50 Best American Restaurants near Tisbury

“Excellent food and service. One of my favorites on Marthas Vineyard.“

“My favorite spot for sandwiches and pastries on the island! I’ve been coming here for years, and both the service and food have been consistently excellent. The portions are generous, so I usually have leftovers for a second meal. The last thing I had was a linguiça sandwich with plantains — it was so good that I finally went out of my way to write a review :) They’re also very accommodating toward gluten sensitivity.“

“Nomans is one of our go to places for lunch when we are on the Vineyard!“

“Breakfast sandwiches were epic. They were the best we have ever had. Huge sandwich with fresh scrambled eggs. Coffee was really good too! Hidden gem“

“Beautiful spot, amazing food, and super-friendly service!“

“Beautiful restaurant with amazing food and great staff. The vegan options are superb and absolutely delicious. Everything is presented beautifully and is super tasty. Special shout out to the sweet & spicy cucumbers which were incredible, and the home made bread is divine! This was a great choice for dining whilst in Marthas Vineyard!“

“Best burger ever!!! Came back next day and got salmon burger also excellent ! Hubby had salad with grilled chicken and even that was superb! We told our waitress both times how fantastic the meals were and that whoever is on the grill is a master. She told us his name is Randy!!! Randy if you are reading this you are the man!!“

“My husband and I just moved here and went to the Conference Table for dinner last night. We were exhausted from packing and moving and our experience at the restaurant was just perfection every way! Everyone was so friendly, our waitress was terrific, and the food was amazing! We had clam chowder and turkey club sandwiches and both were the best we’ve ever had! We’re looking forward to going back!“

“wonderful meal! great service“

“Amazing! If you are a foodie this is a must. From start to finish it is a great meal. I had the Panzanella salad, Rack of Lamb and the Blueberry Bread Pudding. It was all memorable. I am definitely telling anyone who visits to try this place“

“Great gluten free pizza and it has a few gluten free sushi options.“

“Really great view if your waiting for your ferry ride back to the mainland! Super nice people“

“We had a wonderful evening! Excellent food, great service (our waiter & Megan the sommelier we’re excellent) in MV!!!“

“I love this place! We came everyday this week and ordered a variety of delicious meals. WOW!“

“Great atmosphere friendly welcoming staff and love all your all the seafood 🦞 hugs to fluffy dog that hangs on the porch take out this year was very good come here every year“

“This is a good little restaurant, very close to the tarmac and with large viewing windows. The dishes we had were all very good--cheeseburger, chowder, and black bean & sweet potato veggie burger. Very casual. Airy, sunny interior. Lots of fun local aviation memorabilia. I'd eat here again anytime I'm in the area.“

“I had such a pleasant experience here. The restaurant has a really relaxed, easygoing atmosphere that makes it a great spot for a casual dinner. The wood-fired pizzas are definitely a standout, with a perfectly crispy crust and fresh toppings. It is a wonderful neighborhood gem that feels very welcoming.“

“🔝🔝🔝🔝🔝🔝🔝🔝🔝🔝🔝🔝🔝🔝🔝🔝🔝🔝❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️“

“spent time at this fabulous venue and enjoyed every moment, every taste, every drink in this comfortable and well designed restaurant where the staff truly love what they do and make it all about you.“

“Very friendly staff and right there whenever u need them!“

“The food, service and wine list“

“This place was absolutely amazing! Our first time dining here, and everything exceeded expectations. The ambiance, food, and service were all top tier! The eggplant was delicious, and the Chicken Marsala was incredibly tender and full of flavor. We will definitely be returning! The perfect spot to celebrate our anniversary! ❤️“

“I was very disappointed to see the brussels sprouts are now just a serving of shredded Brussels - no longer cut in half and roasted.

The fried codfish are rated top notch though, and the soup is a very good amount As a starter.
Please change the brussels sprouts back to cut in half roasted with bacon and Parmesan cheese that would be tops!
Can be very loud at times.“

“Awesome fun place!! Great food and service.“

“never again!! got served raw food, horrible service. manager was just as bad as the server. man did this place go downhill fast. I have been coming here since the eighties. I didn't even buy a tee-shirt. so overpriced. what used to be a nice little restaurant, has now become a tourist trap. so the tourist can have it. this place will not get anymore of my money. Disappointed and Done“

“Let’s talk about the best warm lobster 🦞 roll in New England!!!!“

“One of the best food experiences I’ve had.“

“I was in the area for work & stopped in not once but twice! Both times stopping in I decided to try something new. The coffee was great. The second time they were roasting the beans on site. Staff is friendly, moose pie, americano, and white mocha is great.“

“Good!Food. Great service and atmosphere!“

“Service, food, wine and ambiance was great. Highly recommend mussels, baked cod and duck confee. Thank you for a wonderful dinner.“

“After getting racist vibes from Shipwrecked restaurant, we decided to place a order and the food was delicious! I would definitely recommend coming here, and the people greeted my husband and was very nice. After the experience we had, it was nice to have someone be nice to us. Thank you for making our night.“

“If you're looking for a spot with a view, this place is hard to beat. The harbor setting is truly the highlight, providing a fantastic backdrop for a meal. The menu is heavily focused on fresh fish, which is exactly what you want when you are dining right by the water.“

“I had the Harpooned Swordfish. Best food I’ve ever had in 60 years on the planet!“

“Just had a delicious dinner, if you have never been or haven't visited in a while, you should definitely stop in!!!“

“Great food, good atmosphere and awesome bartenders and wait staff !“

“We absolutely love Katama Kitchen! We are home now and my husband just said, “Katama Kitchen has the best restaurant pancakes I’ve ever tasted!” The staff is so accommodating and it is so relaxing at the airfield. It’s the first place we’ll hit next year! Thank you so much!“

“The pros: decent burger at a decent price. I love the rolls they use. Burgers are what you want to get here, don't get distracted by the chicken wings or seafood0 it's not their Forte. If you want a side, the fries are OK but they are too pricey for me and the portions are small, I enjoy their Mac & cheese with burger in it, it'll make your eyes roll back in your head with each bite! Props on handling the crowds of people and getting the food out relatively fast, it's not easy. I also appreciate their late night hours. The cons: They won't put any burger dressings (lettuce, tomato, mayo, onion, etc.) on the side, so if you order to go, by the time you get home, the bottom half of the bun is a wet, inedible paste. Also, there's nothing to put ketchup in. No soufflé cups, no packets, so if you order fries, you have to squirt ketchup in the container the fries are in and they get - can u guess? Are you sensing a theme here? - yes, they get soggy. Maybe spend less money on the fancy to go bags and get a sleeve of 2 oz souflee cups, or gather nip bottles, anything!“

“Food is so good. And the ambience is perfect. Love this resto.“

“First time here and the food is unbelievable, the flavors are amazing and everything is very fresh! Many options and I love the drink choices also!“

“Excellent food, great choices super friendly service. Reasonably priced.The retro atmosphere and music was fantastic!“

“Wonderful people in a beautiful place!“

“Favorite place to go when we get back on the Cape!“

“Great good and good atmosphere, love the new cantina!“

“AMAZING PEOPLE AN AMAZING FOOD COME CHECK IT OUT YOU WONT BE DISSAPOINTED !!! 🔪“

“Good!Food. Great service and atmosphere!“

“Not only was the food and atmosphere great, so was the service. I suffer from a chronic illness and don’t do well with heat. When I started to not feel well, this team (led by David, I believe!) took care of me right away to cool down! They went above and beyond to help me feel better!! They even offered their establishment for me if I needed it throughout my day because of how hot it is. I cannot thank them and recommend this place enough! Know when you come here, you’re getting great food and great people! And the food was delicious too!! It was great to enjoy such a nice meal on the beach! And our waiter was fantastic.“

“After a long day of sightseeing I just wanted to sit on the beach and have dinnner with my toes in the sand and my eyes on the sunset. Picked up some tuna salad, noodles, and a gigantic cookie - and the cutest dish towel souvenir - and had the perfect ending to a fabulous day. Thank you, Black Sheep Mercantile!!“

“The yellow Curry Lentil soup!“

“Love the Newes Great atmosphere great food but what’s up with the new menu? Everyone wants the old favorites back! Fish and Chips, calamari Even the burritos from way back when Please, please bring them back! You’ll be glad you did!“