotto (don’t remember the exact name), and it was amazing. Super creamy and full of flavor. Definitely one of my favorite dishes of the night.

Nice atmosphere and friendly service. I’ll definitely be back.“

“Great service! Was busy but that didn’t hinder the attention and care we received! Very clean! Always a great meal here!“

“Stopped on way home from RI very friendly staff and the pizza was awesome 😋“

“Always delicious meals, wonderful service and warm and inviting environment!“

“We just had our first meal here and I can't say enough good things! We both got the double smash burger, and it was crazy good! So juicy and delicious! The owner, Lisa, is delightful and spent time chatting with us while she had a moment. Excellent prices, perfect portions, and just plain outstanding food!! We will be back again and again!“

“Absolutely NOT !!! We ordered our food before 3 other customers who came in to eat in like us . I ordered a chicken salad my husband ordered a cheeseburger sub waited 20 mins still no food but the other 3 customers got their food one had a pizza one had chicken finger dinner and one had a steak and cheese. All of which were as quick as our order but i believe a pizza and fried chicken wings should of taken longer then a cheeseburger 🍔“

“I always have a great experience at Harry's! Best pizza and subs in the area! 😃“

“First visit to oxfords casual dining this past weekend in Oxford and absolutely not our last. Everything was absolutely delicious, and our waitress was super busy but took good care of us. Also got to enjoy some great music from The Drunken Uncles.“

“First time eating here, ordered a Buffalo Chicken pizza and it was amazing! Asked for pineapple as an added topping and they had no issue fulfilling my request. Friendly staff and a very nice meal, hope to eat here again sometime!

(Will add that their drinking water is absolutely repulsive, though — likely not the establishment's fault, but I recommend getting something else if you want a drink.)“

“My family did a timed pre order today placed (about 6 hours ahead of time online) for a large group coming from a local bowling alley for a birthday celebration. All 6 pizzas were ready when we got there at our exact time…fresh, hot and delicious! Plenty of paper goods, a nice bright, clean dining area with plenty of seating. Clean bathrooms and super friendly staff! All the guys at the front counter went above and beyond. Great visit!“

“Just wanted to come on and give a kudos to Upton House of Pizza after our experience last night. We were heading home exhausted from the waterpark and ordered a pickup order, which included a small GF pizza for my daughter. We picked it up, headed home and as we were pulling into the driveway my phone rang. The young kid at the counter called and frantically asked if we had eaten any of the pizza. I assured him we hadn’t yet and he said that he had separated it so well from the counter that another staff had put a regular pizza in the box he had pre-labeled thinking it was it (apparently, it was actually the free regular small pizza we got free with our order - that we didn’t know we were getting). He asked for our address and was at our door within 7 minutes. He even asked to see the other pizza to double check. I tried to tip him and he refused, saying “it’s not like we just forgot pepperoni or something, this was serious!” Thankfully my daughter is just intolerant and not celiac, but I appreciate this to no end 🥰 People make mistakes, it’s how they rectify them that shows their character! We will definitely continue to give them our business!“