13 Best American Restaurants near Mayer

“My family and I have been enjoying a little staycation this week at a farmhouse Airbnb just outside Cologne. It’s been a nice reminder that you don’t have to travel far to have a great summer. My daughter has spent the week chasing chickens around the property and loving every minute of it.

Even on vacation I’m still working every day. As a Realtor, I’ve done business throughout Mayer over the years, and a few years back I almost bought the property across the street from Knuckleheads with plans to turn it into a small Airbnb. It wasn’t meant to be, but I’ve found myself driving through town regularly ever since.

After passing Knuckleheads countless times—especially on Tuesday nights with the Harleys lined up outside—I finally stopped in with my family.

We arrived toward the tail end of the live music. The patio was still full when we got there, but by the time we left around 9:00, the crowd had started to thin out—which is when I snapped the photo of my daughter enjoying the last few songs.

The musician was a phenomenal guitarist and singer, and the atmosphere made it easy to settle in for the evening.

We ordered burgers, cheese curds, and waffle fries. The waffle fries were outstanding, and what really made the visit was the staff. Vicky and Jenny were personable, attentive, and did a great job taking care of everyone on a busy night.

It’s easy to see why this place has become a local favorite. Between the patio, the music, and the people, we’ll definitely be back the next time we’re in Mayer.

— Geoffrey Serdar“

“Hillcrest has the best chicken dinner! Had my husband's birthday catered. Served about 100 people. Had many compliments on the food. And very reasonably priced. Would recommend highly.“

“I had a great experience at Northside. I felt at home when I walked int the door. The food was amazing and portions gargantuan . Had enough to enjoy another meal at home. The server was delightful and you could see that she enjoyed her job. Highly recommend this gem!“

“Drive up lane was full as our most in these times but the wait staff came out and moved a few of us vehicles to the front of the restaurant and took our orders, then delivered food. I was out of there in less than 9 minutes! Awesome!“

“What a great Restaurant! The Brunch was absolutely awesome! So many options. The ribs were fall off the bone. Our Waitress was so sweet and polite! I highly recommend B’s on the River! :)“

“Great atmosphere, food and drinks, love coming in for a great time and feel 10/10 would recommend“

“We’ve been to Iron Tap a few times and it never disappoints! Today we went to celebrate my son’s heavenly 3rd birthday. Initially we were okay and my daughter seemed fine but within a few minutes she decided she didn’t want to be there… the owner (or really awesome and amazing bartender) came to our rescue and offered us dinosaurs and another area to sit so my 1.5 year old could move and not bug anyone. She didn’t know us or our situation, just saw an overstimulated mother. I wish there was more I could do, because you made our celebration so special. Thank you!“

“Are the menu prices accurate? The prices seem very reasonable if they are.“

“Great food and swift service.“

“Amazing food, service and a Lakeview“

“Das Güt 💯. We love when there are fellow businesses that value great customer service! Thank you Pounders! Top Notch!“

“Its affordable very nice resturant. And the food is good. And the service is good. Its off back behind other bussiness. You really have to look to find it. But if you use your phone to navigate to find this resturant. Yes it cost money. But you pay for what you order. But like I said the food is good. And it's a quite place. Alot of families do go there to eat. And you get your money's worth. Its a nice country resturant. And the bathrooms are clean. I dont have any complaints.thank you. Katrin“

“today i came in with a man in a wheel chair with special needs you all were so wonderful and helpful with us.. thank you so much“