50 Best Bakeries near Keansburg

1 Sophie C's Sweets

5.0 Superb 24 Reviews

37 3rd St, Keansburg

“This review is LONG overdue, but this past October, Sophie had a cake prepared for my boyfriend’s 25th birthday. It was coming up really soon and I still hadn’t gotten a cake. I came across Sophie C’s Sweets on Facebook and saw how talented she was. I messaged her on a Monday, asking if she’d be able to bake me a cake by the following Saturday, and to my surprise, she was able! The ordering process was super smooth and the pricing was very reasonable. When I picked up the cake, she had it beautifully presented, and it looked BETTER than the reference I had sent. Let me tell you, when we finally had a bite, this was the BEST cake I’ve had in my entire life. I’m not exaggerating. If you’re looking for someone to make your custom cake, don’t think twice, get it from Sophie C’s Sweets!”

2 Cookienapped

4.7 Superb 83 Reviews

627 Palmer Avenue, Keansburg

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Everything was delish, especially the cookies”

3 Turquoise Bakery & Cafe

4.9 Superb 121 Reviews

2 Ryan Road Unit 2A, Marlboro · 11.52 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“My wife’s birthday was this past week. The only thing she asked for was a cake from Turquoise! And that’s what she got. The fluffiest, sweetest Red Velvet cake and Cream Cheese. Decorated to perfection! I’m trying to post a photo or two but the app won’t allow it. Oh well… take my word for it. Delicious.”

4 The Vintage Cake

4.9 Superb 112 Reviews

171 First Avenue, Atlantic Highlands · 5.22 miles

• Delivery

“The vintage cake did a phenomal job with my sons first birthday cake and dessert. The artistry on the cake directly matched my theme for the party which was customized. We received so many compliments. I will be ordering from them again and again. THANK YOU!!”

5 Annadale Bakery

4.7 Superb 235 Reviews

821 Annadale Road, Staten Island · 7.35 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“They did a great job on a custom cake. Fair price, pretty and tasty.”

6 Abbate Bakery

4.7 Superb 171 Reviews

247 Main Street, Matawan · 5.93 miles

“This is my second cake from Abbate and it was a complete success for my daughters graduation party! Excellent quality! And packaged perfect for transport!”

7 Benchmark Breads

5.0 Superb 64 Reviews

141 Markham Place, Little Silver · 8.5 miles

“Their breads are amazing! I wish they were close by.”

8 J & M Bakery

4.7 Superb 154 Reviews

1120 NJ-35, Middletown · 3.26 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“BEST BAKERY AROUND!!!! Ordered a custom cake for our daughter in law’s baby sprinkle. I can’t rave about it enough!! It was better than I could of imagined!! Thank you Matt for a beautiful delicious cake. Everyone was and still is raving about it!!!”

9 The Ridiculous Farm

5.0 Superb 56 Reviews

571 NJ-36, Belford · 2.54 miles

“Thank you Ridiculous Farms for the amazing breads, butters, and goodies throughout the year! I absolutely love your bread, and the time and care you put into everything you make! We highly recommend Ridiculous Farms for the most delicious, flavorful, and amazing sourdough breads! If you have not tried them, please put it on your 2026 list!!!”

10 The Bakery

5.0 Superb 52 Reviews

88 Oceanport Avenue, Little Silver · 9.41 miles

“Great place with fresh donuts and pastries!! Boston creme and coffee roll were so good! 😊”

11 Mark's Bake Shoppe

4.6 Superb 205 Reviews

3479 Richmond Road, Staten Island · 9.09 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Delicious breakfast and fresh baked goods!”

12 The Baker’s Grove

4.6 Superb 146 Reviews

524 Broad Street, Shrewsbury · 8.22 miles

• Delivery

“The BEST Carrot Cake I’ve ever had! 🥕🍰”

13 Crumbl

4.5 Superb 302 Reviews

2136 NJ-35, Holmdel · 2.22 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“It's not as pricey as i thought it was gonna be. My daughter and I love crumbl!! The cake batter cookie is my favorite one. The staff were all very nice and helpful. I recommend everyone try crumbl at least once! you won't regret it”

14 Holtermann's Bakery

4.5 Superb 214 Reviews

405 Arthur Kill Road, Staten Island · 8.59 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“OMG! This place is to die for! So delicious! Cupcakes that literally melt in your mouth! Such a friendly atmosphere! I would drive a 100 miles to eat here! Absolutely Fantastic! It's like a mouth ecstasy! Literally to die for!”

15 Cups and Cakes Bakery ~ Juice Bar ~ Cafe

4.7 Superb 65 Reviews

122 East River Road, Rumson · 8.31 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“If you are looking for a custom cake that looks amazing and tastes delicious, I highly recommend Cups & Cakes in Rumson. Denise and her team created a wonderful cake for our daughter with her college logo/High School grad. Everybody loved it! They go above and beyond to make your vision a reality! Thanks, Denise!”

16 Allie Bakes Cakes

5.0 Superb 32 Reviews

33 Circle Dr, Rumson · 11.71 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Like WAY BEYOND expectations!! We ordered 24 cupcakes (strawberry shortcake) and a specialty cake to accommodate both of my boys (one is gluten free, the other egg free), and not only was everything ADORABLE, but also DELICIOUS! We were hoping by to bring some home; but alas, it all went! Allie was a BREEZE to work with. Just a few texts and she worked PURE MAGIC.”

17 Sammi Sweetz

4.9 Superb 38 Reviews

128 Rose Avenue, Staten Island · 9.12 miles

• Delivery

“The chocolate chip cookie that I sampled at the New Dorp Restaurant Crawl was the best I have ever had! Can't wait to get more!”

18 Antoinette Boulangerie

4.5 Superb 159 Reviews

32 Monmouth Street, Red Bank · 7.17 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Zeynep is amazing!! She baked an absolutely stunning first birthday cake for my son’s’s birthday. It was a 3-tiered teddy bear-themed cake, and she did a fabulous job!! She was a pleasure to work with, and I’d highly highly recommend her.”

19 JAMM Pops

5.0 Superb 30 Reviews

366 Broad Street, Keyport · 3.69 miles

“Passionate small business owner. Who makes delicious cake, pops, and holds children's events.”

20 Paris Baguette

4.6 Superb 83 Reviews

2111 NJ-35 Ste 25A, Holmdel · 2.2 miles

“First of all, my hubby and I are picky eaters, so the 4 stars is based entirely on our opinion of the food we had. The cafe itself was clean, a comfy spot to meet friends for a little visiting, the staff were friendly and helpful, and the restrooms were clean and private. I had the hash brown ham and cheese. My husband had the turkey and cheese melt. They were both okay, but not completely our cup of tea. I honestly think that is just because of our taste preference, not the quality of the food. I recommend others go and experience this place for yourself. There is a great selection of breads and pastries.”

21 Cookie Jar

4.6 Superb 81 Reviews

181 New Dorp Lane, Staten Island · 9.13 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“From one business owner to another, I couldn't be more happy for the lovely treats James and Maria Carozza at Cookie Jar delivered to me as a gift! This speaks to the generosity and thoughtfulness of Cookie Jar as a whole, and I only wish for this business's continued success!”

22 Sal's Bakery

4.5 Superb 142 Reviews

245 Richmond Valley Road, Staten Island · 7.88 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Sal made my son’s birthday cake and it was amazingly delicious and he’s so talented with the decor. Highly recommend this bakery and pastries were delicious as well. Thank you Sal”

23 Kiddie Cakes

4.5 Superb 139 Reviews

6378 Amboy Road, Staten Island · 7.2 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Thank you for making the most beautiful cake on short notice! Absolutely delicious! What could be better than cookie dough ice cream and cake? Awesome job 🧡”

24 Nothing Bundt Cakes

4.5 Superb 108 Reviews

1081 Broad Street, Shrewsbury · 9.4 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“I have had these Bundt cakes for many occasions and they are always delicious. The staff at the store is always pleasant and polite. The store is so cute and always clean and organized. Thank you making our events so special 😍”

25 Papa Ganache Matawan

4.4 Superb 262 Reviews

106 Main Street, Matawan · 5.52 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Papa Ganache is by far my favorite gluten-free bakery/eatery in NJ. They are so beyond accommodating and the food tastes too good to be real! They did my wedding cake too! Highly recommend.”

26 Dorsi's Bakery

4.4 Superb 238 Reviews

479 Port Reading Avenue, Port Reading · 10.75 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“I ordered a bridal shower cake for my daughter and I’m so happy I chose Dorsi’s to bake it!! It was absolutely beautiful and taste even better!!! I highly recommend Dorsi’s for any of your specialty cake needs!!! Beautiful job! 👏👏👏”

27 Mav's Top Buns

4.5 Superb 91 Reviews

1092 NJ-35, Middletown · 3.26 miles

• Delivery

“I always love anything I get here! Its convenient when Riposo is right there too. During a rush it can get a little cramped and theres only a small bench on the side to sit and wait. However it's always very clean, and the staff is always amazing and works fast.”

28 Bittersweet Bake Shoppe

5.0 Superb 22 Reviews

Bittersweet Bake Shoppe, 4275 Arthur Kill Rd Store 3, Staten Island · 8.73 miles

“Never disappointed when I order from Bittersweet Bake Shoppe. My family and I have used them since the start for birthdays, communions, and party favors. Everyone raves about the quality of their desserts and how amazing their creations look. Sam and Carissa are so professional and kind and will make sure your dessert dreams come true. You cannot go wrong ordering them!”

29 Busy Bee Roasters and Coffee Shop

4.9 Superb 97 Reviews

71 NJ-36, West Long Branch · 11.29 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Amazing food, friendly staff, delicious coffee🖤”

30 Nino's Bakery

4.5 Superb 78 Reviews

46 Oceanport Avenue, West Long Branch · 11.51 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Awesome bread. The bread room is open to the public and they also do wholesale. Rustic Italian sesame seed loaf as a baguette style is amazing. Buy 3 if you want 1 to make it home!”

31 Vincenzo Salvatore Cakes

5.0 Superb 20 Reviews

81 Winant Place, Staten Island · 8.76 miles

• Delivery

“We cannot say enough wonderful things about our wedding cake! It was absolutely stunning and truly exceeded our expectations. Not only was it one of the most beautiful cakes we’ve ever seen, but it was also delicious! We received so many compliments from our guests about how amazing it tasted. Vin did such an incredible job bringing our vision to life and putting so much thought and detail into every part of the cake. It was truly a beautiful and memorable part of our wedding day. I must also mention that he went out of his way to schedule a tasting that accommodated our schedules, which was difficult since we were from out of town. He went above and beyond for us, which speaks volumes about his character. Thank you so much for creating something so beautiful, delicious, and special for our wedding. We are beyond happy that we chose you and would recommend you to anyone looking for an incredible wedding cake”

32 Angel Bakeries

4.6 Superb 43 Reviews

110 Raskulinecz Road, Carteret · 11.43 miles

• Delivery

“Absolutely LOVE the pittah bread It’s like eating a baked cloud”

33 NY Bread Inc

4.4 Superb 110 Reviews

2201 Neptune Avenue, Brooklyn · 11.96 miles

• Take-Out

“NY Bread Inc is a wonderful neighborhood bakery on Neptune Avenue that consistently delivers high-quality, freshly baked goods. The facility is clean, tidy, and filled with the irresistible aroma of warm dough and freshly baked breads as soon as you step up. Their specialty lies in a wide selection of traditional breads, soft loaves, rolls, and delicious baked treats that taste incredible and fresh. Whether you are stocking up on daily bread staples or picking up fresh baked goods for a family meal, the texture and crust quality are always top-notch. The staff and counter workers are polite, welcoming, and keep service moving at a pleasant pace. It can get quite busy during morning hours as locals drop in to buy fresh loaves, but the fantastic quality, authentic recipes, and reasonable prices make NY Bread Inc a true neighborhood gem!”

34 Main Street Donuts

4.7 Superb 150 Reviews

141 Main Street, Matawan · 5.57 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Yummy!! Love the speciality donuts!!”

35 Cyclone Bagels

4.4 Superb 75 Reviews

2028 Surf Avenue, Brooklyn · 11.86 miles

• Delivery

“This place was so cute! I enjoyed the energy of the workers and my bagel was very cheap! For it to be a bougie Coney Island lol I only paid 4.25 for a mozzarella and scallion cream cheese bagel. The bagel tasted so yummy and FRESH! This def will become a place that keep coming back to ! 😊💕”

36 1st Cup Coffee

4.7 Superb 121 Reviews

96 First Avenue, Atlantic Highlands · 5.22 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Such a cute place. Counter guy very friendly. Great smoothies..will definitely be my to go place for coffee”

37 Gourmet Italian Delights - Ice Cream Monster Keyport

4.7 Superb 118 Reviews

Entrance around back on waterside, 29 West Front Street, Keyport · 3.87 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“First time here and won't be the last. The ice cream was so good. The only problem with the ice cream was which flavor to choose. every one we tried was so good.”

38 Honeybell Bakery

4.5 Superb 24 Reviews

101 Crawford's Corner Road, Holmdel · 5.66 miles

• Delivery

“My home away from home! Or is my home my home away from home? Either way, come visit me sometime! <3”

39 Mi Pueblo Querido Bakery and Restaurant

4.5 Superb 22 Reviews

475 State Street, Perth Amboy · 8.71 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Muy buena comida Los invito”

40 Edible Art Custom Cakes & Chocolates

4.4 Superb 27 Reviews

1385 NJ-35 Ste 282, Middletown · 3.74 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“This is the 3rd time I’ve either had a cake or ordered a cake from Edible Art Custom Cakes & Chocolates and every single time they DO NOT MISS. The designs, flavor, everything is 100% spot on - the customer service is top tier, I highly recommend Edible Art Custom Cakes & Chocolates !!”

41 Bagel Oven

4.3 Superb 53 Reviews

72 Monmouth St # 1, Red Bank · 7.14 miles

“So happy you guys reopened, a staple of my childhood! Best bagels at the Jersey Shore hands down, and now they offer delicious homemade spreads! I got the mini with Veggie cream cheese and that will be in my weekend rotation from now on. Also the entire place is sparkling clean. I can't believe its the same place. Bravo!! Vegetarian options: Limitless veggie options!”

42 Ric Oven Bakers LLC

5.0 Superb 3 Reviews

46 Oceanport Avenue, West Long Branch · 11.51 miles

• Take-Out

“Amazing breads. Great staff and big supporters of the community.”

43 Pollack's Bakery

4.4 Superb 10 Reviews

1050 Rahway Avenue, Avenel · 11.89 miles

“Please in our place like their product.”

44 Paris Baguette

4.2 Good 207 Reviews

2742 Hylan Boulevard, Staten Island · 8.53 miles

• Delivery

“Wonderful experience every time! The food is always fresh, and the staff is consistently kind, welcoming, and patient. During our visit today, Nicole was especially helpful and took her time with my boyfriend and me while he checked whether his card was working. I also really appreciate the genuine, friendly conversations with the staff. Their interactions feel natural and personal, which makes the experience even more enjoyable. The atmosphere is also comfortable and calming.”

45 Normandie Bakery

4.2 Good 166 Reviews

3049 NJ-35, Hazlet · 3.03 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Beautiful job on my daughter cake for her beach theme bridal shower thank you”

46 Paws and Pastries

5.0 Superb 2 Reviews

804 Main St, Belford · 2.5 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

47 Sweet Bee Bakeshop

4.3 Superb 9 Reviews

37 East Front Street, Red Bank · 7.06 miles

“These cookies are so easy to prepare. They start out as frozen balls of cookie dough that you arrange on the included parchment paper then bake! After just 15 minutes, you have the perfect chocolate chip cookie. Moist and chewy with melted chips inside and a crisp, golden cookie finish on the outside. Delicious and made right here in NJ. Buy local, eat deliciousness!”

48 II Panettiere Bakery

5.0 Superb 1 Review

5385 Arthur Kill Road, Staten Island · 8.06 miles

49 Juanito's Bakery

4.2 Good 5 Reviews

165 Shrewsbury Ave, Red Bank · 7.2 miles

• Take-Out

“Everything was delicious nice place good service”

50 Artisan Bakers Group

4.6 Superb 73 Reviews

708 Sharrotts Road, Staten Island · 8.91 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“The most delicious eggplant parmigiana sandwich I have had in almost forever!!! Just the perfect balance of everything! And the BREAD! Beyond fabulous. I drove 36 miles to try this bread and I’m soooo glad I did. I will be back a lot!! My photo does not do this deliciousness any justice , just trust me!!!”