New American Restaurants in Mackinac Island, MI

Browse menus, reviews and photos of New American Restaurants in Mackinac Island.

Showing 11 of 11 restaurants

  • Kingston Kitchen at the Village Inn 1384 Hoban Street, Mackinac Island American · $$

    1 Kingston Kitchen at the Village Inn

    4.6 Superb 526 Reviews

    1384 Hoban Street, Mackinac Island

    • Take-Out
    • Delivery

    Customers’ favorites

    • Mackinac Planked Whitefish
    • Jonkanoo Jerk Beef Tips
    • Boom Boom Cheese Balls
    • Jamaican Fried Chicken

    “Great food! An unexpected find in the U.P.!”

  • Pink Pony 7221 Main Street Suite 103, Mackinac Island Bar & Grill · $$

    2 Pink Pony

    4.5 Superb 778 Reviews

    7221 Main Street Suite 103, Mackinac Island

    • Take-Out
    • Delivery

    Customers’ favorites

    • Michigan Apple & Goat Cheese Salad
    • Michigan Apple & Goat Cheese Salad
    • Beer Battered Whitefish & Chips
    • Chippewa Broiled Whitefish

    “We really enjoyed eating here . And we are very thankful to our nice server Cornell for giving us a great service. And we enjoyed our appetizers that we ordered.”

  • Mary's Bistro Draught House 7463 Main Street, Mackinac Island American · $$

    3 Mary's Bistro Draught House

    4.3 Superb 551 Reviews

    7463 Main Street, Mackinac Island

    • Take-Out
    • Delivery

    Customers’ favorites

    • Draught House Soft Pretzels with House-Made Horseradish-Beer Cheese
    • Mary's Famous Crispy Chicken Tendies
    • Pulled Pork Grilled Cheese
    • Homestyle Chicken Pot Pie

    “I was camping at Wilderness and thought I would spend a night on the Island. I was checking 906 for activities and seen a young female musician playing at your Bistro so I reserved a table for dinner with the hope of seeing some Upnorth music. As what usually happens with plans that did not take place as the Lions were playing and the artist was rescheduled, I believe. Your Hostess and Waitress were very professional young women. The waitress was very knowledgeable and helpful. The food was excellent, Squash Risotto was very good as was the carrot cake with homemade ice cream, with a couple Guinness.”

  • Cannonball Oasis 7641 British Landing Road, Mackinac Island Fast Food · $

    4 Cannonball Oasis

    4.3 Superb 221 Reviews

    7641 British Landing Road, Mackinac Island

    • Take-Out

    Customers’ favorites

    • Hot Dogs Chili Dogs Cheese Dogs & Chili
    • Chicken Strips and Fries
    • Welcome Ice Cream Break
    • Chili Dog and Fries

    “The food is always awesome! My husband literally has talked about it since last year! He finally got his hamburger and fries he waited a year for and i got the pasta salad. We loved it!!!”

  • Winchester's Whiskey & Bourbon Room 7416 Main Street, Mackinac Island American · $$

    5 Winchester's Whiskey & Bourbon Room

    4.2 Good 225 Reviews

    7416 Main Street, Mackinac Island

    • Take-Out

    Customers’ favorites

    • Buffalo Chicken Bacon & Ranch Flatbread
    • Buffalo Chicken Bacon & Ranch Flatbread
    • Crispy Brussel Sprout Chips
    • Salted Maple Old Fashioned

    “Great food and drinks !! Our waitress was amazing for the second year !!”

  • Village Inn Suites 1384 Hoban Street, Mackinac Island American · $$

    6 Village Inn Suites

    4.2 Good 88 Reviews

    1384 Hoban Street, Mackinac Island

    • Take-Out

    “We have made Kingston Kitchen an annual dinner location while visiting Mackinac Island. The jerk chicken fettuccine alfredo is a must!! My husband had the bbq fried chicken and is still talking about how great it was! Great food plus a friendly atmosphere with a great waitstaff. Highly recommended.”

  • Bistro On The Greens One Lake Shore Drive, Mackinac Island American · $$

    7 Bistro On The Greens

    4.1 Good 224 Reviews

    One Lake Shore Drive, Mackinac Island

    • Take-Out

    Customers’ favorites

    • Parmesan Truffle Fries
    • Oven Roasted Chicken
    • Whitefish Sandwich
    • Burger & Fries

    “We really enjoyed Bistro on the Greens. The fish was very well prepared and delicious. The setting is beautiful, with outdoor tables overlooking the golf course and the lake, and a nice breeze coming off the water. It’s only about a half-mile walk from downtown, but it feels completely different—you can escape the busy downtown crowds and enjoy a very peaceful lunch or dinner. A wonderful place to relax and enjoy a good meal!”

  • Woods Restaurant and Bobby's Bar 8655 Cudahy Circle, Mackinac Island American · $$$

    8 Woods Restaurant and Bobby's Bar

    4.1 Good 318 Reviews

    8655 Cudahy Circle, Mackinac Island

    Customers’ favorites

    • Herb Crusted Elk Chop Potato Pave Fall Vegetables
    • Pan Roasted Steelhead Trout
    • Pan-Roasted Duck Breast
    • Spiced Honey Duck Breast

    “Beautiful ride up and amazing dinner atmosphere”

  • Grand Hotel Main Dining Room Mackinac Island Fine Dining · $$$$

    9 Grand Hotel Main Dining Room

    3.7 Good 58 Reviews

    Mackinac Island

    “We very much enjoyed our time at The Grand Hotel. The front porch was amazing for afternoon drinks and relaxing. Shout out to James Tan, our absolute favorite server! We stayed at The Grand with friends for a week! We enjoyed meals at the Jockey Club and loved The Woods!! The staff was mostly attentive, I think the concierge team could do a bit better at being nice. The only complaint I have is dinner in the main dining room. We wanted the experience and got all dolled up one night. Drinks on the porch were great! Dinner was terrible and the service was terrible. I understand it’s a commitment and that’s part of the experience, but our waiter never came around and asked how our meals were after serving us and waited too long between courses. I could see him having a good time laughing and flirting with a coworker when he should have been attending to his patrons. I would recommend The Grand! We absolutely had an amazing week. I would never have dinner in the main dining room again. There are too many great restaurants on the island. You don’t need to settle for bad food and service.”

  • Chianti One Lake Shore Drive, Mackinac Island Fine Dining · $$$$

    10 Chianti

    4.0 Good 310 Reviews

    One Lake Shore Drive, Mackinac Island

    Customers’ favorites

    • Pistachio Cream Cheesecake
    • Saffron Honey Chocolate
    • Green Apple Mousse
    • Foie Bone Marrow

    “We just got married at Mission Point on July 4, 2025 and had the best experience!! Julie Suddon and Charlotte Mills and the entire staff were incredible. Julie was super responsive and sweet from start to finish. Super easy to work with and just a nice person. She transitioned us to Charlotte Mills to do the actual planning and the transition was super smooth with tons of communication. Charlotte was equally impressive. Her communication was great from start to finish as well and fantastic for our rehearsal and the day of the wedding. Just super smooth from touring to actually getting married. We were so thankful for the wonderful and professional communication which eased any stress we could’ve otherwise had! We are so happy we decided to choose Mission Point and recommend anyone do the same if looking to get married on Mackinac Island!! Food was great, bartender was great, the vendors were chose were all on the suggested vendor list which made things super, super easy! Just so smooth, cannot say that enough! Thank you for making our wedding day perfect and for making the planning so fun and easy! Julia and Chris McAlpine❤️”

  • The Jockey Club 1 Grand Avenue, Mackinac Island Seafood · $$$$

    11 The Jockey Club

    3.6 Good 208 Reviews

    1 Grand Avenue, Mackinac Island

    • Take-Out

    Customers’ favorites

    • Wood-Grilled Filet Mignon
    • Tomato Basil Soup

    “Great dining location, very cozy and comfortable. Excellent food choices.”

New American Restaurants Nearby