9 Best Ice Cream Shops in Newark

Nasto's Ice Cream Co. — Old World Desserts Ice Cream Shop • $
236 Jefferson St #240, Newark

Customers` Favorites

Sea Salt Caramel Pretzel and Sweet Corn Lemon Ice
Coffee and Banana Ice Cream Waffle Bowl
Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough
Mango Pineapple Ice Cream
Small Ice Cream Sandwich
Chocolate Chocolate Chip
Peanut Butter Ice Cream
Cookie Dough with M&ms
1 2 Gallon Ice Cream
Strawberry Ice Cream

“Tried the new Woodbridge location twice now and WOW! The Rocky Road and Chocolate were out of this world. We will definitely be repeat customers.“

4.8 Superb274 Reviews
2

M2ICE

M2ICE Ice Cream Shop • $
678 Mt Prospect Ave, Newark

Customers` Favorites

Shaved Ice

“I was in the mood for a Mangonada and not too familiar with the area since we moved to Bayonne a year ago. We were out driving and I googled mangonada and came across M2ICE. They did not DISAPPOINT! Everything was absolutely incredible. The owners were also very welcoming and explained the different options and gave suggestions. We will be back.“

4.8 Superb77 Reviews
Salaam Ice Cream Parlor Ice Cream Shop • $
1024 Bergen St, Newark

Customers` Favorites

Carrot Cake w Cream Cheese Icing
Strawberry Milkshake
Butter Almond
Vanilla Bean
Bean Pie

“⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ A Hidden Gem in NJ – Salaam Ice Cream Parlor is a Must-Visit
it’s a full experience. The place is vibrant, clean, and welcoming, with a unique cultural charm that sets it apart from your typical ice cream shop .
The ice cream in question? rich, creamy, and bursting with flavor. Whether you’re into classic vanilla bean or want to try something new . every scoop is crafted with care and creativity. The waffle cones are crisp and honestly addictive.
What truly makes Salaam stand out is the exceptional customer service. The staff is friendly and patient. You can tell they genuinely care about the community and the people who walk up to get icecream.

Whether you’re a local or just passing through, Salaam Ice Cream Parlor deserves a spot at the top of your list. It’s more than a sweet treat—it’s a place that brings people together.“

4.5 Superb78 Reviews
Magic Cones Plant Based Ice Cream Parlor Ice Cream Shop •
550-552 Central Ave, Newark

Customers` Favorites

Magic Cone Ice Cream

“The best ice cream in the area. I would place some chairs and some sort of umbrella in the front or a bench simple, so people can seat, that could add a better atmosphere to the business. But the food is incredible delicious.

Vegetarian options: Vegan

Dietary restrictions: All vegan and ? plant based.

Kid-friendliness: Small portions.“

4.7 Superb14 Reviews
BeastMode MLM Herbalife Nutrition Ice Cream Shop •
429 Orange St #3122, Newark
4.8 Superb10 Reviews
Gavy's Ices & Hot Dogs Ice Cream Shop • $
107 Broadway, Newark

“my grandma and me would walk down the street sit on the park bench get a few of Tony's best hot dogs with sweet onions or there Chili Cheese dogs then take my fishing pole and walk down the steps to branch brook park and do some fishing this was back in the 70's I stop by there every now and then when I'am in the area brings back old memories of when I was much younger.“

4.5 Superb21 Reviews
Palace Fried Chicken And Gyro Chicken • $
1034 Broad St, Newark

Customers` Favorites

Italian Chicken Cheese Steak
Italian Fish Sandwich
Italian Cheese Steak
Bacon Cheese Burger
Fresh Chicken
Chicken Wings
Salad

“Been coming here for a while now and the food has been amazing. The fried chicken is one of the best I’ve had in all of the east coast. They also just got BBQ Ribs and Oxtails. And they are heavenly, and full of flavors. Feels like im in a Jamaican/fried chicken cuisine. Best of both worlds.“

4.3 Superb148 Reviews
Bogati Helados con Queso Newark Ice Cream Shop •
217 Ferry St, Newark

“The service is good and the food is amazing! For the people complaining please take a moment to reflect and put your pettiness aside, all these complaints and it’s the bare minimum that any other establishment can and has made. No need for the one review stars. Keep doing what you’re doing! For anyone new, try it out! It’s really popular though so be ready for the slight crowd😂“

3.4 Good16 Reviews
Cold Stone Ice Cream Shop • $$
641 Broad St, Newark

“Absolutely LOVE THIS PLACE!!!

The employees are AWESOME... They're friendly very helpful and have a lot of patience!!

I can never make up my mind w what I want to order & then I change around the toppings or ice cream & no matter how long I take to make up my mind they NEVER get impatient w me!!“

3.6 Good50 Reviews

You May Also Like