Restaurants in Middletown

Best Restaurants in Middletown

Customers` Favorites

Crabcakes
Crab Dip
Meatballs
Chicken Parm
Chicken Marsala
Lobster Ravioli
Tiramisu
Seafood Alfredo
Filet Oscar
Lasagna

“Aaron amazing server!
Food delicious, portions very generous...yum!
Aiden, an amazing service attendant, his work ethic perfect...really so enjoyed all.”

4.6 Superb469 Reviews
Aleko's Village Cafe 4304 Old National Pike, Middletown Greek • $

Customers` Favorites

Baklava
Sauce
Hummus
Vegetarian Gyro
Gyro Platter
Vegetarian Platter
Feta Fries
Gyro Salad
Sampler Platter
Falafel Platter

“Do yourself a favor and go get some yummy food!”

4.8 Superb204 Reviews

Customers` Favorites

California Burrito
Burrito Bowl
Surf and Turf Burrito
Tacos de Carne Asada
4 Piece Tacos Dorados
Torta Al Pastor
Torta De Birria
Tacos Al Pastor
Regular Burrito
Loaded Nachos

“9.7/10 California burrito 9.4/10 Surf n Turf burrito”

5 Superb40 Reviews
Black Hog BBQ 100 Middletown Pkwy Suite 208, Middletown Barbecue • $

Customers` Favorites

Ribs
French Fries
Potato Salad
Cole Slaw
BBQ Sauce
Smoked Sausage
Luke's Burger
Chilli
Cornbread 1
Rib Special

“Outstanding! I am up here for work from Florida, and as many times as I have been to Frederick, I can't believe I have not eaten here sooner. The atmosphere is wonderful! There is nothing better than the smell of smoked BBQ filling the air. Ample parking, and I love the location. The food is fantastic! I had the potato salad, sweet potatoes, and 2 meats (Arkansas Brisket which are burnt tips and Hot Links). The platter comes with pickled onions, pickles, and cornbread. It did not disappoint. Plus the original BBQ which comes with it, had an interesting flavor. Sweet and vinegary, with a little heat, which was nice. Highly recommend this place for anyone looking for some good BBQ.”

4.7 Superb140 Reviews
Tapia's on Main 203 E Main St, Middletown Pizza • $$

Customers` Favorites

Caesar Salad
Calamari
Burger and Fries
Shrimp and Scallops
Caprese
Gnocchi
Bruschetta
Cheese Pizza
Avocado Toast
Garlic Bread

“I went to Tapias On Main with my husband last weekend for the first time and it was exceptional! 5 stars for everything- the rockfish on the special menu was amazing as well as the watermelon mojito! Our server Jenna was very friendly and attentive. I will definitely be recommending this restaurant to our friends.”

4.5 Superb223 Reviews
Verona Pizzeria Town Center Plaza Shopping Center, 809 E Main St, Middletown Pizza • $

Customers` Favorites

Garlic Bread
Wings
Mozzarella Sticks
Pepperoni Pizza

“Thank you Verona for taking such incredible care of our community during this uncertain time. The food is always perfectly yummy!!! Our favorite place!”

4.4 Superb115 Reviews
The Main Cup 14 W Main St, Middletown American • $$

Customers` Favorites

Smith Island Cake
Cobb Salad
Fish and Chips
Spinach Artichoke Dip
Sweet Potato Fries
Veggie Sandwich
Blackened Chicken Tacos
Hot Crab Dip
Gyro Tacos
Pita Chips

“We have eaten here every week since 2017. It’s a great neighborhood restaurant with amazing staff and food.”

4.3 Superb314 Reviews

Customers` Favorites

Assorted Pastries
Rockfish & Chips
Fish\u0026Chips

“We were at Schroyer's Tavern for a class reunion. The food was delicious, the great. We socialized with friends then ate from a wonderful buffet! The staff members were attentive to our needs and wants! We had a fantastic and joyful evening!”

4.2 Good75 Reviews
Asian Cafe Parking 101 Garage Dr, Middletown Cafe • $

“Best vegetable lo mein I’ve had in ages, same goes for the vegetable spring rolls. Great, fast, and friendly service. No complaints about this place at all.”

3.5 Good14 Reviews
Dempseys Grille 116 W Main St, Middletown American • $

Customers` Favorites

Pancake
Corn Fritters
Hamburger
Sausage Gravy
Corned Beef Hash
Avocado Toast
Hot Cake
Beyond Burger
Cheeseburger
Reubens with French Fries Crispy Chicken Sandwich Steak and Cheese Sub with Housemade Macaroni Salad

“Everything about Dempsey’s exceeds expectations. The menu and ingredients are incredibly thoughtful. Everything down to the seasoning is made in house. The desserts are to die for - special shout out to the cheesecakes. I tried strawberry, original and blueberry - all were fantastic but the blueberry has a special place in my heart. This is an outstanding family owned and ran business that supports diversity and inclusion. They have choices for everyone - comfort food, gluten free options, diabetic options, you name it. I will certainly be back and recommend to all. Good people, good food.”

4 Good231 Reviews
Valley Grill Sports Bar 50 Glenbrook Dr, Middletown Sports Bar • $$

“First time I’ve eaten at the Valley Grille in ages and WOW! I was seriously impressed! Their new chef is crushin’ it! 👏

We asked if they’d make the “Family Combo” (12 wings, 1 lb chicken tenders, 3 cheeseburger sliders & fries) even though it’s usually just on the Sunday menu, and they did! The 5 hungry kids in our group demolished it 😂

Also… I’m a total sucker for homemade ranch, and theirs is legit so good. Creamy, flavorful, and clearly not from a bottle 🙌

The adults all ended up ordering tacos...shrimp, carne asada, el fuego pork, and Cajun fish...and every one of them was unique and packed with flavor. But the surprise star of the night was the Brisket Wedge Salad. The brisket was tender, lean, and plated beautifully. Highly recommend trying that one!

The chef even came out to check on our meal, which was such a nice touch, and our server was awesome- handling multiple tables and the bar like a pro.

I live in Glenbrook and have always wanted this spot to thrive, and it finally feels like it’s getting there. Definitely planning to check out trivia night soon!”

3.1 Average70 Reviews
Cinco de Mayo - Middletown 200 Middletown Pkwy, Middletown Mexican • $

Customers` Favorites

Chicken Taco Salad
One Quesadilla and One Enchilada
Shrimp Quesadilla
Salsa and Chips
Super Burrito
Birria Tacos
Shrimp Tacos
Taco Combos
Chori Pollo

“We had an excellent meal here today! The service was fast and pleasant, the food was outstanding and when I asked for a to-go box they brought me an extra bag of chips to take with me. We will be back!!”

3.6 Good148 Reviews
Asian Cafe 7 N Church St, Middletown Chinese • $

Customers` Favorites

Chicken Teriyaki
Orange Chicken
Coconut Curry Shrimp
Hot and Sour Soup
Beef Rice Noodle
Curry Chicken
TSO's Chicken
Sweet

“Every time I go to my beach house in Ocean City it’s a tradition for me to stop here and get food when I’m coming home to Middletown love this place always friendly always great food I highly recommend it to anyone great value they give you plenty to eat”

3.4 Good135 Reviews
Domino's Pizza 4316 Old National Pike Ste B, Middletown Pizza • $

“Great small town pizza shop that has been in town for decades. Everyone is very friendly and the pizzas are great. So glad to have a staple like Domino's in our small town!”

2.8 Average97 Reviews

More Restaurants in Middletown

Customers` Favorites

Bakery

“A delightful stop for a relaxing cuppa and breakfast”

4.9 Superb105 Reviews

Customers` Favorites

Bakery
Croissant
Baklava
Morning Bun Blueberrygalette
Peanut Butter Cup Pie
Asparagus Gouda
Apple Hand
Crab Quiche
Baked Pies
Bear Claw

“Well worth the trip from NOVA. Cannot believe the taste. European quality, dough you die for and the flavors unreal. Great people will answer any questions about the pastry. Opened only Thursday to Saturday. When they sell out closes early then so don’t wait until late afternoon to get there. Service quick.”

4.9 Superb166 Reviews
More Ice Cream 13 W Main St, Middletown Ice Cream Shop • $

Customers` Favorites

Ice Cream Cone

“Very good local small business.”

4.6 Superb104 Reviews
South Mountain Creamery 8305 Bolivar Rd, Middletown Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt • $$

“A great out of the way place for children AND adults to learn a little about dairy farm life and to satisfy their ice cream sweet tooth but also those who want/need natural dairy products.
While not a complaint, in my own recent experience, they were so busy that the ice cream freezer lids had to kept open which produced a very soft and runny result. That, combined with the hot weather, meant I rapidly had a thin, though very tasty, shake!😋🤣”

4.1 Good325 Reviews

Get more info in our app

Download app for free

Open