15 Best Pizza Restaurants near Amenia

“Stopped in to have a slice when I was grocery shopping. The pizza was really good! Definitely glad I stopped in, will definitely be returning to this pizzeria in the near future.That even let us, at North East Ford, put up our display featuring our $2 inspection sticker coupons. Thank you“

“Very unexpected. There is a sign in the small building that is called "the grand shack" we wanted to go to the 4 brothers pizza inn, but TBH we could tell if it was open. The snack shack, which I guess is attached to the drive, it was great! I had a great burger, good price. Nice service. Very nice outdoor seating area. A bit quirky.“

“The fricken best. Hands down. Owners an OG from the Gambino neighborhood. Marinara sauce takes 10 hrs to make and uses organic san marzanos. These guys know what's up. I come out here once a year for a race at limerock and Deanos is always a stop on the way out. Gentleman this is the guy from Rochester who asked for whatever marinara sauce you could part with and told you he didn't care what it cost.So we always order calzones and guys......I gotta say......this fricken meat baby you put together for me was next level alright? From the quality of the rocioitta to the beautiful mozz that was stuffed inside this perfect dough baby. Look a chicken pepp and spinach calzone is not supposed to taste this good. Especially for $12 come on..and the homemade sauce on top of that? I'm talking we got tomato seeds, fresh basil (which is sweet as all hell, just beautiful basil) onions that you know have been sweating for a minute. Next time im down that way I'm gonna have to call in a gallon order of that sauce.Long story short. Good people. Good pies. Good calzones. Damn good ingredients and it shows. You guys get it. God bless and keep doing you guys.“

“Great place. The food is amazing!!! We've eaten here several times and every time the food is outstanding! Their meals and pizzas are delicious and the sushi is fantastic. We had the Spicy Chicken Katsu and Katsu Deluxe the other night, it blew our minds how good it was!! While the bar/restaurant area is very small and gets crowded quickly, they offer a pick up option on the side of the business (this is the way to go).“

“Staff and food are outstanding!The menu is updated regularly and seasonally, so there are new things to try.Cocktails are as good as they get!If weather permits, the patio is an excellent place for a meal and company.I highly recommend trying this place when you're in the area.“

“I experienced wonderful moments at this place over the course of a month. I used to come to this establishment in the evening to relax after a demanding day spent at the art residency. Amazing people, fantastic food, excellent beer. I hope to return there someday and reconnect with the 'old' friends. Wishing Lantern lots of relaxed evenings. Paul from Czech republic ;-*“

“I usually don't care about Burger or Pizza-not my thing. But Cozzy's changed my opinion. Love Love his nice thin crust white pizza also he makes a great side fresh veggies cooked in olive oil Italian style ? omg talking about it, I want that for a dinner again!“

“Their pizza gets all the stars amazing. We also had jalapeno poppers they were not so great as I think they were in the freezer for 2 months. The garlic knots fantastic as well. The service was horrible the waitress seemed like she had no interest I get it was a Wednesday night and it was slow but she never even came over to see if we needed any more drinks or anything. I'm sure on a busy night like the weekends they are better staffed so I wouldn't hold that against them I will definitely be back because that pizza was amazing“

“Tower Pizza is genuinely the real deal. The pizza is amazing, the meatballs are top tier, and the sauce is truly incredible. I’m very picky, as my family owned a famous Italian restaurant in Jersey City for many years, but I rave about this place to anyone who will listen.The owner and his staff are talented and hard working. They remember my husband’s name when he goes to pick up. Every time we get food here, it’s so consistent, which is crucial, and we order without fail at least 1x a week. My new favorite restaurant.“

“It's a great place to sit down and have a nice dinner. Their pizza is pan pizza so if you're looking for New York style this is not the place but they're pan pizza is pretty good. I've also had a few of their dinners and their appetizers and the food is top-notch great place if you're in the Kent area. They also have a bar and an outside patio which I cannot review as I have not been there when it's warm yet and I have not tended to the bar but the atmosphere looked pretty great on the bar side.“

“This is our second visit to Fern. This time we brought one of our college kids with us! Lucky we had a reservation, because it was busy! Got drinks right away...always a good start! Got the burrata appetizer - a lot of cheese and not much toast, but the flavor was lovely. Maybe another wee bit of bread to go with the ginormous piece of cheese? And pesto on each piece! Moving on. Dinner was terrific...we all had pasta: gnocchi, cavatelli and rigatoni...all delicious, not sure which I liked best and with a glass of red wine, now that is perfection! Kid got the budino aka Italian chocolate pudding. Not too sweet, which is perfect! She loved it. Michael was our server and did a splendid job, he was on point the whole time! A wonderful evening was had by all and the bill was reasonable too!“

“I loved Swyft! I heard about the place for a while & was not disappointed. It is a small & cozy gathering place with a fireplace. The beet salad, cheese plate & carrots were all a hit (see photo) Presentation was A+. The real show stopper was wood-fired PIZZA! (we ordered TIGER KING, the one with the chili oil on it, YUM!)“

“My family and I love this place. Their pizza is SO delicious and they have a crispy chicken wrap that is the only thing I want to eat while I’m currently pregnant. My husband tried their wrap with greek dressing tonight and the dressing was AMAZING. The people who work there are always so nice. I am shocked there are any negative reviews. Can’t wait to come back soon! ??“

“This is a more laid-back restaurant in the Four Brothers chain. The family pizza recipe is delicious and uniquely their own. This location is neat and clean but has not had the facelift of the others so stepping inside is loke being transported back a generation. My favorite stop in Millerton.“

“Absolutely, love this place! Great for a quick slice, always good. Great for a company lunch & even a family dinner. Had wings, pizza, pasta. It's all good & staff is friendly. Place is always clean & you can sit inside or outside“