36 Best Pizza Restaurants in Fayetteville

“My experience at Old Chicago (Fayetteville) was great. The food is delicious. Conrad is awesome. One of the best waiters I’ve had in. Long time.“

“Not flashy but great home cooked food and service excellent... well worth the wait if needed.. try the grilled biscuits!!!“

“We couldn’t choose so we had both! 😋Donair/Greek. Good job Pizza Time 👍“

“Best Pizza in Fayetteville everyday!“

“As an Italian (born and raised), I can say with absolute confidence that this is the only place in Fayetteville that makes REAL italian food.
If you come here expecting to eat gigantic portions of fettuccine Alfredo, pepperoni pizza or garlic bread dipped in butter, know that you will be disappointed. For that you can go to Olive Garden or all other restaurants cosplaying as “Italian” around here. But if you want to experience the real italian cuisine and especially Neapolitan pizza this is definitely the place! It is like a home away from home 🏡“

“Tried the Mellow Mushroom for the first time on June 18 at this location. Food was decent. Waitress was super awesome (lady with dress, tattoos, and nose piercing). Restaurants with good food are easy to find, but it's not always easy to find places with legendary staff. Well done! :)“

“I went last week after receiving a menu in the mail. I told the owner it was my first time there. He was super nice and funny, top notch in customer service. He gave me a slice of pizza to try while I waited and it was DELICIOUS. I got a calzone which was the best I've ever had. The dough wasn't real thick like many places make theirs so I could taste the filling without being overpowered with dough. This will forever be my to go spot for pizza and calzones. I shop at that Walmart all the time but have never looked at the businesses in the shopping center. I'm so happy I got the menu advertisement in the mail.“

“Come and enjoy Marco’s Pizza!! Great Deals especially buy one get one free every Tuesday.“

“The customer service was not the best. The manager was talking to the employee as she was talking to me and had to ask me my name twice. Because she was all into their conversation and forgot my name.
The pizza is better than the flatzz. The flazz really didn't have flavor.“

“My son and I walked here because it is close to our neighborhood. we sat in and enjoyed a nice lunch with friendly service, some nice tunes playing, and great pizza!“

“I don't know why I've never reviewed Dinos before now. I honestly love their pizza and wings. I don't think that I have had a better cook wing in my immediate area. I always choose well done since they are normally pretty meaty and their buffalo and garlic Parm are both really good. Their pizza has a homemade crust, like freshly made and fresh toppings. Once again I choose well done x normal. They don't add a lot of sauce which is good for me. The owner is super sweet and anytime I've had an issue, they take care of it with no complaint. If you're looking to support a local place, this is it. They also have grinders but I have never tried them.“

“Clearly the new management appreciates their customers! Great food, service and prices!!! Can’t wait to eat more Hungry Howie’s at this location!!! Yummy 😋“

“Love coming here me and my friends the food is fantastic. It is cooked with love. It is so full of flavor. You always get a large portion and it is delivered to your table hot the waitresses are so friendly nice and smiling to the best ones you could ever find you’re always welcome there feel like you’re You’re at home on a Sunday dinner I recommend this for everyone if you want a nice home cooked meal, friendly atmosphere and beautiful smiles from these ladies you must go.“

“I love this place. I took my girlfriend here for our first date and for Valentine’s Day, and it delivered both times. The vibe is always on point. Even when the place is packed to the walls, the servers stay friendly like they’ve got unlimited patience on tap.

The music is legit Italian, they hand out roses like they got a florist in the back, and honestly the whole atmosphere feels like the kind of spot that helps seal the deal for any date night.

I’m already looking forward to my next visit—this place hasn’t missed yet.“

“Hands-down, absolutely amazing. The staff is amazing. The manager is absolutely amazing. It’s clean and tidy, and they treat their customers so well so happy With this location!“

“Good Pizza, But Please Cut It Right

Rudino’s consistently delivers decent, reliable pizza. The crust is solid, the toppings are fresh, and overall it’s a good go-to spot when I want something satisfying.

That said, the one thing that keeps them from being an easy five-star choice is surprisingly simple: they just don’t cut the pizza the way I request. I’ve asked multiple times for it to be cut a specific way, and the instructions seem to get ignored every time. It’s not a dealbreaker, but it is frustrating—especially when you’re ordering for kids or a group and need the slices a certain way.

If Rudino’s can dial in their attention to special instructions, they’d be one of my top spots. Until then, the food is good… but the follow-through needs work.“

“Hunt Brothers Pizza is a great pizza for anybody searching for really good tasting food the employees are always very respectful their Pizza is also never undercooked or overcooked it is always just right with a perfect amount of toppings“

“We had some good Pizza and other things like wings, cinnamon pretzels, the sandwhiches, and pastabowls. Most all of the options there is gonna be good eats. It's better to order and go because there's no dining inside to note, just a few chairs to sit down on and wait for your food. It's not like Elizabeth's pizza down in elizabethtown though lol.

Parking: It's on the front of the plaza. All you can do is walk in and order or wait outside for takeout if you ordered it. There is no way to dine-in here.

Kid-friendliness: Not at all. Lots of traffic around, and no seats or things inside for them to do.

Wheelchair accessibility: The sidewalk is the same level as the street in some spots.“

“The young lady that was at the register was extremely rude. The food was as good as it looks. I ordered 1 Large pizza, 1 Large calzone, and 3 chocolate chip cookies. The calzone was raw on the inside. The crust to the pizza was very hard to chew. The cookies were okay. I would not recommend any food to anyone. My husband and I have tried their food a lot and each time the calzone is under cooked. Try at your own risk.

***UPDATE
They changed the person behind the register!! The woman that was there today was very courteous, quick, and efficient. Apparently their power had just turned back on when I placed my order. She made our food without missing a beat and provided wonderful customer service. The food looked and tasted much better than last time. We bought a small buffalo chicken pizza and a large calzone.“

“The food was good first time there the guy James was very nice and friendly“

“I would personally give this place 4 out of 5 stars the pizza is always good and greasy and the pepperoni is always fantastic I come by here maybe twice a month. However I was shocked today when I was told I needed to pay a quarter for service water when I just tipped them 3 dollars for the food needless to say I won’t be eating here as frequently because of that experience I know it’s petty but I don’t carry quarters and I didn’t want to put 25 cents on my credit card.“

“Hunt Brothers Pizza is a great pizza for anybody searching for really good tasting food the employees are always very respectful their Pizza is also never undercooked or overcooked it is always just right with a perfect amount of toppings“

“I had an online order that was accidentally voided. I went in to get my order and was told it was ordered. Ms Mia was very nice and apologetic, she had someone help take my large order to my car, and I got a better discount. She made my experience so much better and worth the wait. Thank you!“

“I’ve always loved this location (McPherson Church Rd) and I just wanted to say that they are amazing and such sweet, kind and caring people work there! We enjoy going with our kids! Always a good experience!“

“The guy that was putting in the pizza in the oven. Was not wearing a glove with the hand he used to put the pizza in the oven. His other hand had a glove?“

“Helpful and friendly exceeding the standard
The girl behind the bar offered to use her own personal money to help a dad who had a stuffed animal get stuck in the claw machine for his daughter unfortunately I didn't get her name“

“Great food and service! Awesome dining area and selections of food choices!“

“Bubba's 33 never disappoints dine in or pick always good food and good service 5 stars plus“

“We ordered some pizza online and it was taking a while so I called and I wasn't expecting them to answer but they answered right away and explained they were short staffed having only 2 people working. So I understood and they ended up coming a few minutes later and it was delicious! So the fact they were working extra hard they still brought us the food and made it delicious. He was also very nice and professional.“

“Every time I get delivery or take out I always get it on time. The driver always follows directions never lost. Anytime I get take out too they are always nice super fast and always communicative about the time. Obviously the best part is the pizza never burnt or messed up order when I receive my order. The manager I usually see on duty who deserves a big shout along with his crew is Bryson, huge thanks to those guys.“

“We have been working in Fayetteville for 6 months. We stay in air b&bs or we camp out at Raven Rock in Lillington. We stopped in at Capri's Italian Restaurant and ordered a couple pizzas. The staff was very friendly and inviting. They had their children there. The second time we came, the same customers were there again.. The food was amazing and the prices were right. Thank you so much for your hospitality. If you haven't been yet, you need to check this place out!!“

“food was great Sabrina is amazing server she knows how to give great service and make sure my food is cooked to perfection“

“We didn't go to Papa John's, Google. There is a Sports Clips beauty shop right there, and the child got a haircut. The only handicapped spot, is just to the right of Papa John's.

Parking: The handicapped spot is shared bt Papa John's and Sports Clips hair salon next door.“

“Definitely the fastest delivery in Fayetteville. Great food and an amazing friendly staff. Oh and the guy that delivers pizza in his Red Dodge Challenger yes he’s AWESOME.“

“Wow! Weeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeee!“

“There is a hard working team here! I just left. They are flooded with post-hurricane customers, and no workers are slacking off.“