50 Best Ice Cream Shops near Bayville

“I wish this establishment the best of luck. They have quality products. The store is sparkling clean.“

“This 16 Handles location is always a great experience! The store is spotless, and the friendly staff create such a warm, welcoming environment-especially with kids. I really appreciate how clearly everything is labeled, from which toppings are kosher to what allergens are present, making it easy to eat here with confidence. Highly recommend!“

“Brown butter cookie dough is a must.“

“I really love this place! I mean, we don’t come here often, but tasting on ice cream served here once again made me remember how well it’s appreciated and respected. For one, the flavors are excellent. My brother was shocked to have 2 enormous balls of ice cream on such a small cone, but when tasting the brownie ice cream left him with a reaction similar to the one in ratatouille where the midget chef eats ratatouille and grasps the table cloth. Unfortunately, I could not take a photo of his ice cream but I did for my pistachio. I would love to come here more often.“

“If you want a place to go eat with dirty hands this is the one! Bathroom is always closed but there’s an alley not too far away. You can tell management really cares about the customer experience when they keep the bathroom closed from customers. And they even have tables, that alone would be a health department violation(tables without a working bathroom) but who has time to call them anyway? I think the stuff here is delicious but it could also be the flavor from the last customer on the door handle so who knows?“

“fresh buns and delicious dogs!“

“Tiny ice cream place that does their own take on ice cream sundaes and shaved ice, with tons of tropical flavors and a "sundae" that has fresh fruit and condensed milk on top. The ice cream quality is very high, the people are lovely and eager to help, the portions are huge, and the combination of ice cream and fruit is extremely refreshing.“

“I have visited this store unexpectedly, and I must admit, the staff’s were very friendly and helpful, the atmosphere was very pleasant and extremely welcoming. This store is very tidy and make anyone feel they’re being treated right and they have a great selection of products to choose from.
Jason- Queens- NYC
Attorney- In- Fact!“

“Immaculate frozen yogurt store and friendly staff. They’re following strict Covid protocols. Great tasting yogurt too! 🍦“

“delicious shaved ice, portion size, swag and value for the price. also a plus that it's located in a cute spot in sea cliff. you need to check this place out when open. only draw back is that it's a little slow to get things made. but it's worth the wait on a summer day.“

“The Dubai chocolate brownie probably one of the best we had from crumbles. Pink sugar/red velvet was also great. My son crazy for crumble cookies sometimes I took a bites it’s really fulfilling . One time we had a bad experience with delivery the guy really made the cookies disgusting I don’t recommend order this way but for pick up yes. Cookies was fresh and delicious!“

“Absolutely spectacular service all around. I came in with a nut allergy, and even though it was packed, Josie and Cira were there to help me pick out flavors while being cautious of my allergies. I would recommend this place out of anywhere else in Huntington. Very clean, classy, respectful, and great service!“

“Highly recommended shop! I’m new to the North Shore and have been looking for a non-chain local coffee shop in the area. CoCo was recommended to me by a friend who raved about them and it does not disappoint. Terrence does not miss a single detail- from the quality of the coffee—to the matcha powder—to the innovative drink menu- to the hand-painted made in-house delicious chocolate truffles that fly off the shelves daily- to the warm and welcoming hip vibe that makes you feel like you’re sitting in a coffee shop in Greenwich Village. It’s also refreshing to see them support other small businesses in the area with an array of baked goods from St Rocco’s made especially for this store to fantastic local donuts. Great gift boxes filled with these heavenly chocolate bites are also available around the holidays. Easily one of my favorite gems I’ve discovered in the area so far (and yes, they blow away Karmic Grind).“

“Today I was walking by an Alkemy store, and through the glass, I saw two girls working on an ice cream machine that was billowing out white smoke. It looked so cool! The girls were really pretty, super cute, and just so nice. When they saw me taking a picture, they even waved at me and smiled. I was pretty busy today and didn't have time to stop and grab a bite, but I definitely need to go back and try their ice cream next time!“

“Fresh and delicious. Will visit again“

“Loved my candied nut popcorn !!! Ice cream is amazing too. And awesome customer service 👍🏼“

“This is a nice locally-owned ice cream shop super close to the train station and in walking distance of a lot of shops. They’ve got sorbet, some interesting ice cream flavors, toppings, frozen yogurt, and a ton of other items. We got a cup and a cone and had quick and friendly service. The waffle cone didn’t seem homemade, but it was still tasty. Recommend for a cold treat on a hot day.“

“Wonderful ice cream experience. I got the mint chip & it was delicious.“

“I've been seeing the really good food posted on Social Media and finally made the 5 minute trek. I have to say the calzones and pizza were excellent! The calzones are enormous. Where looking forward to trying something different next time, and next time will be soon! ��“

“Ice Cream Deliciousness!!!!“

“Unique and fun experience! Delicious ice cream and friendly workers! Will definitely be back!! Coram location“

“Had a great experience! Came in tonight after an event and there was a line out the door. Staff was patient and kind despite the craziness of kids running in and out. Emily was the name of our server and she was kind, joyful, organized and patient when my kids ordered 3 razzles and a milkshake during all the craziness. Will definitely be back!!“

“As a frequent visitor to TCBY, I can confidently say that each visit continues to exceed expectations with its consistently high-quality offerings, welcoming ambiance, and exceptional service. The frozen yogurt is always luxuriously smooth and perfectly balanced between rich and refreshing, with flavors like white chocolate mousse and birthday cake remaining personal favorites. The toppings bar is thoughtfully curated, offering a wide array of fresh fruit, gourmet sauces, and crunchy mix-ins that allow for endless customization. The staff are consistently courteous, attentive, and efficient, which contributes to the inviting and well-managed atmosphere. TCBY’s commitment to excellence, both in product and service, is why I return time and time again—and why I never hesitate to recommend it to others.“

“I love the products and the crew“

“This had been out number one spot for ice cream cakes. My family and I have been coming here for over a decade . Everyone always asks us where we bought our cake after a party . It is only cash only so be prepared before you go. Over 15 flavors to choose from, you won't be disappointed.“

“great shakes and and great ice creams with lots of flavors that I would highly recommend it. I wouldn't give it 5 stars because there's no seating as the whole indoor space is taken up by freezers. I think better stand up freezer to reduce floor space and make seating available would really improve the image of the place and for people who want to come there. I definitely want to have more of their shakes more often!“

“Their location has changed since the picture was posted. They’ve reopened nearby and introduced a variety of new flavors. My favorite has been the acai bowl, but you really can't go wrong with their cream or water ices. Their banana shake is just as delightful as any of their other specialty shakes and ice creams. I believe I visit them 3 to 4 times a week.“

“The best carvel store in the area! All of the employees are so wonderful and accommodating with my family and especially my 4 year old daughter. Always have a smile on their face and all of their products are delicious!! They are a staple to the Port Chester and Greenwich communities. We are regulars for many, many years.“

“Delicious frozen yogurt!🍦🍨“

“***** (Five Star) Review - The hubby and I love the Hicksville Sweet Shop! It is such a warm and welcoming restaurant/ice cream shop – were everyone knows your name! We reserved a table for Valentines Day and had a wonderful meal consisting of crab cakes, fried shrimp, French fries, vegetables and, for dessert, fresh homemade strawberry shortcake – reservations are rarely needed! Homemade ice cream and chocolates are also delicious! I can honestly say I never had a bad meal at the Hicksville Sweet Shop! Thank you Eva, Phil, Harry, Walter, Alma, Jeannie & Clair❤️e!“

“One of my favorite places for ice cream in Huntington! The chocolates are homemade too & TOTALLY delicious!“

“AMAZING!!! First time customer. The first thing that caught my eye was the decor. It reminds me of an old school ice cream parlor. The aroma of a freshly made crepe was in the air. Not knowing what to order, the owner asked what I liked and then created this beautiful crepe just for me. I can tell you this was delicious! If you’re in the area you must go and check it out. You will not be disappointed!“

“I recently visited Sunny Daes for the first time, and I was impressed by the quality of the ice cream. It was delicious and clearly made with care. However, the service didn't quite match up to the same standard. I understand that it can get busy, but it's important to maintain consistent and friendly customer service. Instead of feeling rushed to make a decision, a little more patience and attentiveness from the staff would greatly enhance the overall experience.“

“Ordered a cappuccino blast and a mini cone cake. Both were amazing. The drink was very refreshing and not overwhelmingly sweet or heavy. The cake I got cookie dough and cookies and cream. My friends and family loved it.

Kid-friendliness: Kids love ice cream“

“Amazing. So incredibly fresh. We will be back.“

“Its always difficult finding a chocolate flavor and at the time I went they had it! They have two vegan flavors at a time. Today was a fruity pomegranate and the other was a chocolate. You can call them and ask when they have currently. Im pleasantly surprised someone picked up“

“I teach at the local high school and we recently had Ralph’s cater our Junior Prom. They only required a few days advanced notice and provided a great price. Drop off and pick up was excellent; I had forgotten to ask for spoons and they went and picked them up for me!

In prior years, we’d paid 4x as much for an ice cream truck, but the kids liked the Ralph’s way more. They are great for individual orders but are also great for catering; give them a try!“

“My wife and I were dining outdoors at a nearby restaurant, and we kept seeing people walking by with ice cream cones. My wife checked her smartphone and discovered there was this ice cream shop just past the restaurant. We enjoyed our meal, but we craved ice cream, so we had our dessert at Gofer's. I had a handmade waffle cone with chocolate and black raspberry chip ice creams. Very yummy! Gofers had soft serve ice cream, ice cream cakes, ice cream quarts to go, and more. It was a popular place on a Saturday evening. It's well worth a visit.“

“The truffle fries were to die for and the burger was just the right size and delish!“

“Ottimo 👏 lavoro . Gelato come in Italia“

“Delicious cake, amazing staff - who dealt with my craziness on such short notice. Beautifully decorated and brought such a smile to my 16-year-old daughter's face (which isn't easy😉) Even the restaurant staff was impressed by the taste and texture of the cake. Can't wait to stop in again for a treat or to order another specialty cake.“

“Seriously the best ices and ice creams ever. They have douzaines of classic dessert and candy flavors which are better then the originals. It's pure and elevates your spirit up to the moon! Once a year, we travel to Long Island, New York and, we dream about Ralph's all year round, back in Canada. What we would do to have this here in our country.“

“It is so refreshing to know there is someone bilingual working at a busy place like this, if I am not mistaken she said her name was Kaylin. She took her time naming flavors to my father in Spanish which was so sweet. This location always has the nicest girls every time we go, I applaud the owners and the managers.“

“Just got off the phone with Jared. His service is fantastic! Friendly, efficient, and a pleasure to work with!“

“Great ice cream and customer service!“

“Great place on a warm summer night for an array of cold, frozen treats. Don't forget that Wednesday's are bogo free ice cream sundaes. Very clean, great, quick and happy staff. Highly recommend!“

“I went here with my family to get a cake for my moms birthday. All the small cakes (which we wanted) were taken (as it was Easter). A very nice woman (I didn't catch her name) came to us and said that she would give us a cake for a lower price. Very very pleased with customer service. Would give more stars if I could.“

“Ice cream is amazing. Employees are super friendly, especially Andre. I love the vibe they have and how kind they are, I don’t understand any negative reviews. The ice cream and shakes are delicious. I think people in this mall and area just like complaining.“

“My husband and I have been here a few times and its always been a good time. We went a few days ago and the man working greeted us warmly and gave us time to look and decide what we wanted with zero pressure. Our order was accurate and tasted great, just like the few things we picked out from the freezer. This will be our go to for ice cream, it was perfect!“