11 Best American Restaurants in Mackinac Island

Kingston Kitchen at the Village Inn American • $$
1384 Hoban St, Mackinac Island

Customers` Favorites

Mackinac Planked Whitefish
Jonkanoo Jerk Beef Tips
Boom Boom Cheese Balls
Jamaican Fried Chicken
Calypso Pork Sandwich
Jamaican Jerk Chicken
Coconut Curry Chicken
Jerk Chicken Sandwich
Westmoreland Risotto
Caribbean Calamari

“We went here twice during our three days on the island. Food delicious and service was great. It was a bright spot to find something different in comparison all the other typical pub fare on the island. Highly recommend!“

4.6 Superb209 Reviews
Village Inn Suites American • $$
1384 Hoban St, Mackinac Island

“We went here twice during our three days on the island. Food delicious and service was great. It was a bright spot to find something different in comparison all the other typical pub fare on the island. Highly recommend!“

4.7 Superb54 Reviews
Winchester's Whiskey & Bourbon Room American • $$
7416 Main St, Mackinac Island

Customers` Favorites

Buffalo Chicken Bacon & Ranch Flatbread
Crispy Brussel Sprout Chips
Salted Maple Old Fashioned
Strawberry Rhubarb Lowball
Warm Soft Pretzel Bites
Smoked Brisket Poutine
Brussels Sprout Chips
White Fish and Chips
The Bicycle Burger
Pub Pretzel Sticks

“Great food and drinks !! Our waitress was amazing for the second year !!“

4.3 Superb92 Reviews
The Gate House American • $$
1547 Cadotte Ave, Mackinac Island

Customers` Favorites

Smoked Whitefish and Clam Chowder
Grilled Cheese and Fries
Crispy Chicken Sandwich
Bacon-Cheddar Burger
Grilled Lamb Burger
Gate House Nachos
Mac Daddy Burger
Brisket Nachos
Grilled Cheese
Warm Crab Dip

“relaxing atmosphere.good food“

4.1 Good119 Reviews
Pink Pony Bar & Grill • $$
7221 Main St #103, Mackinac Island

Customers` Favorites

Michigan Apple & Goat Cheese Salad
Beer Battered Whitefish & Chips
Chippewa Broiled Whitefish
Honey Brie Apple Flatbread
Honey Apple Brie Flatbread
BBQ Pulled Pork Sandwich
Whitefish Beurre Blanc
Wild Mushroom Risotto
Prime Rib French Dip
Smoked Whitefish Dip

“I’ve had going to the Pink Pony on my “bucket” list for ages now! I finally was able to check it off! It was such a fun atmosphere, but our server Lauren, made it INCREDIBLE!!!! She was funny, quick with drinks/food and made sure to build a connection with us even though it was hotter than heck out and she was running her butt off. Lauren is an amazing asset to the Pink Pony!!“

4.5 Superb409 Reviews
Woods Restaurant American • $$$
8655 Cudahy Cir, Mackinac Island

Customers` Favorites

Herb Crusted Elk Chop Potato Pave Fall Vegetables
Pan Roasted Steelhead Trout
Pan-Roasted Duck Breast
Spiced Honey Duck Breast
Domestic Rack of Lamb
Bavarian Soft Pretzel
Grilled Filet Mignon
Great Wine Selection
Escargot En Croute
Hungarian Goulash

“Beautiful ride up and amazing dinner atmosphere“

3.8 Good89 Reviews
Cannonball Oasis Fast Food • $
7641 British Landing Rd, Mackinac Island

Customers` Favorites

Hot Dogs Chili Dogs Cheese Dogs & Chili
Welcome Ice Cream Break
Chili Dog and Fries
Deep Fried Pickles
Chili Cheese Fries
Mozzarella Sticks
Soft Pretzel
French Fries
Onion Rings
Cheeseburger

“The food is always awesome! My husband literally has talked about it since last year! He finally got his hamburger and fries he waited a year for and i got the pasta salad. We loved it!!!“

4.5 Superb71 Reviews
Mustang Lounge Lounges • $
1485 Astor St, Mackinac Island

Customers` Favorites

Porky Mac and Cheese
Crispy Shrimp Basket
BBQ Brisket Burger
Mustang Burger
Fish and Chips
Boneless Wings
Pulled Pork
Tater Tots
Patty Melt
Quesadilla

“We chose this tavern as it states it's the most historic tavern. I guess I was expecting it to look more historic on the inside. Decor was OK: Paneling, tvs, video (gambling?) machines. The service was excellent, as was the food: boneless wings, tavern burger and fries and baked potato soup. The hot apple cider was sweet and so good!“

4.3 Superb150 Reviews
Great Turtle Brewery & Distillery Distilleries • $$
1359 Hoban St, Mackinac Island

Customers` Favorites

Braised Short Rib Grilled Cheese
The Legendary Chicken Sandwich
Painted Turtle Cocktail Flight
Parmesan Brussels Sprouts
Brewery Fish and Chips
Giant Bavarian Pretzel
Cherry Gose Sour Beer
The Painted Turtle
Summer Berry Flight
Burger and Fries

“A great place to sit and sample some great brews while waiting for your ferry.“

4.1 Good188 Reviews
The Straits American •
8593 Cudahy Cir, Mackinac Island

“Wonderful dinner! We tried everything. From the New York Strip, to the whitefish to the Wagyu burger, it was all amazing. The property itself is beautiful and we enjoyed the sunset over looking Lake Huron. Angus took the best care of us and we look forward to seeing him next year!“

3 Average2 Reviews
The Jockey Club at the Grand Stand Seafood • $$
1 Grand Avenue, Mackinac Island

Customers` Favorites

Wood-Grilled Filet Mignon
Tomato Basil Soup

“Great dining location, very cozy and comfortable. Excellent food choices.“

3.3 Good69 Reviews