50 Best Italian Restaurants near Peapack

“Staff is very welcoming & attentive. Food is amazing!“

“I chose cafe azzurro based on recommendations from others for a “celebration of life” luncheon and I am so glad I did. With 30+ people the restaurant was generous to give us our own room and the menu selections were delicious. The service as well was impeccable! 10/10 I will gladly return and encourage others to sample their excellent food and ambiance. Thank you from our whole family !“

“Had a fantastic Valentine’s dinner at Bistro Seven Three in Bernardsville last night! Food was unbelievable and the service was friendly and really attentive! Thanks! We’ll be back!“

“We went last night to celebrate NYE at Rosie's... the food was delicious, however we did not get our dinner until 10:45. We arrived at 8:30. In fact, our table was last to receive each course of the meal, and it was just too slow. The bill for 4, with tip, was $650, which is too much to receive such poor service.“

“Beautiful alfresco dining weather permitting. Dinner never disappoints all selections excellemt. Best mussels ever. It’s not about the mussels but about the sauce which is FABULOUS.“

“Food and service consistantly great. Daily specials are varied and well presented. Sweet and spicey calamari is best ever. Our server Niti was outstanding.“

“I can’t say one bad thing about this restaurant - the food, the service, even the greeting at the front door was all great. As soon as my friends and I walked in we felt comfortable. We shared eggplant rollatini and bruschetta to start, and each had pasta dishes (chicken parm & lasagna) for our main entrees. We each brought half our dinners home so we could share a dessert :) which was also wonderful (fresh baked chocolate chip cookie in a cast iron pan with ice cream). We WILL be back. This place is a gem!“

“From the moment we walked in, we were treated as if we were sitting in first class. The staff was so attentive to our table even though they were very busy. We were not rushed and enjoyed every savory bit of food that was put before us. They also catered to me being a vegetarian. We finished our meal with the most delicious homemade gelato . if ever given the opportunity, please do not pass this gem of a restaurant up.“

“The food is amazing and it never disappoints. Love the atmosphere and coziness of this place.“

“What a find! We are local but this was our first time here. Been going to the nail salon near by for years and decided to try the restaurant with friends! It is now my favorite restaurant and not only near because it is near by.

Can't wait to go back and try more from the menus. The Supa de Pesce was spectacular. Fresh and delicious! Service was great as well! Can't wait to return and try some other items on the menu! As a pescatarian this may well be my new favorite restaurant and being local
Is a bonus!!!“

“Delicious food! Great staff!“

“This restaurant was absolutely delicious. Our waiter Zee was wonderful. The only complaint I have is the really small front on part of the menu items. It seems like they just want to keep the menu on one side of the paper.  The risotto, the special petrale sole, the gnocchi were all out of this world. “

“Catered a family event flawlessly. They were so kind and made sure we would be able to feed everyone regardless of dietary restrictions. If you have an event you need to feed people at in NJ use Bensi!“

“We were there for my daughters birthday this past Saturday. My wife and my daughter's boyfriend had the seared salmon which they loved. My daughter had the chicken parm, which she said was good. Her only "complaint" was that the sauce was a bit too sweet for her taste, but the portion was good and the chicken was cooked well. My son enjoyed his pepperoni pizza. He's not very adventerous. I had the Capellini Napoletani. It was very good. The capellini was cooked perfectly for my taste as was the shrimp, clams and calamari. Very tender. The sauce was great. This is our go-to for great food and is my wife's favorite. She is returning with coworkers for lunch on Tuesday. Service is top notch. Keep up the good work. We'll definately be returning.“

“Fabulous food. Honestly don’t think there are many restaurants who can beat the food quality. If you haven’t tried it, you should.“

“We've been ordering here for a while now. It's one of the better NY/NJ style pizzas in the area without being too specialized.Their pasta and meat menu items are where they are best - looking at you Chicken Puicinella and Cavatelli with Broccoli.For appetizers, they have great wings which are crispy, the way I like them. Also, the fried calamari uses a very light batter, so it's not too heavy.We've ordered trays from them twice for parties and we weren't disappointed in the quantity provided and they were affordable.“

“Food is fresh and delicious! Hats off to the Chef! Great atmosphere and friendly staff.“

“Luna Rossa is an exceptional restaurant which is run by a loyal and dedicated team under the direction of Adrian. Our first time visiting this establishment was with a party of 10. Adrian took all of our orders including appetizers without writing anything down. The food was delivered to perfection. I am astounded by the diversity of the menu, the ability to switch out sides, the quality and taste of the food. The chefs are talented and cook to delight every palate. I can not say enough about this wonderful restaurant including their staff Carlos, Kevin, and everyone that works so hard to deliver memorable meals. I look forward to going back soon. Thank you!“

“Thank you Sapori for the amazing food you made for my family Father's Day party! The Baked ziti was so cheesy good, the green salad fresh & crisp, bruschetta was crunchy & lots of topping, & shrimp scampi garlic yum! the service was so friendly! Many Blessings to your family from Ken & JoAnne Betz xo“

“Everything we have ordered from DaNapolis has been excellent...pizza, Chicken Francese, Shrimp Scampi, etc., everything is perfect. By far the best in the area.“

“The best food, service, and reasonably priced. Family meals are a great value when you don't feel like cooking. I have also catered parties here. Thank you, for helping us out with our Girl Scout troop!!“

“Was there for the first time last night, what a wonderful experience! The service was great, Franchesca was very friendly and attentive and the food was absolutely delicious. One of the best Italian food I’ve ever had. If you are looking for great food and service, definitely visit this place!“

“Very Good Italian Food. Always Delicious.“

“Beautiful inside. Food and service was Wonderful! 100% recommend!“

“This was my first time here and everything was great! Sandwiches, stuffed peppers, potato salad and the sausage wheel with provolone.“

“This is a great restaurant. Great food, great service, lovely interior.“

“Such a wonderful experience at Café Emilia! Delicious food, the most attentive service, so personable they make you feel like you’re family friends! Made my husband a custom ordered lasagna, I had the halibut special. Both were delicious. Thank you for such a memorable experience, we will see you again soon!“

“This restaurant was absolutely delicious. Our waiter Zee was wonderful. The only complaint I have is the really small front on part of the menu items. It seems like they just want to keep the menu on one side of the paper.  The risotto, the special petrale sole, the gnocchi were all out of this world. “

“This is our GO-TO place for catering when we have parties. They are so accommodating, they can make anything on or off the menu, great pricing, and they are truly appreciative for the business! Every single time we order, our guests RAVE about the food. We went out on a limb and ordered a large cheesesteak Stromboli last night and people couldn’t stop eating it. HIGHLY recommend!“

“Best sandwich I have ever had! I highly suggest the Grilled Chicken with Fresh Mozz and Roasted Peppers. Cute and cozy place with friendly staff and great prices. I will definity be back!“

“Best pizza in Morris County - Great staff and great food“

“Food was amazing … Fast and delicious“

“The Chicago deep dish pizza was perfectly balanced. With the airy yet slightly dense dough, sauce and cheese along with some flavor, I Would definitely go back if i didn’t live an hr away. The gentleman that handles the front is also very friendly and attentive to each customer.“

“5 stars ! delicious food - something for every. they will accommodate for different tastes ( vegetarian or gluten-free ) friendly staff !“

“The food is awesome on both sides! Shabo and family are wonderful hosts! We love NY Pizza and Monte Casa!“

“I’ve been here quite a few times over the years but never got around to leaving a review. The food has always been consistently good, the breadsticks are fresh, and the portions are generous. The staff have always been friendly and attentive, even when the restaurant is busy. It’s a comfortable place to sit down with family or friends, and I’ve always had a good experience. Definitely worth a visit if you’re in the area.“

“Absolutely outstanding! The food was incredibly fresh, and you could truly taste that everything was handmade with care. Every dish was full of flavor and felt authentically crafted. The service was just as impressive—our server took the time to answer questions, explain the menu, and offer excellent recommendations. A perfect combination of exceptional food and genuine hospitality. We’ll definitely be back!“

“Buen servicio, excelente dinner y aperitivos, mi familia todos contentos y en especial mi esposa la del cumpleaños. Gracias.“

“I recently visited JOES PIZZA and had an absolutely fantastic experience! From the moment I walked in, the atmosphere was warm and welcoming. The staff was friendly and attentive, making us feel right at home. The pizza? Simply amazing. The crust was perfectly crispy on the outside yet soft and chewy inside—exactly what you want in a pizza. I tried their signature EGGPLANT PIZZA, and the combination of fresh ingredients and bold flavors was a delightful surprise. You can tell they use high-quality ingredients, and everything tasted so fresh. What really stood out was the variety of toppings and unique combinations. There’s something for everyone, whether you’re into classic Margherita or prefer something more adventurous. And don’t even get me started on their homemade sauces—wow! The portions were generous, and the prices were more than reasonable for the quality you get. I’ll definitely be back soon to try more from their menu. If you're in the area and craving delicious pizza,“

“Came in with a party of 12, food was fantastic and waitresses were attentive and friendly! It was a great dinner.“

“Great food. Pizza and dinners“

“Great food, family friendly dining. Love this local treasure“

“We recently moved to the Basking Ridge area and discovered Chianti’s. Obsessed! The wood fired pizza is cooked to perfection. I have an 8, 6, and 19 month old that are always so excited to eat here. They are very accommodating to
families with small children. A highchair is immediately brought over before we even ask. The entire staff is warm, welcoming, and great with kids. My favorite dish is the chicken Parmesan. To be honest, one of the bests I’ve ever had. We come here at least once a month, sometimes twice.“

“i love the pizza and pasta“

“Absolutely one of the best tasting pies around! Been going there for years. They also have a new garlic spread that is a MUST HAVE! Great to dip your slice in or have on a white slice. If you haven’t tried it yet, ask for it when you order a pizza! 🍕🇮🇹👌🏼“

“Excellent food! Friendly atmosphere as well?“

“Overall we enjoyed a wonderful meal. We ate at the bar and had a very good meal good service from the younger bar tender. The only negative was the grumpy older bartender who spent most of the time ignoring us and paying attention to his phone.“

“Great food awesome staff great owners👍“

“Not only serving delicious creative pizza, but they use ONLY the healthiest cooking oils! Do NOT eat any pizza using Vegetable/ Soybean chemically-altered cooking oil, or any “seed-oils” in general.“

“What a great Pizza Discovery. First of all, you cannot get any better Customer Service. The Family owned business was highly engaged the moment you walk thru the doors. They have been in the Food Business for 50 years and at this location for 30, so they understand the importance of customer engagement. Their great attitude alone would have me wanting to go back because they are such nice people. Small Family run business, it doesn't get any better. But it does here, the Pizza was excellent and the Homemade dessert knocked it out of the park. The Pizza is unique in that it made like a traditional Neopolitan style where the crust is wet and has some sag at the start of the slice. This is not usually the style with a deck oven Pizza slice, but they pull it off because the dough is so fresh. Perfect blend of cheese with an excellent homemade sauce. They are tucked away in a mini mall in Peacock, but once you make it there once, your taste buds will bring you back. Thank you for a great experience.“