13 Best Italian Restaurants near Sagamore Beach

“Tried a few items in the past few weeks and for us the Calzone is better than the pizza ! The vegetable pizza was overdone and dried all out but the calzone is great here! And the subs were pretty good. If your trying the vegan pizza be sure it’s made with some sauce n cheeses . Ours didn’t have it :( and to be fair try a different kind .“

“Tonight, we spontaneously explored Ella’s Wood Fired Kitchen in Wareham, and I'm thrilled we did. Despite having no reservation, we were promptly seated in a cozy corner near the bar. Our server quickly attended to us, delivering refreshing waters and delightful traditional mules. The highlight was the special pomegranate margarita with reposado and pomegranate simple syrup – truly amazing. For starters, we indulged in fried pork ribs, a Caesar salad with exceptional homemade croutons that had a cheese filling and focaccia with garlic Parmesan oil dip. The generous slices of focaccia were a personal favorite and very easy to pull apart. Moving on to the main course, we savored Chicken Parm, TAGLIATELLE bolognese, the house special surf & turf with scallops, and the WOOD GRILLED NY STRIP OR 6 OZ. FILET MIGNON with smashed fingerlings, roasted onion, shishito peppers, horseradish crema, and chimichurri. The in-house-made pasta added a delightful touch, and the rave reviews for the special surf and turf almost led to a second helping. Unable to resist, we took home pizzas – margarita, three cheese pepperoni, and sausage ricotta. For dessert, we all enjoyed a pistachio toffee cake in a mason jar with pistachio gelato and dulce de leche sauce. The entire meal was a delight, and our server's kindness and excellent recommendations enhanced the experience. We're eagerly looking forward to returning, perhaps opting for seats at the bar next time. The restaurant's charming decor, candlelit ambiance, and consistently busy atmosphere make it a highly recommended dining spot.“

“The food is good , but you need to serve tentacles with the calamari not just the rings if your gonna call yourself an authentic Italian restaurant“

“Amari is the best Italian restaurant in the whole cape... chef ginaro is from Italy the Italian sauce is fantastic the seafood dishes the best, truly authentic Italian restaurant .super environment everybody is friendly the staff is great!! And remember this is the best place on Cape Cod for authentic Italian....the best👌“

“I’m truly grateful to Jimmy. Had a few hiccups lately, but as an owner, and as an AMAZING man he is I explained my issues and he listened. He’s corrected everything when I have never made a complaint ever. I’m happy to give Two Brothers my business they deserve it. I’ve never wrote a review, but I am now. Love Jimmy and his business. The fact that he listens and goes out of his way to fix it he’s AMAZING I am so grateful. We love you guys! Thank you SO much !“

“We love going to the Pine hills mama mia's, staff is friendly and food and atmosphere are always great.“

“Great food nevr left hungry been going almost 40 years!“

“We had our wedding at The Sagamore in Sandwich and it was absolutely perfect! From start to finish, Nicole Sabina and Katlyn went above and beyond to make sure everything was seamless. We had over 190 guests and not once did it ever feel overwhelming — they handled every detail flawlessly and with such professionalism. The food was incredible, our guests are still raving about it, and the energy of the night was everything we hoped for. The vibe was amazing, the space was beautiful, and once the music started, the dance floor turned into a full-on party that never slowed down. We couldn’t have asked for a better team or a better venue. Nicole, Katlyn, and The Sagamore staff truly made our wedding day unforgettable.“

“We had a wonderful dinner tonight out under the tent with our server, Grace. As always, the food and drink were fantastic. We didn’t feel rushed and enjoyed a pleasant dining experience. Thank you for another relaxing date night- we look forward to returning soon!“

“Tonight I tried Harbor Pizza for the first time since having to go gluten free- I can honestly say that that was the absolute best gluten free pizza I have ever had on the Cape! My husband and kids said their regular pizza was fantastic too- we will definitely be back!“

“I placed my first order for delivery tonight. I mainly pick our food up. We love their wings and pizza. I gave instruction on delivery. I get a text asking if they were at the correct place, I said I am in the driveway with the light on. I go out side and see no one. I go to the front of the building and our food is sitting on the ground. The delivery person text me and said they left it there cause I didn't answer my phone. Well excuse me a person has to pee. The delivery person told me I should give better instructions. Who the hell are you talking to. Told them I could not have been more clear with instructions Driveway, light will be on. The kicker is I paid on line with my card. I never add a tip online. I always tip with cash. Since my order was left on the ground and driver took off. I had no one to give a tip to. Driver lost out on a tip, but our food as always very good. I will be picking our food up after this. Delivery person very rude needs to take customer service lessons.“

“Great pizza for watching the Celtics! We order the Marc Anthony's Special - and they delivered quickly, even on a Friday night. Perfect!“

“This restaurant is the best and consistent. I got a pizza and a roast beef wrap. All was great!“