50 Best Mexican Restaurants near New Milford

“we’ve gone for the past two years to celebrate my friend’s birthday. They never let us down“

“💥💥💥💥💥 Just discovered a gem! Can’t wait to return. Tucked in on Columbus Av. betw 106/107. Best Mexican food I’ve yet to find in the city. I had the fish tacos! Excellente! Also the best sangria. Our server, Carol, was wonderful. And she gave me a delicious flan desert and everyone sang happy birthday. Thank you Carol and everyone! See you soon!“

“It was a surprise to find this little restaurant in Harlem. There were no tables, and we took the last two seats at the bar. While we waited, I surprisingly felt at home. The aroma of the food, the care with which Karina prepared each of the dishes, and the kindness and joy they served us. By the time our table was ready, we didn't want to take it anymore; we ate much more than we planned to order because we didn't want to miss out on their delicious food. I have dietary restrictions, and I was surprised to see that everything from the exquisite tortillas to the delicious tres leches dessert was prepared right there, gluten-free and preservative-free. I hope to return soon.“

“El concepto es muy padre y bonito. Me sentí en México por un momento. El sabor de la comida excelente. Pero mi mesera me descuidó y nunca me preguntó cómo estaba todo, nunca pasó a preguntar si ocupaba algo. No se ganó la propina, pero ya me la cobraron en la cuenta.“

“😍 I Love ❤️ their chicken and steak 🥩 tacos 🌮 and their Melanesa steak 🥩 sandwich 🥪 🥰❤️“

“I couldn’t get a picture of anyone’s food since we all dug in right away but the food here is amazing! We had their Birria tacos, a steak meal and a steak fajitas meal—chef’s kiss! They were very kind, welcoming and family oriented here. The place is small, I will say, it’s way smaller than I expected but nonetheless, we were quickly seated and the music was good the entire time. This was a memorable experience , thank you!“

“Me and my daughter, enjoyed this restaurant so much during our Mommy and Me weekend! The atmosphere was laid back and quite relaxing. The service was superb and the food was so good, we had to order food to bring home. I would give this establishment 6 stars if I could. We were both very pleased and we will be dining here again very soon. If you have not been here, you should definitely give them a visit. Peace and Love, Chele from the Block.“

“Hermoso restaurante de comida internacional música tragos espectaculares y ambiente súper agradable“

“Best Quesabirria!“

“Delicious, authentic, homemade food.“

“My family and I stopped by for a quick bite after school and were pleasantly delighted with the delicious food, great service and attentive environment. We will definitely return and make it our Mexican Food restaurant going forward. We loved the food and very attentive waitress who paid attention to every detail.“

“Comida súper autentica, deliciosa, sabrosa y los precios súper accesibles! 100% recomendado“

“Loved this spot! Great food and service!“

“Taco Express on Jerome Ave is a solid spot. I really like the food...everything I’ve had has been flavorful, fresh, and satisfying. It’s one of those places that’s easy to go back to when you want something quick and good. Definitely a nice local taco spot worth checking out.“

“Had the breakfast burrito 🌯 been wanting to get to this place for a while.

Wasn’t the best I’ve ever had but it was good. The chorizo was the one I went with definitely wasn’t disappointed.

I don’t think it’s worth a far drive but if you’re in the area or it’s not completely out your way it’s definitely worth stopping in for a visit. The place does have seating but not a lot of room. There is a park near by and lots of outdoor seating near the area. That’s what I chose to do.

The breakfast burrito price was amazing especially for nyc the food was good quality and really delicious. The sauce everyone was talking about wasn’t over powering. Matter of fact I wish I had more next time I’ll ask for some on the side felt like I needed an extra pump 😂.

I truly enjoyed this place and I’m sure you guys will also the coffee was mid but it’s ok food makes up for it.

Hope you enjoyed this review like always follow me on IG @imbroke_eats and @imbroke_rob

Hope this helped“

“The birria tacos were delicious! Excellent service.“

“The food is good and has been very consistent. The tortillas taste homemade and the salsa is great. I’ve ordered 3 times and I haven’t had any issues other than maybe forgetting my salsa one time. I really enjoyed the battered fried shrimp tacos a lot. Pricey but worth trying and giving a chance.“

“Definitivamente las mejores quesadillas de Tinga al carbón.“

“Ronny was absolutely amazing and made our visit to Chevy’s a great experience from start to finish. His kindness, professionalism, and genuine personality immediately made us feel welcomed. He didn’t just provide great service he made sure we felt comfortable, respected, and truly cared for.
What impressed us the most was the way Ronny treated my mom. He went out of his way to make sure she was happy and had everything she needed. His patience, positive attitude, and thoughtful way of helping made her feel special. My mom left Chevy’s with a big smile and kept talking about how wonderful Ronny was and how much she appreciated the way he treated us.
People like Ronny are what make a place stand out. He brings great energy, kindness, and dedication to his work, and it shows through the way he interacts with customers. He made our experience memorable, and we are truly grateful for the excellent service he provided. Chevy’s is lucky to have someone like Ronny on their team, and we look forward to coming back again because of him. THANK YOUUUU SO MUCH RONNY❤“

“Excellent places , if you want to have at great time with family or friends , great atmosphere , great food , great drinks , great staff , ty Gretel will highly recommended to everyone #new sherif in town 🙏🏼“

“Great meal - drinks extraordinary. Definitely coming back.“

“Muy rica comida 🥘 excelente servicio muy atentas y amables lo recomiendo 💯 ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️“

“Queridos Alex y María, Desde el principio captaron mi atención. Su huella en la industria es única; a lo largo de los años, su constancia ha sido de primera. Oro para que cada proyecto en el que se aventuren multiplique su fe en Dios.“

“Un lugar muy hermoso 🤩 y encantador ☺️“

“Great atmosphere, friendly service and interesting menu offering plenty of delicious options. We will be back for sure!“

“Great fresh halal Mexican food. At this point my baby is going to come out wearing a sombrero because of how often I eat here 😂. In all honesty, the food slaps and I always leave feeling satisfied. Preggo lady approved. 👍🏼 I always recommend the loaded nachos(birria of course), birria quesadilla and the birria tacos. Chicken burritos are also delish, I personally avoid the California burrito because I feel it’s too salty.“

“Edit: Updating my review. After it was open for a couple months I went back and it was much improved, bumping up to 4 stars.

Recently opened. I'll cut them some slack but the staff clearly are not trained well enough yet. Unorganized, broken burritos, confusion, bags not big enough, etc. Id wait a month or two until they are more trained.“

“Food is super fresh and the owner is so nice and you can tell he takes pride in his food. Never had baliada before Mi Sabor and definitely a fan!“

“Ordered via uber eats tonight . I've wanted to try for awhile (since I did a delivery for Feed the Frontlines) and I wasn't disappointed! We shared several items and they were all yummy! I will definitely order again.“

“Delicious food, good service, and a massive selection of agave-based drinks. Lovely ambiance / decor inside, and the dishes/bowls that they use are also lovely (and for sale, apparently). The place is among the most expensive in the neighborhood by a decent margin, but you certainly do feel like you're having an elevated experience (and the food was surprisingly filling).
We started with the trio of moles which were delicious, though the lightest one they offered did taste surprisingly close to vodka / tomato sauce, they provided tortillas which was nice but not nearly enough (we had to ask for more and then they charged us extra for it, despite not giving us enough the first time). The menu is rather short, so make sure there are things you like before going. The tlayuda with added meat was delicious, as were the tacos (which were $10 each) and the fluke aguachile also good (watermelon in summer is always a welcome treat).“

“Brunch walk-in, got seated right away. Good set-up, TV's by the bar, noise levels on the quieter side.

What we ordered: Breakfast Burrito ($19.95) and Taquitos de pollo ($13.95). Excellent food, perfect portion sizes, and quick service. Our food arrived within 20 minutes of placing the order. Competitively priced. We got a small serving of chips & salsa as well (complementary)

Will be one of our go-to-places for a sit down Mexican meal!“

“Awesome food… outdoor on summer time and indoor when it’s cold. Lovevthe Spanish music while eating ❤️“

“Tacoria is easily my go-to lunch spot since I work nearby, and it never disappoints. The food is consistently fresh, flavorful, and honestly one of the highlights of my workday. On top of that, the staff is always so friendly and welcoming especially Peter and Jose, which makes the experience even better. Great food and great people. You really can’t ask for more. Highly recommend!“

“Just tacos. Maybe tacos and a little bit of everything else.
Food was delicious and Enrique was awesome very hospitable made the whole experience even better.
Served hot and wait time was no more than 5-10min for our food.
To be completely transparent a bit on the pricier side but overall 8/10 all around.“

“Ordered 5 tacos, very yummy. Just don't understand why it asks what sauce you want per taco to then completely ignore it, CONSTANTLY. If you don't want to give the sauce just don't offer it, sending other sauces instead, which weren't wanted, end up being thrown in the trash.“

“Incredible restaurant. Food was over the top incredibly creative and delicious. People were super friendly. There was even a sweet karaoke singer who came in and lit the place up even more. But seriously if you’re interested in an absolutely incredible meal, go. Impossible to regret and prices were decent.“

“The reviews I read to this restaurant really fooled me. The food served here did not taste fresh. Don't get me started on their drinks, more like ice. If you love spending money on bad food and iced drinks then this is the place for you. I wouldn't recommend this place to anyone“

“Absolutely loved it here today for lunch. Our first time eating here and we will definitely be back soon!“

“The food is prepared with high quality products and the taste is definitely authentic. I love green tamales and Rajas, especially when they are just out of the olla because the dough feels soft and the salsa is spicy and runny.“

“Everything on the menu is excellent I have never had a bad meal. Margaritas are a must“

“Food and service is AMAZING! You NEED to try this place out! Will be coming back more often to try out every item on the menu 😋“

“This place is absolutely one of my favorites. Food is yummy no matter what you order, I recommend the corn soup 😋, tacos, the Sangria is delicious. Friendly staff and the place is very clean and affordable. 5 🌟 from me. Great place for friends, business or family!“

“Came to this place 2 years ago and the food was amazing. After 2 years the quality of the food and service hasn’t changed. The oysters are super fresh, the michelada is so good as well. I also tried the steak tacos, birria mulitas, and the quesadillas al pastor. All the food is super fresh. Definitely recommended. A must place to go for.
Thank You to Omar, Yair, and Noe for your amazing servirce and the great vibes.“

“awesome menu items great service“

“Food here is amazing. I walked in with amazing service where employees made sure you felt welcomed.Not only that but the service provided is fast and convenient too.“

“Muy bueno y fresco torta cubana 100“

“toda la comida es rica excelente“

“We really loved this placed visiting from Houston Pablo took really good care if us the service was amazing and the food was just as good, I had the chicken poblano dish 10/10 definitely will be coming back to dine with this establishment. Coming from the Houston Mexican cuisine scene wow above and beyond.“

“Food was excellent. Everything that I had was great. Flounder, was fantastic. Great place to eat good service fantastic atmosphere.“