31 Best Bakeries near Bay Head

“Mueller’s Bakery is hands down the best bakery in the nation, and their crumb cakes are in a league of their own!**

I’ve had crumb cakes from all over, but nothing—and I mean nothing—comes close to the perfection that Mueller’s delivers. The cake is incredibly moist, the crumb topping is generous and perfectly balanced between sweet and buttery, and the flavor is out of this world.

The moment you walk through the doors, you’re greeted with the heavenly aroma of freshly baked goods, and you just know you’re in for a treat.

Their crumb cake is a masterpiece that sets the standard for all others, and once you’ve had it, you’ll never want another crumb cake from anywhere else. Simply the best!“

“The cake for my daughters bridal shower not only looked amazing but tasted as good as it looked I was stressed because my usual bakery sadly closed due to the pandemic so I was nervous trying a new place. I couldn’t have been happier You are my go to now for all specialty cakes Thank you Toni so much“

“Have ordered lunch from here several times as well as catering for holidays and countless treats. Everything is always delicious and relatively affordable for the amount of food you get. Lengthy menu. Staff is always lovely. They do a great job of creating a safe space for all.“

“I ordered a dozen bundtinis on line for my daughter’s birthday. They were ready when I arrived to pick them up and looked wonderful. They were so delicious. Everyone enjoyed them. They’re great to bring to someone’s home and perfect to serve at your own home. The shop is so cute. I will definitely be back!“

“Best bakery at the shore!!“

“I can’t believe there’s only 94% recommendation on this crumb cake. We get it from Jerry’s in seaside park and it’s amazing. I can’t wait to try all the other flavors. Keep doing your thing ✌️“

“I’ve gotten the last 3 cakes from here and they DO NOT DISAPPOINT!!! Soo delicious and sooooo incredibly beautiful. They’re so sweet at the store also. 10/10.“

“Last year, while my family was vacationing in Point Pleasant, we were celebrating my twin grandsons' first birthday. I looked up bakeries in Point Pleasant and contacted Country Bakery via email. our theme was O fish ally 1. I sent a picture of a possible design and they did an amazing job. fast forward to this year and the twins are going to cele rate birthday #2 while we are in Point Pleasant. so, of course I reached out to the Country Bakery. This years theme is Mickey Mouse and I know we will be amazed once again. I highly recommend this business My emails are answered very quickly, they work with my and don't get tired of my questions! We will be in Point Pleasant again next year and will getting in touch for birthday #3.“

“The best bakery you’ll find down the shore - hands down! The chocolate croissants are to die for. All of the croissants and pastry are delicious, flavorful, perfect. Whether you want sweet or savory you’ll be floored. Be sure to try their pizza too. There is a reason there is usually a line out the door and they sell out quickly. The staff are lovely; the shop is charming, welcoming, and clean. The customers are all lovely as well. It’s a real little community in Spring Lake. An absolute must visit if you’re anywhere down the shore. I promise. I’ve been going since they opened a few years ago and they are consistently great. ?“

“I had ordered a graduation cake not only did the cake look absolutely amazing it was the best tasting cake ever.“

“Love this place!!! Can not go to spring lake without stopping here. 12/10“

“Wonderful place. Cozy and delicious. Like Europe.“

“Had brunch here. Was apprehensive when I walked into the bakery section as I felt the restaurant would be an “add-on”. But the food was very good and the atmosphere very pleasant. You order up front but are brought your food at the table. Highly recommend!“

“Alli and the Colonial Bakery team are ahhhhmazing! I cannot thank them enough. I have searched everywhere for a traditional NJ hard roll with poppy seeds and get a bakery to ship. It was a gift and not easy to find. Alli answered my emails and calls right away. The rolls arrived fresh and on time. The memories put a priceless smile on his face (he is like a dad to me and hasn't lived in Jersey in decades). Oh, and did I mention the rolls were legit and delicious!!! Thank you, Colonial Bakery!!!“

“Had my family for breakfast, they still can't stop raving over the quiches, they were the best we've ever eaten!!!! Absolutely delicious everything from there is just wonderful!!“

“Alli and the Colonial Bakery team are ahhhhmazing! I cannot thank them enough. I have searched everywhere for a traditional NJ hard roll with poppy seeds and get a bakery to ship. It was a gift and not easy to find. Alli answered my emails and calls right away. The rolls arrived fresh and on time. The memories put a priceless smile on his face (he is like a dad to me and hasn't lived in Jersey in decades). Oh, and did I mention the rolls were legit and delicious!!! Thank you, Colonial Bakery!!!“

“Stumbled upon this while visiting family and the shore. I was almost overwhelmed with the amount of options available! I ordered three different cupcakes, a cannoli, and a croissant. The croissant was the flakiest and most delicious that I’ve ever had— vegan or otherwise. Highly recommend this place.“

“Mandoli’s nailed it! The cake they made me for my baby shower was beyond perfect I almost didn’t want to cut it! It looked exactly like my inspo pic I couldn’t have been happier. All my guests were raving about how pretty it was and how great it tasted, the raspberry buttercream was amazing. They also were nice enough to deliver my cake last minute. I highly recommend Mandoli’s and I will be using them in the future!“

“I chose this place to make a cake for my wedding and couldn't have been happier. I was very satisfied with how the cake came out and everyone loved it. I will definitely be getting other cakes from there in the future. The cake was made in a timely manner and was ready right when I needed it.“

“Our wedding cake came from Cameo. It was amazing! It was everything I wanted on our wedding day, beautiful, light and incredibly delicious! I highly recommend Cameo for anyone who is looking for a bakery for their wedding cake.“

“Always great cookies! But I stopped in for Graduation cookies & they were booked. They made time for me & did a dozen of 2022 chocolate chip cookies! They are the best!“

“Everything she sells is the VERY Best Quality. We are from the Jersey Shore currently living in Williamsburg, Virginia. We always bring plenty of goodies home with us. Very Friendly Staff.“

“Mr Cupcakes is beyond a cupcake I love all of the cupcakes he has but I do have a favorite and that would be red velvet and the rainbow cookie Johnny the owner has been nothing but helpful honest and delivers I am so glad that they came to Brick and expanded their sweets if you haven't tried it you need to it's definitely worth it“

“We couldn't have been more thrilled with the custom cake that we purchased from here. Not only did it come out exactly how I had envisioned it, it tasted absolutely delicious. It was the hit of the party. We got a huge 14" round, and the whole thing was gone! They'd delivered it to our door (we are local) too! Just a wonderful family.
Not only does it feel good supporting a local family business, but it feels great to know that they deserve all the support because their products and services are amazing.“

“I had a pretty odd request for custom Macaron cookies for my son's birthday. Not only were they very willing to try, they did an incredible job! The mushroom shaped Macarons were adorable as well as delicious. They went almost as fast as the cupcakes. What an absolute treat. Highly recommend for creativity and flavor.“

“I ordered a cake for my 75th birthday - chocolate cake, chocolate mousse filling and chocolate whipped cream (more like a mocha). It was the best cake ever and everyone raved about it. With all the chocolate you would think it would be very sweet but it wasn’t. Very light and not at all sweet. I have also gotten cookies from there several and they were delicious. I highly recommend Red Rise Bakery!!.“

“I drive up every year from Florida to visit family .One of the must visit places is Hoffman's ! I look foward to seeing the looks on my grandchildrens face eating your fantastic ice creams thanks again. John very nice remodel on your shop !“

“The cookies are amazing and once you order they will have it to you in just a matter of minutes

Vegetarian options: Very yummy

Dietary restrictions: If you have a foray or gluten issue do not go here but it’s so worth it“

“hermoso mi favorito precioso“

“Fresh food and not salty. I’m glad that we have a good Mexican Restaurant in Silverton.“

“almost all the donuts are made in front of you, so you know they are fresh !“