5 Best American Restaurants near Castine

“We had the opportunity to spend a night and enjoy a delicious dinner at the Pentagoet Inn and Pub. The Inn is gorgeous and the owners have thought of every detail. The pub and restaurant were outstanding. We would highly recommend this little piece of coastal, historic Maine.“

“The food, atmosphere, and vibes were all incredible! Wife had the ahi tuna, which was seared perfectly and she said it was some of the best fish she’s had in forever. High praise coming from Portland! I had the tofu stir fry which was also amazing. One of the better dishes I’ve had on the Blue Hill Peninsula, especially for a quick lunch.

Kermit was great and it was fun seeing the folks from town come in and banter with him a bit! You can tell he cares a lot about the restaurant and his community. Reminded me of my dad. Pure New England. Not the most talkative guy, but had a heart of gold.

Don’t believe the negative reviewers. They’re already back to being sad in their Connecticut mansions. Go and taste for yourself. You won’t be disappointed!“

“Great service and food was amazing! You really need to experience this gem!“

“Always delicious!! love coming here every summer!!“

“The Stonington room was clean and decorated well. Both of Oakland's private beaches had beautiful views and were so peaceful.“