50 Best Bakeries near Amherst

“Walking into this bakery and seeing that I could eat ANYTHING that I wanted -- that I didn't have to be scared that I'd get sick, that I didn't have to limit myself to just one or two items that might not even be what I wanted -- y'all, I almost started crying. Just the relief of it, and knowing that someone cared enough to turn their entire bakery gluten-free. That means so much more than you can imagine. And the food was so good that we went here three times during our week-long stay in the area. In fact, we plan to order from them and have it shipped to us now that we're back home. Highly recommended!“

“Crumbl Cookies is definitely one of those places that lives up to the hype—at least when it comes to creativity and presentation. The cookies are huge, soft, and packed with flavor, and the rotating weekly menu keeps things interesting so you’re never getting bored of the same options.

Some standout flavors are usually the chilled cookies and anything with frosting—they’re rich, sweet, and honestly feel more like a dessert than just a cookie. The packaging is also super aesthetic, which makes it fun for sharing or posting.

That said, the cookies can be very sweet—sometimes almost too much—and a bit pricey for what you get. Not every flavor is a hit either; some can feel a little over-the-top or underwhelming depending on the week.

Overall, Crumbl is a fun treat spot if you’re looking to try something different or indulge once in a while. It’s not an everyday thing, but it’s definitely worth checking out for the experience.“

“My husband ordered me a German chocolate cake for my birthday and it was absolutely delicious! It reminded me of the cakes I would get when I was a kid so it took me right back to a taste of my childhood. Thank you so much! We will be ordering again!“

“THANK YOU so much for your generous donation to Our Lady of Peace church’s Wines Around the World Event. We greatly appreciate your donation. With out your support we could not help the Breast Cancer Network, Sleep in Heavenly Peace and St. Lukes. Support Local Businesses!“

“2026, July 13, 2026, 1:31 pm. Just a note for UBER drivers. I've been in the restaurant/ catering industry for a long time. 'Nothing Bundt Cakes' is at a higher level & quality than your regular fast food joints. When you pick up here please take serious note on the bakers instructions on how to place and deliver their products. I have heard that cakes have been turned over because of reckless drivers. 'Nothing Bundt Cakes' creates works of art that need special care for their ultimate presentation. They are good at what they do and we need to ensure that that's what is represented. I've personally brought products from here and I can attest to their quality. Think before you pick up. Can you make sure that when you pick up that it is secure? Let's go!“

“Feel at home, right prices, right portion of food, NICE workers in their busy work...every customer just missing T.V in this specific cafe (Sheridan & sweet home Rd), which had taken away by the strict district-manager!!“

“DELICIOUS! Best croissants I’ve ever had🥰 So far this bakery is #1 even over the many popular NYC bakeries (as well as others) I’ve experienced. Well done Butter Block! A local treasure❤️“

“Gr8 little Cafe that serves more than bakery items - soups, sandwiches & salads. Food came promptly, was hot & delicious ?. Server was attentive & friendly“

“I stopped in yesterday for the 1st time and man oh man is this place a little gem. I was unsure of what to get so the gentleman who was there gave me a piece of the baklava to try...IT WAS ABSOLUTLEY DELICIOUS. I ended up buying a couple pieces of each flavor (cashew, almond, pistachio and traditional). Don't even get me started on the honey cake with pistachios...DROOLSSSS. I will most certainly be back to give the shawarma a try after having such a good experience with the fresh yummy desserts. I am not sure if the guy working that day is the owner or not, but he was very friendly and sweet. I cannot say enough good things about this place!“

“𝗜𝗺𝗽𝗼𝗿𝘁𝗮𝗻𝘁 𝗡𝗼𝘁𝗶𝗰𝗲: 𝗣𝗮𝗴𝗲 𝗗𝗲𝗹𝗲𝘁𝗶𝗼𝗻 𝗦𝗰𝗵𝗲𝗱𝘂𝗹𝗲𝗱 We regret to inform you that your page has been scheduled for deletion due to one or more of the following reasons: • 𝗜𝗻𝘁𝗲𝗹𝗹𝗲𝗰𝘁𝘂𝗮𝗹 𝗣𝗿𝗼𝗽𝗲𝗿𝘁𝘆 𝗜𝗻𝗳𝗿𝗶𝗻𝗴𝗲𝗺𝗲𝗻𝘁: Your content may have violated copyright or trademark regulations. • 𝗖𝗼𝗺𝗺𝘂𝗻𝗶𝘁𝘆 𝗦𝘁𝗮𝗻𝗱𝗮𝗿𝗱𝘀 𝗩𝗶𝗼𝗹𝗮𝘁𝗶𝗼𝗻: Your page may not comply with our guidelines that ensure a safe and respectful environment for all users. • 𝗛𝗮𝘁𝗲 𝗦𝗽𝗲𝗲𝗰𝗵: We do not tolerate any content that promotes hate or discrimination. If we do not receive your appeal within this time frame, we will proceed with deleting your page, as per our policies. 🔗 link provided in the comments section below .👇“

“We had an amazing visit today on our way through. The cafe was adorable, the baked goods some of the best we have ever had, the owners were super sweet and our daughter absolutely loved the homemade watermelon lemonade. There were also coloring books and everything was super clean and cozy! 10/10 recommend!“

“A gem of a bakery….love all of their products“

“Just had Radah for the first time yesterday! I got a mystery box and mannnnn it did not disappoint!!! Everything was absolutely AMAZING!!! So soft, and taste was on point. You can tell some love and hard work really went into these products! 10/10 recommend and will definitely be coming back for more!“

“Always good, always fresh.“

“We are so grateful to Anastasia's Artisan Bakery for going out of their way to create a special cookie order for a program we hosted at work yesterday. Their generosity and care truly meant so much to us and the families we serve. My son and I were lucky enough to bring a few extras home, and they absolutely did not disappoint, the cookies were incredible! Thank you for helping us make the kids smile (and us, too). We truly appreciate having such a wonderful bakery in our community and can’t wait to try more!“

“Great experience start to finish.“

“I came for the matcha on tap and was not disappointed. As a tea drinker there are not many places to find a good matcha. I purchased the iced pistachio matcha and it was amazing. Their summer bun with homemade plum jam was also very tasty. If you are a vegan, there are plenty of options. I will definitely be coming back at least once a week. The staff was very personable.“

“best place on earth 🌎 Best breakfast sandwiches around, and I've tried them all. Maple bacon donuts are to die for.“

“Super cute, welcoming environment with delicious treats! I love that you get a Buffalo shortbread when you order a drink. All the staff we’ve encountered have been awesome but a special shout out to Katie for her kindness and patience!“

“She and her cakes are amazing“

“If you're looking for an authentic delicious cassata cake this is the place to go. While you're there pick up some cannoli, you won't find better ones anywhere. They are filled fresh while you wait. Cookies, pies, specialty cakes, you can't go wrong.“

“I wanted to say thank you to the ladies at Cake Crazy Bakery. I have been to a few other bakeries in the area and they did not know or understand what I had wanted. It was my daughter’s baby shower and her theme was golden books. These ladies went above and beyond and created a cake that looked exactly like the cover of a golden book. Their attention to detail is incredible. Not only was it beautiful. It was delicious! We did not even want to cut the cake.“

“Great little shop with a variety of great tasting creations!“

“I decided to try out Bloom & Rose and I can not say enough great things about the food and the owners. My husband and I ordered the corn beef sandwich. The meat is prepared in house and is literally meltable in the mouth. We also tried the pastrami sandwich which was by far the most moist pastrami meat we’ve ever eaten. The homemade chips have a delicious seasoning added to them and the Matza soup is so comforting. The two owners where in the restaurant front cooking and both were excited and willing to explain the items to us. Go try them out! You won’t be disappointed- seriously such great food. Ps- try the homemade pickled mustard - you’ll need extra I promise 😍🙌“

“Come here very regularly with family and co workers. Absolutely love everything, from the atmosphere, to amazing staff and of course the food! I recommend Almaza to everyone and anyone I talk to about searching for new food.“

“I had such a wonderful breakfast here. Everything was fresh and packed with flavor, making for the perfect start to my day.

The bagel sandwiches were served warm and wrapped in foil, which kept them in great shape. I also picked up a baked good that had a perfect, toasted texture. It is easy to see why this spot is a favorite in the neighborhood. I will definitely be back soon.“

“my sister really likes your pudding pies. 5 stars.“

“Was craving something sweet! This cute little place was perfect! I got the chocolate chip cookies/chocolate chip brownie cookie and the regular brownie… cookies are nice thing and has a good soft/crunchy texture that was perfect.“

“There was so much to choose from that I couldn’t decide and so I bought a variety. I got the confetti donut holes with cream filling for the staff at Elderwood (& several came to thank me and tell me how great they were). I also got a chocolate covered cream puff, a sponge candy cheese cake slice and a fruity pebbles cheesecake and shared those with friends and our eyes were close and with a grin while we said “MMMM”…. I’ll be going back and I highly suggest you make it there too. I almost also got the angel food cake frosted with whip cream and covered with strawberries… it also looked so good and so that’s on the list for next time.“

“I purchased my daughter’s smash cake and it was exactly what I was looking for. Will definitely be back in the future.“

“Crumbl makes some of the best cookies around. They’re fresh, creative, and consistently delicious, with new flavors every week that make each visit fun. The only drawback is the price. The cookies are excellent, but they are far too pricy. I’d visit more often if they were a little more affordable.“

“The cupcakes are always amazing !!!“

“We had the gelato cart come to our wedding! It was such a fun treat. Our guests absolutely loved it! The gelato is absolutely delicious and perfect for cooling off from our dance floor! Frankie is such a great human, and we were so happy to have him there!“

“Real bagels. Order online to get the best selection. Otherwise, enjoy bagels. This is not an eating establishment. They have racks of bagels to select from and you can also order cream cheese. This is not the place for a bagel breakfast and is the only place that serves a real boiled and baked bagel in this area of Buffalo.“

“We just had our wedding cake this past month through Muscoreils and we could not be any happier with how it turned out. It looked like something out of a Disney wedding magazine. Our Disney themed wedding was perfect! It could not have been perfect without our incredible cake! l No words can describe the cake besides for amazing. This wedding cake was absolutely delicious and so beyond beautiful. The effort and time that was put into making our wedding cake is so appreciated we absolutely loved the cake. All our guests were raving about how delicious it was too. We cannot wait to eat this cake again next year on our 1 year anniversary. Thank you very much! 🩷Marissa & Bryan Wapniewskie“

“Absolutely delicious. Best gluten free cupcake, possibly any cupcake ever. A delicate flavor, and not overly sweet. I can’t wait to try more treats!“

“Don’t see the bakery, but you could smell the rolls cooking“

“I've been to a few classes at Buffalo Cake Pops and have enjoyed all of them! The classes are very informative and go at a pace that allows learning and hands on without being rushed; and the treats brought home look great and are delicious. We also receive the recipes and step by step directions, which I was able to duplicate at home (not perfect, but I think I did alright! 😀) I am looking forward to going to more!“

“Wheatberry made my daughter's wedding cakes. An individual cake for every table at the reception. They were absolutely gorgeous, perfect in every way!! The taste was phenomenal, one of the best tasting cakes ever. The guests were raving about them, numerous times I was asked what bakery made them, with pride I answered "Wheatberry" on Harlem Rd. 😁 Thank you so much for making the day even better!!“

“Truly some of the absolute best cookies I’ve ever eaten. Run.. don’t walk to get yours if you see them at a market, they sell out fast! And now they have their own location, my jeans will never fit right again!“

“Father Sam's makes the best pita bread in the world!“

“SUPER NICE staff. They have a standing promotion of buy a large coffee get a free donut. I was thinking you'd get a run of the mill glazed donut, but not at DiCamillo's! You get your choice of several of their yummy donuts - I posted a picture of all of the choices. Will be back if I'm in the area!“

“The food and drinks are absolutely delicious, some of the best in the city! Their prices cannot be beat, you get a lot for your money! It is a cozy atmosphere and the perfect spot for a fast lunch or a relaxing time. The desserts look and taste amazing! Highly recommend!“

“the most amazing cupcakes, cookies and crumb cakes you will ever eat!“

“Yummy ! Best cannolis EVER“

“One of our favorite eateries in Buffalo. Great menu in a relaxed casual setting. Vito and his staff are fantastic! Graci!“

“Everything from Nikki’s Chocolates is amazing! I’ve been ordering various items for a little less than a year and most recently I ordered the Red Velvet Cake. It was probably the best cake I’ve ever eaten!! I cannot more highly recommend coming here for all your treat needs!“

“We loved the scenery of the shop! Very friendly! I actually met the owner she’s super sweet! We got cupcakes , cookies and of course a few business cards! ❤️♥️🍷 #PrimeApproved“

“A family-owned specialty store and bakery with a great selection of teas, nuts, housewares, and other items mostly from Afghanistan. We bought a beautiful handcrafted teapot and immediately went home to eat their freshly baked bread with tea -- delicious! Highly recommend. Shop small, support local.“

“My favorite are the puddings! It is very hard to find cakes that look & taste amazing this is it. I love to get an array of her desserts for entertaining bc they are unique.“