10 Best Bakeries in Ofallon

Pie on the Fly Bakery •
614 N Main St, O'Fallon

Customers` Favorites

Key Lime Pie

“My husband and I used Pie on the Fly for our wedding at the end of September, and we had such a great experience! We ordered mini cheesecakes and brownies and they were an absolute hit! We were able to customize the flavors we wanted and even picked out the wrappers they were in to match our wedding colors! Not only were they great, but they are reasonably priced as well. This is a family owned shop that truly cares about their craft and it shows! We will definitely be back and use them again if we ever have another event! Thank you so much!“

5 Superb48 Reviews
Susie G's Specialty Cakes Bakery • $$
2679 State Hwy K, O'Fallon

Customers` Favorites

Gooey Butter Brownie
Birthday Cake
Cupcakes
Cakes

“I ordered a very last minute cake for a birthday party. I sent a picture and wording that I wanted on the cake. They not only were able to make it in the time I needed by also designed it by using a picture I found and the wording I wanted. This is the most beautiful cake I have ever ordered and it tasted even better. This cake turned out so much better than I had imagined and it was so delicious! I have found my new place for specialty cakes!“

5 Superb34 Reviews
Sweet Spot Cake Shoppe Bakery •
1120 Technology Dr Suite 120, O'Fallon

Customers` Favorites

Pastries and More
Wedding Cake
Cakes

“I ordered a cake with not a ton of notice - it was a yellow cake with chocolate buttercream. I needed photos of my bosses face cut out and put on the cake - it was amazing! Not only was the cake decorated nicely and looked just how I wanted it, but it was delicious. Such a hit - I will for sure come here again! Side note - walking into the shop, it smelled so amazing of all of the beautiful cakes, cookies and other desserts - loved it!“

4.9 Superb44 Reviews
The COOKIE Box Bakery • $
2443 State Hwy K, O'Fallon

Customers` Favorites

Peanut Butter Chocolate Chip Cookie

“These cookies don’t have any business being THIS GOOD!! My goodness! ??My husband’s favorite is the Butter Brickle! My new favorite is the Golden Oreo. Ohh my goodnesssss!!These cookies are melt in your mouth yumminess and let’s not even mention when you put them in the microwave for about 10 seconds…whew!! Try this place out!The owner ain’t too bad either! ? “

4.9 Superb35 Reviews
Temmtations by Wedding Wonderland Bakery • $
3449 Pheasant Meadow Dr #108, O'Fallon

Customers` Favorites

Birthday Cake
Wedding Cake

“I am visiting a friend from out of town and we stopped by to see what sort of sweet treats we wanted to have at home. This beautiful shop is full of an abundance of tempting treats for those looking for special desserts/snacks/treats for any occasion. We ended up grabbing some cake pops, pineapple upside-down cake, gooey butter cake, and chocolate-covered Oreos. The gooey-butter cake was absolutely amazing—gooey, sweet, rich and decadent! If you love this cake, grab a piece for yourself. I have had one of the cake-pops (milk-chocolate covered banana cake), and it was absolutely delicious! The chocolate had a nice crack to it and the banana cake was moist and had a nice, strong natural banana flavor. The pineapple upside down cake (sold in individual large squares) was moist, covered with a nice crunch of crystallized sugar with a cherry on top, and was just amazing. Also highly recommend! Haven’t tried the other items, but will report back when I do. There are also crunchy dog treats for your fur baby available for sale, which we are saving for our next visit with friends who have a dog. This place is full of gorgeous wedding cakes, as well as cupcakes, the latter of which we will need to review after we return at a later date to try them. There is a reason this shop won the 4th season of The Next Great Baker…you need to visit and see for yourself. Highly recommend this fantastic bakery!!“

4.6 Superb40 Reviews
CRUSHED SUGAR Bakery •
2956 State Hwy K, O'Fallon

Customers` Favorites

Toffee Pretzel Chocolate Chip Cookie
Chocolate Chip Cookie Sandwich
Snickerdoodle Puppy Chow
Gooey Butter Cake
Confetti Cookie
Pecan Pie Bar

“This place is AMAZING!!!! 12/10!! The treats and desserts are so carefully thought out and created. I have never had a bite of anything I didn’t like. I order for multiple holidays a year and the owner is always very willing to work with me and my requests! She has the cutest paint your own cookies for my kids that they love! The pecan bars are one of my all-time favorites! The perfect amount of gooey stickiness that they should be with the perfect combination of crust. Another personal favorite is the pop tarts when they are made, WOW! The owner also does cookie decorating classes around the holidays that are so much fun for families or even a girls night out.I highly recommend Crushed Sugar and look forward to seeing them this year at the LSL market!“

4.3 Superb22 Reviews
PJ's Cookies Bakery •
419 Covered Bridge Ln, O'Fallon

“PJ's Coffee on Highway K in O'Fallon serves food that is absolutely delicious, in a pleasant atmosphere, with friendly employees whose work ethic and knowledge of their products is excellent. My wife and I stopped by for coffee and beignets (mostly for the beignets for me) and we're thrilled that we finally are aware of a local (close by) place that serves these New Orleans delicacies...mmmm are they good! We will visit more often now that we had such a great experience today! We encourage you to give them a try - breakfast sandwiches, scones, and much more!“

4.3 Superb13 Reviews
Sweetology Bakery • $$
2550 State Hwy K Hutchings Farm Shopping Plaza, O'Fallon

“My daughter and I met some friends at this location on December 29th. This was the second time we have been, but the first as a walk in. The other time had been during a birthday party, which was fun as well. The ladies working this day were very friendly and helpful. The lady who gave us instructions was very informative and great at communicating what we needed to do. I do not remember her name, but she did have glasses on. They had all the tools we needed to decorate all of our treats, cupcakes and cookies. Gloves came in handy for sure! My only suggestion is to possibly have a way to rinse out the decorating tips, as most of them got used more than once. It took lots of time to try and get out the previous color before being able to move on to the next color. Also, paper towels would've helped with lots of things during our decorating process as well. I was given them, after asking for some. I can definitely appreciate a place where you can go have a good time with family, and not have to worry about cleaning up afterwards! Thank you for providing this cool place, and for taking care of the mess afterwards! We will be back!“

4.3 Superb11 Reviews
Sophie's Bakery Bakery •
3010 Winghaven Blvd, O'Fallon

“Their baked goods have helped my husband and me keep our weight loss for two years. There is nothing "diet" about the taste. Everything we've tried is delicious and satisfying. The automatic reorder service makes it convenient too.“

4.4 Superb7 Reviews
Made Today Cafe & Bakery Breakfast • $
107 O'Fallon Plaza, O'Fallon

Customers` Favorites

Biscuits & Gravy Pancakes and Hash Browns
French Toast with Eggs and Bacon
Blueberry Pancakes
Two Egg Breakfast
Sausage

“Know going in, that's it's going to be a slower than other breakfast spots, plan for an hour to get in and out. They are a small shop and there's usually just 2-3 people working.That said.The food is incredible. The breakfasts are outstanding, the bakery and deserts are also amazing.“

4 Good33 Reviews
Loading...
map Map