11 Best American Restaurants in Saugatuck

“Always a great time. The best staff around.“

“Sat up top and enjoyed great food, drinks, and a view with friends!“

“excellent fried chicken spicy 1“

“The waiter was very good. My cba sandwich was excellent. It was made just the way I asked!!!“

“Best food best bartender!!!“

“Stopped into Spectators in Saugatuck and discovered the Pot Roast Sandwich special—pure magic! Tender, slow-roasted beef just like grandma’s, with zesty caper mayo, caramelized onions, and a soft, fresh bun. Comfort food meets gourmet—don’t walk, RUN to try it!“

“We are in Saugatuck on vacation and have eaten here three times because it simply is the best place we’ve found to eat in Saugatuck. Food is fresh, creative, and so tasty. The Mediterranean couscous salad and Brussel kale Caesar are beyond delicious. The Maui sandwich was superb. Today my hubby got the burger and said it was the best burger he has ever eaten. The wait staff were professional, friendly, and attentive each time we dined there. This is a must try in Saugatuck. In a sea of restaurants serving the same tired menus, Pumpernickels is unique and delicious.“

“Be nice there are younger people who work here . Probably their first job . Very cute concept. Plenty of outdoor seating(picnic tables) Prices are cheaper than most restaurants downtown. A little slower than i thought it would be . I did order online to got there & my order wasn’t ready yet in which. They explained why and made up for it. They do charge a small fee for ordering online. Super sweet staff. Although I do believe my sandwich had the wrong cheese . It was still decent I mean it is a grilled cheese shack not a 5 star bouji restaurant . If you want something simple & quick for the most part. They do have corn hole boards as well. I’d definitely come here if you have little ones who can’t sit still in a restaurant. Small variety . But it’s a grilled cheese. If you have a bigger order prepare to wait .“

“The Sicilian pizza… might be the best pizza I’ve ever had in my life.“

“Noah our bartender/server was fantastic! We would go back just to visit with him!! #noahsark“

“Sat outside for lunch and watched the world go by while we enjoyed our salads. I had the gorgonzola salad, and my cousin had the smoked salmon salad. I was so happy to learn they locally sourced everything. Our salad was from a farm in Caledonia, MI, and the salmon came from Big O's and live caught in the Great Lakes. Everything was delicious, and our server was amazing. Definitely recommend!“