Bagels Restaurants near New Milford, NJ

“This place is clean and the people are very helpful and nice The chef makes good breakfast sandwich. Their bagel is good. People are just friendly and food is great! Service is good. Support our local stores! This is a good place for bagels and morre!“

“I order here around 3 times a week for breakfast. Its convenient to order on the website and not wait for food. Lets me grab and get back on the road for work. The staff are amazing here. Always friendly and hard working. The food is great and at low and fair prices. Highly recommend.“

“Best godfather sandwich EVER!!! My Friday treat after a long work week!!! Alex, please get another one ready this Friday (5/22) Ken’s picking it up. You make them THE BEST!!! Thank you!!!“

“Yes please to all of it! We love this place.“

“Absolutely love the sunny and bright atmosphere of this place, all of the workers are super helpful and friendly. The food is amazing too, the muffins are INCREDIBLE. The owners are also super nice! They might just be friends with the whole town!“

“I always get great service in this place. The food is fantastic (especially for the price). Their salads are made fresh on the spot... they cut everything fresh as they need em... they don't store the lettuce pre cut in tubs like most restaurants do. This is just an example of what sets Ben's apart from most places. Now, yes, I know they pride themselves for their bagels, but truth be told, I don't eat bagels... but my wife LOVES their bagels. -Boots“

“Turkey , egg and , cheese on an everything bagel. Best spot around !“

“It always a pleasure visiting JV Hot Bagels. The menu are impressive, with a variety of mouth-watering options that are bursting with flavor. The service is impeccable, with friendly and attentive staff who make my wife and I feel like VIPs. The owner even remembers are names.To top it off, we were surprised with complimentary meals from time to time. I highly recommend this restaurant to anyone looking for a memorable experience. You won't be disappointed!"“

“This small business is just wonderful. The food is delicious, the bagels and sandwiches are so fresh and tasty and the bagels are large. I purchased here a few times via the TGTG app and purchased bagels and their delicious home made assorted flavor cream cheeses. Additionally, the owner Ernesto and his wife are so genuine, customer service focused and take pride in the products/service they provide to their clients and community. I definitely recommend this bagel shop and more as one of the BEST in NJ and I drive 7 miles from Maywood,NJ to support them while purchasing their outstanding products!!!! ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️“

“Pretty busy bagel shop (Sun Late Morning) that turned out some sandwiches much faster than expected. Taylor Ham (pork roll) egg and cheese was Awesome! 3 generous cut pieces of pork roll (didn't have to order extra meat) w and egg over medium and gooey gooey cheese. Bagel itself was delish. Well worth the $9. Wife's bagel w scallion cream cheese and tomato had EXCESSIVE amount of cream cheese. But that can be fixed with the correct order verbiage on our side of the counter, no reduction as the bagel itself was again, delish.“

“The bagels of my Brooklyn youth!“

“Tried this spot today for the first time
I ordered three sandwiches
Turkey, bacon, egg & cheese on a plain bagel: classic

Garlic bagel with pastrami, egg & cheese. They don’t skimp on the pastrami

Turkey sausage, egg & cheese on a croissant.

I found the bagels to be soft enough for my kid which was a big deal for him.

Ordered two iced macchiatos without the sugar which was really good

The lady at the register was sweet and welcoming.

It got busy and they handled it really well, it wasn’t a mad house like some places get.“

“Carlos has been making bagels for years! Glad to see him start his own business!“

“Kind of an awkward location. Really solid bagels. Surprisingly fluffy but dense with flavor their bagels beat out a lot of other places locally. Fair prices and they stuff the breakfast sandwiches pretty good. Steak egg and cheese is awesome.“

“Hot Bagels really knows how to make a breakfast sandwich! I had one of the best turkey, egg, and cheese sandwiches I've ever tasted. The woman who took my order was incredibly pleasant, and the whole place had a warm and inviting vibe. It was a great experience from start to finish—I’ll definitely be coming back.“

“The bagels here are so good, they are life changing. After trying a bagel here, I realized I had never had a good bagel in my life before this one, and I will never look at another bagel the same way again. If I could give a million stars out of five, I would.“

“A MUST STOP every time I come back to NJ to visit my Mom!“

“Excelente los desayunos..“

“I stopped here on a whim driving home and I’m so glad I did. Super friendly workers who asked how I was while they were making my order and one even brought my bag of food to me as I was waiting by the front door.

We ordered the Chipotle Chicken and Chino’s Special subs to go (hero sizes). Both were incredible! The CC had a really nice kick to it and complimented the crispy chicken cutlet very well. Chino’s Special was my favorite - a messy sub with a generous helping of turkey meat with a runny egg.

My family of 3 wished we had more space in our stomachs to finish everything. The hero sized subs are large, and absolutely worth the price especially with similar restaurants charging the same, if not more, for a mediocre sub. We will be back for more!“

“I've lived within many areas in the NYC greater area over the years. As you can imagine I've had many bagels along the way. I'm happy to have found this bagel spot. They are some of the best bagels you can find on both sides of the Hudson River! Truly amazing bagels!!! We bring them everywhere we go when we vacation with the families and they are always a big hit and topic of conversation.“

“Best bagel shop this side of Route 3!From excellent CONSISTENT quality of food, a great selection, and the best staff any customer could wish for, this place is truly a hidden gem.Easy parking in the front and back, and always there to answer for a quick pick up order; great with catering too! This place has won my family and friends over for good.Thank you Bagel Plus & Cafe! See you soon again!Cheers!-Best Regards: Karim G. Daif“

“The food was great, and the staff was super helpful �“

“Excellent food, great service and quick.“

“I love their bacon egg sandwich on their onion bagel!! always fresh and taste great!!!!“

“The iced coffee was really good. I got a large with oat milk which was just under $5. For the quality I think it is well worth it. I didn’t try a bagel but I will say they looked very thick and fluffy. Hope to try one day. The service was also really nice :)“

“I read their amazing reviews, I had to add me 2 cents. Definitely try their French toast. Brings back my memories of being a kid, and filling as f...... Great for breakfast, lunch or dinner!!!“

“A real bagel. Case closed.“

“I'm glad I found this spot. It's easy to get to and they offer a lot of food options. They have donuts, bagels, sandwiches, and more!

I ordered a bagel and coffee, and it was $4.50! I'll definitely be back.

A lot of their sandwiches looked/sounded pretty good. I can't wait to come back and try out more of their food options.“

“awesome food and amazing services ....highly recommend this Bagel Shop....“

“Some of the best hand rolled bagels in NJ. Great crisp crust and wonderfully chewy textured inside. For those that are complaining they do not have a griddle, I believe they have a Kosher certification which means no meat can be served here since they use cream cheese (dairy). This was our go to bagel place when we lived in Fair Lawn, now we live in SC, and we come here to stock up on bagels to take south on every visit to NJ.“

“I found this gem of a spot when visiting family in NJ. This has to be the best I’ve had since becoming celiac 6 years ago. The bakery items are to die for and the bagel breakfast sandwiches are the best ever. I got to stop in this past weekend and got a few goodies to bring home. If you are gluten free and in the are do not pass this place up.“

“Had a great experience visiting, should have came sooner!! I feel like the place is fresher cleaner and has a wide selection of quality sandwiches and salads. There was a bit of a line but well worth the wait. Everyone loved their sandwiches!“

“Broadway Bagel is good for a lot of things but it's better to tell you what its not good for because it's smaller. their pastrami, very chewy & fatty. I got a wrap & was horrible because I was fighting with the pastrami to bite off a piece & then getting fat in your mouth is disgusting. At times when I get a breakfast sandwich with bacon it's like that's when they choose to hide fatty bacon instead of giving you well cooked bacon. How does an establishment do that to their customers? The tuna wrap w/ French fries, I usually order but now they're adding lettuce when before it was onions & avocado now they're putting celery & adding lettuce. why did they mess with such a great sandwich? Certain staff I work with like their blueberry pancakes, homefries, BLT. But like I said too many times I bought a BLT & it was filled with a lot of fatty bacon. I look at my food before I eat it. They used to have different flavors of OJ, Mango/Pineapple, Strawberry/Banana/Orange, but now all they have is regular OJ. They're changing how they made stuff and they changed the working crew so all I can say is I mostly get breakfast. It's hit & Miss for a lot of things because I like my food the way anyone having a business should make the food for their customers; with love & as best as possible.“

“Customer service is their main priority“

“Excellent service! Delicious food!“

“They always that pot of fresh coffee ready when u get there and staff is super nice and clean 💜🙏💙🌻🥰💯“

“Great food and atmosphere. wonderful staff.“

“This is awesome has a great menu food in delicious 😋 service is fantastic as well“

“The best bagels and customer service around!“

“Been coming here over 20 years! Ownership has changed in the last few years but they still serve up my favorite bagels in the area, as well as the very best BEC sandwich - it’s perfect in my opinion. The new owners are very sweet people. Love getting the whole wheat everything bagels they make on weekends, and I like the cookies too!“

“✅Excellent catering services ✅Delicious wraps ✅Bacon, egg & cheese on a 🥯 or yummy croissant 🥐 simple perfection“

“Absolutely the best bagel there is. Each one no matter the flavor is a delight. And their food that they put on the bagel is delicious. Get there before 3;30 PM if you want sliced cheese because they close the slicer at 3;30. I know if I get there at 3;32 PM the slicer is off. So I get tuna fish instead and it’s about as good as it gets. The staff is friendly and do a good job. What a place!“

“The staff are extremely nice and kind. I called from a distance and asked for bagels to be delivered to the local hospital. The staff was very patient and made every effort to get the bagels to the patient.“

“Came for lunch and walked out really loving this spot because the service was phenomenal. Food is delicious but these days staff is so rude, not here. Santos and his mini-me are the warmest and best part of this establishment. Come for the chicken wraps!“

“excellent service!!! very positive and professional. food was great!!! I highly recommend this place. very satisfied with the food.“

“Fine coffee in USA the Peruvian blend is next level thank you Yisrael for introducing me to it.
I just had a sandwich with croissant with egg and salad. Those cubed beets were really something you could tell. This place Cares about quality.“

“Great selection of breakfast and lunch options in addition to some hard-to-get grocery items. Friendly staff and they also have a text option allowing you to place your order ahead of time.“

“The best bagels..Owners of the deli very nice,with big smile on face ,the food is delicious 😋..Highly recommend to go there“

“Amazing spot! The man who served me was beyond cool, polite and just a 10/10 kind of guy. Best service!

I ordered some sausage, egg and cheese’s on everything bagels and they were perfect, exactly what I needed to start my morning.

I forgot to ask for the name of the man that served us, but I know he has great tastes in music.“

“One of the best Vegetable soups I have ever had.“