50 Best Bakeries near Middletown

“BEST BAKERY AROUND!!!! Ordered a custom cake for our daughter in law’s baby sprinkle. I can’t rave about it enough!! It was better than I could of imagined!! Thank you Matt for a beautiful delicious cake. Everyone was and still is raving about it!!!“

“I highly recommend Edible Art Custom Cakes & Chocolates !!!I have been using Debbie for years!! My friends and family always, always, always rave about how beautiful her cakes are and how delicious all of her desserts taste!!!Debbie only uses the finest and freshest ingredients and doesn’t skimp on anything!! Her attention to detail is impeccable and her expertise and knowledge is impressive!!Debbie knows exactly how to turn my vision into a beautiful, delicious masterpiece! Every single time!!!!“

“I wanted to come on here and let you know that the Middletown location has an AMAZING General Manager, Tricia. I ordered a specific birthday Bundt cake online for my niece’s birthday who was coming to visit me and I requested to have it delivered since I was busy prepping her favorite dinner. To my surprise when the delivery arrived I received a Halloween decorated cake. I called the store which is when i spoke with Tricia. She handled my issue with such impeccable customer service and resolved it immediately. Tricia, you went above and beyond and for that alone you will forever have me as customer at your Middletown, NJ location. I appreciated everything you did for me!! Nothing Bundt Cakes I hope you recognize what an asset you have on your Team.“

“This is a little mall area that has a plethora of shops and businesses. Not the place to go if you are looking for something of everything, but there’s a ShopRite here that is pretty good. Not a bad place if you live in the area. It is accessible and parking is OK, even on crowded weekends.“

“Absolutely! Love the fruity pebble bagel❤️“

“Amazing bakery, delicious food and coffee and beverages in general. The atmosphere is so cute. The people are super super kind and sweet and you feel very welcomed when you walk into the bakery. This will definitely be my go to spot, I would rather support turquoise, bakery and café over any Starbucks or any other coffee shop!“

“Our wedding cake was AMAZING. My husband has a severe gluten allergy, and this cake was made gluten free for us. It tasted beyond delicious and everyone loved it. Not to mention how absolutely gorgeous the design was. The photo speaks for itself. Just a perfect cake with a seamless ordering/payment/delivery process. Thank you for taking great care of us!“

“It's not as pricey as i thought it was gonna be. My daughter and I love crumbl!! The cake batter cookie is my favorite one. The staff were all very nice and helpful. I recommend everyone try crumbl at least once! you won't regret it“

“The BEST Carrot Cake I’ve ever had! 🥕🍰“

“Thank you Ridiculous Farms for the amazing breads, butters, and goodies throughout the year! I absolutely love your bread, and the time and care you put into everything you make! We highly recommend Ridiculous Farms for the most delicious, flavorful, and amazing sourdough breads! If you have not tried them, please put it on your 2026 list!!!“

“Everything in this establishment is just delicious and a bit of heaven. From the service to the cleanliness to the most delicious food and let’s not forget how wonderful the owners and staff treat you. I’ve been here two times and I always leave with a smile on my face. And a nice full stomach their food is outrageous. Their service is impeccable and I highly recommend them. Thank you for always being nice to me and my children when we go to your establishment.“

“Great place for all types of desserts and pastries!“

“This is my second cake from Abbate and it was a complete success for my daughters graduation party! Excellent quality! And packaged perfect for transport!“

“Papa Ganache is by far my favorite gluten-free bakery/eatery in NJ. They are so beyond accommodating and the food tastes too good to be real! They did my wedding cake too! Highly recommend.“

“Thank you for making the most beautiful cake on short notice! Absolutely delicious! What could be better than cookie dough ice cream and cake? Awesome job 🧡“

“I really like this place! I had a coffee and it was good. Since it was my first time here, the bakery was crowded inside, which limited indoor seating, so I had to sit outside—but I didn’t mind. The service was a bit slow with a moderately long line, but the bakery was clean and the staff were friendly. I’ll definitely be returning and recommend giving this place a try!“

“I absolutely love Vincenzo! His personality, energy, creativity and designs are all magical!
He is a true artist and his medium is Fondant. If you want someone who gets excited to create something special for you and enjoys the creative process Vincenzo Salvatore is your person!

Not only are his cakes a work of art, they are delicious. I think my husbands favorite part of wedding planning was going to the cake tastings!

When planning a wedding it's important to align yourself with vendors/creatives who see your vision and get excited for you!
Vincenzo was our number 1 fan throughout the entire process!“

“Never disappointed when I order from Bittersweet Bake Shoppe. My family and I have used them since the start for birthdays, communions, and party favors. Everyone raves about the quality of their desserts and how amazing their creations look. Sam and Carissa are so professional and kind and will make sure your dessert dreams come true. You cannot go wrong ordering them!“

“If you are looking for a custom cake that looks amazing and tastes delicious, I highly recommend Cups & Cakes in Rumson. Denise and her team created a wonderful cake for our daughter with her college logo/High School grad. Everybody loved it! They go above and beyond to make your vision a reality! Thanks, Denise!“

“The best cookies I have ever eaten. They are fresh and you can taste the real butter and eggs in then cookies. Each month there is a flavor of the month, one more delicious then the next. Give a me a cookie napped cookie anytime! You are are always greeted my the friendly owner.“

“Sal made my son’s birthday cake and it was amazingly delicious and he’s so talented with the decor. Highly recommend this bakery and pastries were delicious as well. Thank you Sal“

“My wife is an excellent baker, who usually makes my birthday cake for me. This year she couldn't, so I bought a cake from Antoinette Boulangerie. I'm a bakery snob. When I'm not eating homemade desserts, I only buy from the best bakeries in NYC and NJ. Antoinette Boulangerie is one of them.

The cake I bought was not pre-ordered; it was a ready-to-go cake for the day I called, which was my birthday. There were three that day: Red Velvet, Chocolate, Lemon-Raspberry. I chose the Lemon-Raspberry: lemon icing, vanilla cake, raspberry filling. It was FANTASTIC. The cake itself was perfectly moist, light and flavorful; the lemon icing was delicious and just the right amount of sweet, not too sweet; the raspberry filling was delicate. These are the signs of an excellent baker. In the past I've also had pastries from Antoinette, usually tarts and eclairs, and they've always been excellent.

My wife thought the cake was so good that she's considering appointing Antoinette Boulangerie as my official birthday baker.“

“So happy you guys reopened, a staple of my childhood! Best bagels at the Jersey Shore hands down, and now they offer delicious homemade spreads! I got the mini with Veggie cream cheese and that will be in my weekend rotation from now on. Also the entire place is sparkling clean. I can't believe its the same place. Bravo!!

Vegetarian options: Limitless veggie options!“

“Yummy!! Love the speciality donuts!!“

“My kids love to stop in every time we come to the beach. Nothing better than a good cookie or cake after a long day of play. The lobster tails are delicious and light to the crunch!! Highly recommend🙌🏽“

“Amazing food, friendly staff, delicious coffee🖤“

“My home away from home! Or is my home my home away from home? Either way, come visit me sometime! <3“

“This review is LONG overdue, but this past October, Sophie had a cake prepared for my boyfriend’s 25th birthday. It was coming up really soon and I still hadn’t gotten a cake. I came across Sophie C’s Sweets on Facebook and saw how talented she was. I messaged her on a Monday, asking if she’d be able to bake me a cake by the following Saturday, and to my surprise, she was able! The ordering process was super smooth and the pricing was very reasonable. When I picked up the cake, she had it beautifully presented, and it looked BETTER than the reference I had sent. Let me tell you, when we finally had a bite, this was the BEST cake I’ve had in my entire life. I’m not exaggerating. If you’re looking for someone to make your custom cake, don’t think twice, get it from Sophie C’s Sweets!“

“Kosher bakery with everything you can think of. They offer cakes, cookies, bread, challah, pastries etc... and even sell pizza and sushi. This bakery is the go to bakery in this town and is extremely popular. The pi,za and sushi can have very long waits in the summer especially during peak hours.

Dietary restrictions: Fully kosher yashan pat n chalav yisrael

Parking: Easy to find parking on street on regular days. During peak season parking can be rough.

Kid-friendliness: Very kid friendly“

“Awesome bread. The bread room is open to the public and they also do wholesale. Rustic Italian sesame seed loaf as a baguette style is amazing. Buy 3 if you want 1 to make it home!“

“I have had these Bundt cakes for many occasions and they are always delicious. The staff at the store is always pleasant and polite. The store is so cute and always clean and organized. Thank you making our events so special 😍“

“I visited yesterday morning before work and had a great experience. This location has a team that stands out from other locations. It fits in wonderfully with Red Bank’s culture even though it’s a recognized franchise brand and the coffee is delicious. The chocolate and strawberry croissants are very fresh. I love the modern aesthetic and layout mixed with the friendly atmosphere. I felt like I was in an high end “Mom and Pop shop”. It was also cleaner than most of the local coffee shops. Definitely suggest coming here if you want some reliably quick and tasty food/coffee in a busy Red Bank“

“What a choice of bagels and cream cheese! I worked with Maria for a special event for the PR Council of Greater AC. She was more than helpful and the bagels were fresh and delicious! We will be back every time! Thank you!“

“Beautiful job on my daughter cake for her beach theme bridal shower thank you“

“It is a very great, authentic, Mexican bakery with delicious deserts and bread, ice cream, cake, candy, chips, drinks, and piñatas. It’s very kid friendly but wheelchair accessibility is a no. You do ned to go up two steps to go inside. Parking is also hard but you can find a place in front or around the shop. There are no Vegan options so don’t ask if they have that option.“

“Such a cute place. Counter guy very friendly. Great smoothies..will definitely be my to go place for coffee“

“These cookies are so easy to prepare. They start out as frozen balls of cookie dough that you arrange on the included parchment paper then bake! After just 15 minutes, you have the perfect chocolate chip cookie. Moist and chewy with melted chips inside and a crisp, golden cookie finish on the outside. Delicious and made right here in NJ. Buy local, eat deliciousness!“

“I got my tires changed there & it was taken care of nice and professionally. The mechanic name there is Rick & he was pleasant. Unfortunately he’s the only person working there due to shortage of staff and handles all the negativity from others due to lack of help. They need to give him a raise & some help! Cause he is doing amazing! 10/10“

“5 stars staff sweet i went this morning . To buy my friend something for her birthday was fast nice best bakery �“

“The most delicious eggplant parmigiana sandwich I have had in almost forever!!! Just the perfect balance of everything! And the BREAD! Beyond fabulous. I drove 36 miles to try this bread and I’m soooo glad I did. I will be back a lot!! My photo does not do this deliciousness any justice , just trust me!!!“

“Everything tastes so good. They are easy to order from. I would go more if I could“

“Been here a few times, their coffee is delicious, especially their nitro! And the owner is a special ed teacher, and really nice. I hear they're getting their food license soon!“

“Unfortunately they have been on the down slide cannoli cream was sour and Napoleon pastry were stale. Surprise how bad they got“

“Belli Baci Bakery makes some truly delicious treats. The food was excellent—fresh, flavorful, and clearly made with real care. The service was just as impressive, with friendly staff who made the visit feel easy and welcoming. The atmosphere was a bit simple, but still comfortable enough to enjoy everything. Overall, a great spot for quality baked goods and kind service.“

“always a traditional mexican bakery my favorite place!!“

“Amazing food and staff ❤️❤️“

“Great place to shop for fresh frozen food“