14 Best Seafood Restaurants near West Milford

“Bare-bones, no frills, great slices.This is a charming little 49 year old business run by the same family in West Milford for its entire existence. They don’t pretend to be anything fancier than they are (they’re as un-fancy as a place can get), nor do they put on any airs when all you want is a slice and a Snapple.A busy man - most likely the owner - will take your order in between the conversation he’s having with the other person behind the counter, and there are old, now defunct, coin-operated bubble gum machines up against the wall, and a small menu with very likely little variation from the menu that started it all for them in the mid-70’s is lit up with press-letters in the standard see-through red you grew up seeing in pizza places as a kid.The place is freaking perfect. When I’m back near West Milford High school, I will definitely be dropping in again for a slice“

“Unbelievable experience! Chef was incredibly passionate and skillful in his craft, and each dish is specifically curated to the individual guest. This was a dining experience unlike any other that I would recommend to anyone who enjoys good food and has an open mind.“

“This Is an all around great place to have for our area!! The owners and service are all very nice ,the menu is large with so many different choices and the food is all very good and all at very reasonable prices!!!I would say it's in the middle of a diner and upscale restaurant...we do dine in and take out often for breakfast, lunch and dinner!!“

“Murphys has always been a reliable good place to eat and grab drinks, but recently, they updated their menu, and so far, everything I've tried has been really good to great!The Italian Wedding Soup was really great, and mozzarella sticks were light and crispy.I tried 3 kinds of tacos (steak, beef, pulled pork)- all very good, even held up for take out/eating at home.Personal pizza thin crust, always very good. Appetizer sampler was a great way to try a few things at once!I'm both happy and upset that they have several new desserts, too! I wish they had a sampler for that (!) Better for me, they don't!I got the peanut butter chocolate torte(?) And it was light enough to finish! Uh oh!!! Hahaha!The servers I had were very friendly and accommodating. They feel 'happy to be there', which, as a former hospitality professional, I appreciate seeing, and as a Medium, I appreciate feeling!They make you comfortable and offer great suggestions. (And they didn't know I'm a Google Local Guide either!)The owner is always friendly and hands-on as well too.I am very glad for their beautiful renovations and extension, to be able to sit outside in nice weather, easy parking, and fair prices. This restaurant/bar is definitely an asset to our community.And with the new menu, I'll definitely be going more and bringing more friends!Peace, abundance, and continued success for 2024, and always!“

“Regular here, and I can't say one bad thing. Amazing food, very comforting atmosphere, service, and all around ambiance.Seriously, my go to spot legit once a week! Amazing all around!!!Sincerely, corner table regularKid-friendliness: Very accommodating.“

“Let's rally around the Paradise Restaurant! Remember Tuscany? Several former staff are there, and a fantastic new chef! They're planning on expanding the bar into the large dining room! Great atmosphere, staff, and food! We had the eggplant parm and chicken franchaise and it was top notch! Calamari was tender and crispy! Beer and wine selection was very good as well!“

“Brought the kids to Ferati’s tonight and they did not disappoint! We are originally from Brooklyn so we know good pizza. Alex made my daughter the most delicious chicken roll! The quality of food made me feel like I was back home in Brooklyn! Will be coming back often!“

“We licked our knives! Need we say more?! (We didn’t eat everything so we asked them to use a spatula to be sure to get all the sauce!) LOL! But seriously, we just found our new favorite restaurant! Everything is exceptional from the moment you walk in! Excellent service, excellent atmosphere, PHENOMENAL FOOD! Can’t wait to come back! Eric was the most excellent waiter!“

“We had the Caesar salad, delicious! I had the spinach fettuccini with onions, peas and Sunday Sauce. It was very good, but my boyfriend had their signature Pork which was absolutely amazing! It was so flavorful and tender. Service was excellent, and ambiance wonderful. I highly recommend.“

“We had lunch on a Friday, the restaurant was quiet, but the atmosphere was warm our waiter was very professional, very pleasant. We ordered lunch with main course and dessert. The food was absolutely authentic, high end. My veal chop came with an assortment of mushrooms that were perfectly prepared,: flavorful, seasoned just right. My husband another meat dish from the menu, that he hereby declared truly delicious. We hadn't gone back to Cenzino in a long time, but may well be make it a more regular stop.The restaurant is elegant, pristinely clean. Such a nice time.“

“We've been here several times for brunch. Easily the best brunch (steak and eggs) we've ever had. Service is way above great. Accommodating and friendly. Great bar tender and hostess. Can't recommend this establishment highly enough.“

“Very good food, and a unique menu. For example, we had the lobster Mac and Cheese, a combination I had never heard of before. They actually paired very well, especially with Vibe's original cheese blend. It is not your typical burger and beer place, it really is a cut above. It is also kid friendly, with many games like skee ball on site. They also have a large room in the back for parties.“

“Finally came tonight after months of hearing good reviews from friends. My husband and I are definitely going to be regulars. There are so many different choices on the menu that we had a difficult time choosing. We decided to go with the onion soup and goat cheese salad for appetizers and Burger and Salmon for our entrees (which were all delicious!) Can't wait to try all their other options! Didn't have room for dessert, but the options looked so good! Service is on point and friendly. This is truly a hidden gem!“

“We’ve had a beautiful Sunday afternoon at The Breezy, sipping on our wine, listening to great music and chatting with new friends. we highly recommend this place especially in the summer sitting outside watching the boats on the lake eating delicious food and sipping on your favorite beverage. Thanks Paul will see you soon!“