34 Best American Restaurants in Plymouth

“PK Law Group had the pleasure of hosting a dinner with our associates last night at Cork and Table in Plymouth. The evening was truly exceptional, thanks to the extraordinary culinary talent of the chef. Every dish was a testament to their skill, made with the freshest farm-to-table ingredients and presented with creative flair. The food was nothing short of spectacular, and the service matched that high standard. A sincere thank you to the chef and the entire team for making our night unforgettable. If you haven’t been yet, make sure to experience this gem the next time you’re in Plymouth!“

“🫀🫀🫀😚😚😚😚😚😚😚😚😚😚😚😚😚😚😚😚😚😚😚😙😙😙😙“

“I got prime rib takeout tonight. It was delicious and the price was very reasonable. I know I’ll be doing that again.“

“Went in tonight for their holiday pop up and so glad we did. We had heard horror stories and then some great reviews and I must say all the horror stories were not true for our visit. We had 4:45 reservations and were seated immediately, it was quite busy but our waitress was over very quickly to take our orders. Food came out fast and the portions were so big. We left stuffed. The holiday decor is fantastic and the drinks for the holidays are so fun! We will be back for sure.“

“Great service outstanding food friendly atmosphere.. going to return with my wife and family next year. Employees were polite. Gift shops close by and the Bed and Breakfast was very clean well maintained.. Super nice.“

“they're horrible at taking orders , in the past 5 months not sure if new owner new cooks, or just the lack of training but the food it trash ! I used to love this place but either they mess up on the pizza it's cardboard box nasty flat and the subs are so filled with meat ( turkey) it's falling out the sides breaking the whole roll itself barely any lettuce or pickles! last time I got a turkey sub the bread was hard as a rock and it had barley any turkey meat , what is going on with this place !?! they're rude when you order and it's a pickup waste of my gas for sure and money I won't be ordering again this place went room 5 star to zero lost a great customer get your crap together honestly why are you packing rhe sub with one much meat for it to just fall out that's such a lack of effort horrible service and they don't ever take accountability EVER!!“

“Holly was our friendly and attentive waitress when I visited this restaurant for the first time with my dad the other day. Things oftentimes get heated when my dad and I discuss things, and Holly was very good at giving us the space we needed when we needed it without sacrificing the proper amount of attention and service. ???
The food at Kevin's was surprisingly good, especially for the fact that I hadn't heard that before! I built my own omelet with jalapeños, feta, and onions. The home fries on the side were among the very best I've ever has! And Holly kept our coffee ☕️ filled to the brim!
I would have preferred the outdoor seating, but my dad doesn't really like sitting in the sun, so we ate indoors where I wasn't super-crazy about our spot only because it's such a quiet restaurant, and my dad gets angry with me and doesn't realize how loud he speaks when that happens.
I would definitely return to Kevin's fit a quiet, relaxing, very reasonably-priced meal. Next time with my wife, so there won't be any heated discussion! ?“

“Had a private function after a funeral and they were amazing to deal with. Made sure we had everything we needed and the food was amazing. great job!“

“was great butt butt my was still hungry so we came back for seconds“

“Enjoyed two evenings at CJ’s recently. Hope, our server, was engaging and very helpful. She recommended the steak tios and brussel sprouts appitizer. Both were delicious! Hope also makes a great french martini! We can’t wait to go back!“

“Went there for the 1st. Time on a weeknight. I had the grilled cheese sandwich with tomato soup. Never enjoyed a grilled cheese more! Only complaint was slow bartending. Otherwise, very nice.“

“Chowder was warm fries cold sent back none with meal. Kitchen help very loud and having a good time. We have been there before probably will not return.“

“We had a 80th birthday celebration in the private dining room on a busy Saturday night. 71 could not have been better! The food was fantastic for all guests. A lot of the salmon dish and filets were all cooked to perfection. Cynthia the server was knowledgeable and professional. She expertly handled questions regarding allergies and gluten free items. The room was beautiful and we were able to bring in decor and a video slideshow. Highly recommend!!!“

“There is nothing not to love! We make it an annual tradition on our family vacation to have Father's Day dinner at your restaurant and it is always top shelf. I couldn't resist getting the prime rib again, though I have tried several other menu items over the years. It's the best I've had anywhere. Wonderful service, kind, friendly staff, nice atmosphere. Keep up the Great work!“

“Tried for the first time today… our waitress was wonderful, the drinks were awesome, and our meals were delicious! Best fish tacos I’ve ever had, can’t wait to come back!“

“The people are friendly and nice . Its a cute and cozy Cafe. This spot used to be my family restaurant fat mike diner . I had to check it out and remember/ comfort of my family. I recommend going there . Its a different coziness for me. Thank You for your service . Best, from the dog Bentley and I. 😊“

“First time there tonight. Atmosphere was great,bartender was personable,(we sat at the bar) food was delicious 😋! Definitely plan on coming back for another visit.“

“The seafood platter for two is delicious so fresh no grease light and crispy batter, best o rings anywhere , and so clean always a staff wiping taking care of what has to be done employees also well dressed and clean they do it right“

“Everything about this place is good: food, service, cocktails, prices, atmosphere. They basically hit on all cylinders just about every time. Everything the chef touches (possibly even looks at) is amazing. I’ve never had anything there that I didn’t like, and that includes things that I don’t like (not a fish fan, but he found a way to make me appreciate it). There are only so many compliments I can give before a review becomes unabashed, gushing adoration, so I will simply say: Try it.“

“We had a large group of very tough customers and from the service, ambience and food it couldn't have been any better! Prob best restaurant on the south shore. Can't wait to sit outside with the waterviews this summer.“

“Really a 3.5, rounding up to 4 stars.

If you asked me 1.5 years ago, this would be an easy five stars. But having been here twice, I had two wildly different experiences. The first was perfect — the food was delectable, it was served efficiently, and the waitstaff was accommodating. However, the second time we visited most recently, the food was not near the same level of quality. Some of the dishes we loved previously had changed for worse (e.g., the fish and chips) and service was SLOW. We waited on our food for a very long time and spent hours more at dinner than we expected. Not sure what was going on, but the party I was with left not wanting to ever come back. I would give it another chance as our first experience was phenomenal, but the inconsistency did raise some concern.

I love the concept of this restaurant and the atmosphere is truly fantastic for people interested in the farm-to-table, garden style of the place — but I would need to visit again to determine whether this is truly worth the time and money, or if it was a one-time fluke.“

“We love going to the Pine hills mama mia's, staff is friendly and food and atmosphere are always great.“

“Such a great lunch! Chose this place as we enjoyed it on a previous vacation and had to have again 😋 Always enjoy the balsamic glaze chicken with mashed potatoes and a salad. Our waitress, Kayla, was so sweet and personable which made it even better! ☺️“

“What a great night out. Went to Eastbay Grill at Pine Hills last minute and had a fabulous time. Started out with having Katie as our server. She was wonderful. She had a great knowledge of the menu, was extremely friendly and patient as we worked our way through drinks, appetizers and entrees. She really added to our evening out. The food was great. I ordered the flatbread and it was delicious and huge. My husband really enjoyed his meal as well. Can not wait to go back.“

“Quite easily the best clam chowda I've ever had. We had; clam chowda, fried shrimp, sea scallops, fish, hamburger (there were 4 of us). Everything was FANTASTIC! I will definitely return!!! YUMMY!!!“

“We had a celebration of life The wait staff was so attentive to our gathering Great food Thank you for making a difficult day lovely“

“Friendly, attentive wait staff. Best Eggplant parm sandwich. Very nice relaxing lunch.“

“I can’t say enough good things about the staff at the Red Robin in Plymouth. They went above and beyond to support our local community by showing up at a Shred and Sizzle skatepark event with burgers, lemonade, and even the Red Robin mascot for photos with the kids. It wasn’t just about the food (which was delicious, of course) it was about the generosity, kindness, and genuine effort to make everyone feel welcomed and cared for. Their team brought so much joy to families and made the night unforgettable. If you’re looking to support a business that gives back, it’s Red Robin of Plymouth.“

“Love the Fribble. Friendly’s was a big part of my childhood and with no more and Cape Cod, it was a pleasant treat.“

“We had the pleasure of being served by Mabelle at Proof 22, and she was absolutely amazing! From the moment we sat down, she was incredibly friendly, sweet, and attentive. You could feel her genuine warmth and care in every interaction.

We were shocked to learn from her manager that this was her very first serving shift — you would’ve never known! She carried herself with such confidence and professionalism, like a seasoned pro. Mabelle made our experience that much more enjoyable, and we’ll definitely be back. Proof 22 is lucky to have her!“

“Your bartender Lisa and Manny & Barback Danny are AMAZING. Top NOTCH service. Amazing. I manage restaurants and resorts and these individuals. The way they work a crowd is amazing. You. Should be PROUD to have such a professional/Likeable “

“I loveee love love Chili's!
I love that in general, the quality of food is consistently delicious & reasonably priced. Ive eaten at Chili's across the nation. Even though its a chain it is so 'local' with the locals. This was a Boston crowd. The 'Irishman' 2 tables over with wife & child was using the cuss word as if he was with his buddy & i loved hearing how honest that was. It made me giggle.“

“Not the best IHOP I have visited. Clearly reduced staffing, no welcome staff, all done by the servers. Not the warmest of welcomes and pancakes not up to my Vegas quality. Place was virtually empty, but food seemed to take quite a while to appear. Sad.“