50 Best Ice Cream Shops near New Milford

“Excellent shave ice and ramen!“

“The blizzards are delicious. However, the fudge bars are horrible. The only reason that the fudge bars are not good from this location is they are covered in thick layers of ice due to the way that they stock them in a freezer that gets condensation. I wish i could add a pic to my review then the store gives a problem to replace it with a fresh bar.“

“Even Though They Don't Have Sugar Free - Lots Of Ice Cream Places Don't Think Of Diabetics ~ � Sad“

“We happened by last Friday and I asked for a recommendation. I tried the cookies and caramel and it was the best ice cream I've had in a long time! I have thought about it multiple times since returning home from our trip! It's so good!☺️👏“

“I had a fantastic experience! The store manager, was so attentive and cordial. I had no intention of buying anything and i ended up with a bunch of gelato and chocolate. Thank you, Devin!!

Parking: Easy to park. Its at the mall.“

“I'll definitely be back. The three non-dairy flavors i tried were all great, but I went with the P.O.G and another that was similar to almond joy. The owner was friendly and the seating area was comfortable. There's also outdoor seating available!“

“Best ice cream in New Jersey highly recommended .. try the Dubai chocolate its addicting 🥰“

“My only complaint is that the lone worker today, when I was paying with a credit card (without tap) took my card and tried to use tap. Before she took my card I was going to put it into the card processor. When I pointed out that it doesn’t have tap, she (2x’s) typed my card information into the register screen and it was declined (plenty of credit was available because I got gas with it shortly after). I then used my debit card which she just took from me and again tried to use tap (again not a feature on that card either). She was finally able to put my card information for the debit card and it went through. If she had let me put my card in in the first place there would have been no problem with the original transaction attempt. I feel some of the staff might need better/more training on using the register.“

“I went with a friend for the first time and we had a really good experience. They let us try a few of their flavors and I have to say, that made the decision even harder, they were all delicious! The place is small but we were able to sit inside, I love the mural they have in the ceiling of some Yonkers iconic places.“

“Thanks for the yelp elite invite. In little part of town is a hidden gem. Must have past it numerous times. What a great experience! It was my first visit at New Territories, a Hong Kong inspired ice cream and dessert shop. When I walked in, I was greeted by nuz one of the workers there. Warm welcome & big smile.She was super informative about the menu and so much fun to talk to. Then I met the owner , Pete. Explained to me to story of the store pretty amazing. They are famous for their bubble waffles. Was hot and fresh with along with vanilla ice cream & sprinkles. I had the double lemon float with lemonade and lemon sherbet as well. Store was very clean. There was about 15 flavors of ice cream to choose from. Definitely will be going back. Was able to snap a photo with Pete as well… “”OFF THE RECORD… he made another waffle no charge. for me before I left… let’s say didn’t make it home. :) oh almost forgot they have amazing fresh cut fruit açaí bowls… sorry pete… the waffles got to me….“

“I love Luciano’s gelato, I go here everytime I’m at American Dream and it never disappoints, the wide variety of flavors is amazing and the staff is super friendly and accommodating, especially Sam, Adrian, Amanda and Sameer, they are all great servers“

“If I could give 10 stars I would. Everything we have had has been an A+ The UBE ice cream is my family’s favorite. My 4 year old has been obsessed with it since she was 2. It’s a great family experience and the owner Chona couldn’t be a nicer person. She goes above and beyond for me every time I go in there. I wish every owner had the same energy, respect, and friendliness that Chona has. All the workers are extremely helpful and friendly as well. I strongly suggest to give Kubo a try you won’t be sorry.“

“Best Grapefruit ice cream ♥️“

“They will be closing Thanksgiving weekend“

“We absolutely love Ciel! Their croissants are the flakiest, most buttery pastries you can imagine, with that perfect crisp exterior and tender, layered interior. And their tarts and other goodies are all light, fresh and flavorful. We’ve ordered birthday cakes from Ciel for friends and family countless times, and they’re always the star of the party. The couple that own this place are so friendly and on top of everything.“

“SO GOOD !!
Expensive :/ but worth the treat
Nice Mr Moo
Cute cows and Despicable Me
Loved the sticker
Packed w goodies !!

I had the charcoal mocha w pb and Reese’s - the ice cream was more coffee than chocolate in flavor; I should have sampled beforehand
My friend had everything but the cereal w Reese’s and marshmallow fluff

We loved ! Drove over from Paramus :)

Great summer evening to sit outside and ENJOY“

“Always wanted to try this ice cream spot since the mall opened and glad I did. Well worth the wait and found it to taste like the name. Creamy and delicious.

The guy helping us out was super nice and let me try as many samples as I wanted. Would come back every time I visit American Dream.“

“They have the best lemon ice cream 🍦🍦“

“� � loved it so did my kids great experience and fun .“

“We were visiting from San Antonio Texas and this is the best ice cream I’ve ever tasted!“

“We happened by last Friday and I asked for a recommendation. I tried the cookies and caramel and it was the best ice cream I've had in a long time! I have thought about it multiple times since returning home from our trip! It's so good!☺️👏“

“Great homemade ice cream.Great assorted flavors.You won't be disappointed.“

“I don’t usually leave reviews, but this place truly deserves it. Every detail from the warm welcome at the door to the unforgettable flavors shows passion and authenticity. It’s rare to find somewhere that feels both like home and a luxury treat at the same time. I love their coffee and I always try different desserts every single one has turned out delicious, especially after asking the lovely owner for recommendations! ❤️ You won’t just taste the difference here, you’ll feel it. A must visit spot that raises the bar for everyone else in the area!“

“My son and I had such a great visit. The owners are so friendly and nice. On top of that, it’s the best ice cream I have ever had! I live 20 minutes away and I will definitely be visiting again soon“

“They have a 5.0 rating as of this writing. And I can see why. They make their own gelato in house. And it’s oddly good. Way better than it should be for this little out of the way place. I’m not sure this is a destination kind of place. But if you’re in the neighborhood, it’s perfect. Kid friendly and kid approved.“

“Fresh enjoyable used for business meeting“

“Gelato Rice balls calzoni“

“The ice-creams are delicious. They have many egg-free/vegan options as well. And the staff members are very friendly. My son dropped his ice-cream on the floor, but they refused to charge us even after us insisting.“

“The new ressee ice cream thing (forgot the name) it’s like a sundae/blizzard combo sorta, you eat with spoon… it’s shown as brown ice cream (not vanilla) which it is, just vanilla soft serve with peanut butter syrup.. I thought that it was peanut butter ice cream (which would have been better) it was still pretty good though but pretty expensive for a small cup of averaged ice cream.. $8 an some change ?‍♀️?‍♀️“

“Myself and my family have been coming here for over 25 years. We really never get ice cream any where else. It’s the best homemade ice cream around. And yes service is great, very nice and friendly. We just love it. It’s worth the 15 min ride. I’d even drive longer if I had to: 10 stars ⭐️ from us“

“My daughter loves it , she says music and all is amazing. She was Surprised thats the bubble gum ice scream had literally candy inside 😅“

“Never been before today but so happy we stopped by! Kids were thrilled with the flavor choices and I really liked there was a vegan option! We’ll definitely be stopping in again. 😃“

“Every time the door opens the owners are always smiling and very welcoming. A warm wanted feeling is nice for a customer to feel. Especially these days. The ice cream is ALWAYS fresh. The place is always clean as well.“

“Excellent service and outdoor seating“

“wow. after practicing long hours, creating music and bringing joy to world, tirelessly slaving over our instruments, ear drums blown, hands and body cramping fully, we need a place to relax. thus, we visit roll taid creamery, an environment so relaxing and so tranquil we instantly feel healed by the ambience alone. now the ice cream. the ice cream is absolutely delectable, hand curated by the amazing workers, or shall i say artists. such care and tenderness put into their work, you can truly taste the love and passion that they exude. it’s safe to say roll taid is the place to go.“

“delicioso 🤤 buena atencion 🎉“

“Great workers there tonight. It was very busy and they handled the rush very well! The two workers scheduled between 6:30 and 6:50 ,which was about the time frame we were there, worked really hard and did their best to handle the rush. Wanted to make sure to leave a review and ensure they get recognized. Sunday 4/6/2025“

“Malibu with cherry Italian Ice. May I saw the service is above & Beyond. Fast and very respected. Makes the customer feel good and its a guarantee of coming back with the entire family and share with others. Lots of different choices and there are little tables to eat outside the ice cream shop. I will say a family in front of me: the mama dropped her ice cream by mistake while carrying the others for her children and they literally gave her a brand new one with no charge! Other places they will charge 😆 but not Ralph's so go check them out this summer you wont regret it. 😉“

“Thank you for your support of Eastbrook’s class of 2021!“

“Such a beautiful little spot, with delicious home made ice cream at affordable prices, and really kind staff. I got the chocolate cherry and mango flavours twice already.
Importantly, also pet friendly with delicious ice cream for doggies. It seems that, judging from the reaction of a couple of them, even some doggies are regular customers! :-)
I love the atmosphere and colours of this little gem, which has a long bench and quite a few spots to sit down and enjoy your ice cream, as well as the colourful metal tables outside at a vibrant and friendly neighbourhood, so close to Central Park and in the wider Columbia University lively neighbourhood.
If I lived in the area long term, I would visit it every day!“

“Excellent gelato! Very nice staff! Lovely outdoor patio.“

“The most amazing experience ever. Can’t say enough. Both Mary and Philip are the sweetest and were absolutely a pleasure to work with. I had a Valentine’s event on feb15th which needed to be rescheduled to the 22nd and I canceled the order last minute for 30 boxes of chocolate covered strawberries. They didn’t charge me a single cent. I got the same order for the following week and they did an absolutely amazing job. The BEST CHOCOLATE COVERED STRAWBERRIES EVER!!!! I highly recommend them and they have loyal customer for life ❤️❤️“

“We used to walk there from the house over 50 years ago. Pick up a dozen Dilly Bars (I think they call them Buster bars now). I always knew the staff because we grew up together. So much more than memories !“

“The cookie butter bomb is so good! I enjoyed it so much I’d definitely recommend this ice cream place! Very tasty!“

“Uncle Louie G’s is a staple in our household! They have an amazing selection of flavors and the owners are always so friendly and helpful. Not only do we love to stop in with our kids, but we make sure to stock up on treats to take home too!“

“Amazing tasting ice cream at great prices accompanied by great service“

“Really nice, polite and courteous staff members. Very well recommended!“

“The ice cream is delicious and there are so many good options! It’s just so delicious 😋“

“The kunafe is so good with the ice cream on top of the kunafe you should try it especially with Zubeyir 5 star service“

“I’ve been to this franchise only twice and love everything from the flavors to the toppings! Just so yummy, highly recommend“