50 Best Pizza Restaurants in Fayetteville

“I would be fine if this was the only place for pizza in town. I love the atmosphere and friendliness. We felt like we were being fed by family. Please try this place before trying the others in town. Then, you will have a better idea of how to compare. Just know this pizza is different and the closest to italian pizza without traveling to Italy.“

“Tried the Mellow Mushroom for the first time on June 18 at this location. Food was decent. Waitress was super awesome (lady with dress, tattoos, and nose piercing). Restaurants with good food are easy to find, but it's not always easy to find places with legendary staff. Well done! :)“

“Not flashy but great home cooked food and service excellent... well worth the wait if needed.. try the grilled biscuits!!!“

“Shrimp and rice bowl was 🔥“

“Best Pizza in Fayetteville everyday!“

“My experience at Old Chicago (Fayetteville) was great. The food is delicious. Conrad is awesome. One of the best waiters I’ve had in. Long time.“

“Great customer service!!!
Staff Always smiling when I walk in to get my order. Very friendly
feel like I walked into a 1990s Walmart
Can’t get better than that without a time machine..
way to go.. I come to this one every time and it’s not the closest to me“

“We couldn’t choose so we had both! 😋Donair/Greek. Good job Pizza Time 👍“

“Clearly the new management appreciates their customers! Great food, service and prices!!! Can’t wait to eat more Hungry Howie’s at this location!!! Yummy 😋“

“Love coming here me and my friends the food is fantastic. It is cooked with love. It is so full of flavor. You always get a large portion and it is delivered to your table hot the waitresses are so friendly nice and smiling to the best ones you could ever find you’re always welcome there feel like you’re You’re at home on a Sunday dinner I recommend this for everyone if you want a nice home cooked meal, friendly atmosphere and beautiful smiles from these ladies you must go.“

“The guy that was putting in the pizza in the oven. Was not wearing a glove with the hand he used to put the pizza in the oven. His other hand had a glove?“

“Bubba's 33 never disappoints dine in or pick always good food and good service 5 stars plus“

“We have been working in Fayetteville for 6 months. We stay in air b&bs or we camp out at Raven Rock in Lillington. We stopped in at Capri's Italian Restaurant and ordered a couple pizzas. The staff was very friendly and inviting. They had their children there. The second time we came, the same customers were there again.. The food was amazing and the prices were right. Thank you so much for your hospitality. If you haven't been yet, you need to check this place out!!“

“Customer service was great. I loved that the owner and employees were doing all they could to create a fun customer experience having trivia nights, schedules for future menu items. The good was a bit expensive but the menu items I had were hand made and limited time menu items. 12 dollar burger with no sides. I would definitely give them a try!“

“Come and enjoy Marco’s Pizza!! Great Deals especially buy one get one free every Tuesday.“

“i haven’t been here in many years since i moved away and was very excited to come back now that im back in town. they have a lovely separate gluten free menu with plenty of options. they also have vegetarian options! so happy i stopped back by this spot“

“I’ve always loved this location (McPherson Church Rd) and I just wanted to say that they are amazing and such sweet, kind and caring people work there! We enjoy going with our kids! Always a good experience!“

“I don't know why I've never reviewed Dinos before now. I honestly love their pizza and wings. I don't think that I have had a better cook wing in my immediate area. I always choose well done since they are normally pretty meaty and their buffalo and garlic Parm are both really good. Their pizza has a homemade crust, like freshly made and fresh toppings. Once again I choose well done x normal. They don't add a lot of sauce which is good for me. The owner is super sweet and anytime I've had an issue, they take care of it with no complaint. If you're looking to support a local place, this is it. They also have grinders but I have never tried them.“

“My son and I walked here because it is close to our neighborhood. we sat in and enjoyed a nice lunch with friendly service, some nice tunes playing, and great pizza!“

“Just way too expensive just like everything today $29 for two sandwiches two bags of chips and two drinks I go going to Golden corral got all I can eat for less than that. The note here was for weeks before or months before but yesterday's visit to zacky's just piss poor attitude I tell you they're closing down no matter where you turn around but the people's attitude yesterday just hold drum just taking care less about come back again or thanks for your order or nothing they're just their attitude there is not very well at the drive-thru“

“Hands-down, absolutely amazing. The staff is amazing. The manager is absolutely amazing. It’s clean and tidy, and they treat their customers so well so happy With this location!“

“Dine in this morning at Rudino’s in hope Mills, there was no wait time to be sat, the daytime host Katelin was the sweetest ever. She was very polite. Our server was Nicole she was also very nice and did an amazing job at taking care of us. The wait time for our food wasn’t long at all and the food was amazing. Everything was fresh and to our liking.“

“food was great Sabrina is amazing server she knows how to give great service and make sure my food is cooked to perfection“

“My sons and I came in yesterday for the first time and let me tell you the pizza is absolutely DELICIOUS 😋 Logan took our order he was so kind! I told him that this pizza is definitely better than Dominos pizza hut and Papa John's! I live 30 minutes away and I'm actually about to pull back up to get another pizza 🍕 GREAT SERVICE AND GREAT FOOD! I CAN'T COMPLAIN AND THEY DO MILITARY DISCOUNTS!“

“Great food and service! Awesome dining area and selections of food choices!“

“love there pizza and you cant get unlimited toppings“

“love there pizza and you cant get unlimited toppings“

“Great place to eat, always great food and great service. Ashley H was my waitress at lunch and was wonderful as always!“

“I would personally give this place 4 out of 5 stars the pizza is always good and greasy and the pepperoni is always fantastic I come by here maybe twice a month. However I was shocked today when I was told I needed to pay a quarter for service water when I just tipped them 3 dollars for the food needless to say I won’t be eating here as frequently because of that experience I know it’s petty but I don’t carry quarters and I didn’t want to put 25 cents on my credit card.“

“The personal pan pizza is absolutely delicious! The crust is light, crunchy with just the right amount of fresh cheeses and delectable sauces. Remarkable customer service! The crew are accommodating, kind, engaging, respectful and willing to please.“

“The food was good first time there the guy James was very nice and friendly“

“My name is Danielle Brown and I love this Marcos. My husband and I always have great services . My food is always hot and fresh. The people are very nice and respectful. I had a young lady to ask me how I want my wings and people dnt ask me ever . So of course I will be going to Marcos in hope mills always. Y’all should give them a raise for all their hard work.“

“Definitely the fastest delivery in Fayetteville. Great food and an amazing friendly staff. Oh and the guy that delivers pizza in his Red Dodge Challenger yes he’s AWESOME.“

“Thanks for a great customer service from the first moment they grap my call and answered me thanks for a respectful and well manner driver who brought my food to my house. I appreciate your business and keep going guys you doing a great job. Thanks again“

“It was nasty out due to snow. I ordered delivery and they were extremely short handed and very apologetic. The pizza was amazing. That $20 tip was worth every penny. Thank you. You were very polite from the start even though customers were not being very friendly.“

“I ordered delivery from this dominos, I think Charles was my delivery driver. He gave me a wonderful pep talk and showed incredible humanity when I was having a terrible time. The food is also always amazing and delicious, definitely satisfies pizza cravings and my favorite pizza place.“

“Affordable, Hot and ready 🍕“

“There is a hard working team here! I just left. They are flooded with post-hurricane customers, and no workers are slacking off.“

“Wow! Weeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeee!“

“We visited the Pizza Hut on Bragg Blvd for the lunch buffet, and it was a great experience! The new staff member, Kate, was incredibly welcoming, friendly, and attentive. She went above and beyond to make our visit enjoyable and provided excellent customer service from the moment we walked in.

One tip Kate shared was to call about 10 minutes before arriving for the lunch buffet so you can request the pizzas your family likes. That way they’re fresh, hot, and customized to your preferences when you get there—a great touch that we really appreciated.

If you’re looking for an affordable and easy lunch outing with the kids this summer, I highly recommend it. My 9 and 12-year-old had a great time and absolutely loved the buffet. Staff members like Kate are what make dining out a genuinely enjoyable experience. We’ll definitely be back! 🍕😊“

“I ordered online, the process was easy, I got 2 pizzas on was awesome made to perfection the other was a little overly well done. i wasnt too mad about it because it had enough sauce on it to not be dry but the xtra cheese i ordered was super crispy. Any other time i have ordered from here it has been spot on though.“

“This cicis location is very consistent. I love coming here. The staff are always so friendly and accommodating. I come almost weekly at this point😅. I wish people had a bit more courtesy and would clean up behind themselves but hey everyone ain't raised right. You wont be dissatisfied here!“

“I haven’t ordered anything off their menu that I didn’t enjoy! The servers are all like family. Great family restaurant.“

“I never had a desire to review this spot bc never was really impressed. But the last few orders have been ON POINT. Not only timely but perfectly cooked and super hot. Whatever you’re doing different, manager, cooks whatever it is…Kerp up the good work. Thanks for a great pizza“

“We ordered some pizza online and it was taking a while so I called and I wasn't expecting them to answer but they answered right away and explained they were short staffed having only 2 people working. So I understood and they ended up coming a few minutes later and it was delicious! So the fact they were working extra hard they still brought us the food and made it delicious. He was also very nice and professional.“

“Just giving a HUGE thank you to Jason here at this dominos for going above and beyond with our order today for my daughters field day lunch.
With all of the activities going on I placed an online order to have picked up at a certain time to only realize I did NOT put in the correct pick up time for it and he assured me that everything was okay and he would help me have it out the door for them on time for lunch and he surely did make sure I brought it into the classroom on time for the kids and I couldn’t say thank you enough for him doing that for us!!
I appreciate you so much and the kiddos did as well!!
JASON YOU ROCK!!! Keep doing what you are doing!!!!“

“Order from here often and pick up via drive thru. Our experience had always been fast and pleasant. There has been a time or two where our order wasn’t correct but it was always rectified with no issues. Jay at the window was fun and pleasant to talk to. Definitely made the quick drive thru experience more memorable.“

“I’m pretty sure this is the location we went to, we have tried pizza from a few different Domino’s locations around Fayetteville since the start of the year. This was on February 3rd, 2026. This is what I expect when I ask for extra black olives on my pizza! This was wonderful to open the box to! This is the medium (12”) Parmesan stuffed crust pizza with light sauce, normal cheese, and extra black olives all over.“

“This pizza was so much better than I expected.I thought I was just getting it because of the fifty percent off deal.But it turned out to be great.The six cheese medium pizza was off the chain.He delivered it.Delivered it on time he put it in my hands and my front door and the pizza was actually like that.It was a one I was surprised at how good the pizza was“