50 Best Italian Restaurants near Bayville

“Absolutely excellent pizza!! Food is amazing as well!!“

“Great pasta, healthy, light, fresh… simply delicious“

“What a great restaurant! Angelo and Oscar run a tight ship. Can’t wait to revisit.“

“As always I give this restaurant 5 stars. Met friends for dinner on Sunday night. The service is exceptional. All of us had something different and we all enjoyed our food. My friend did a price fixed with filet of sole and said it was delicious. The brussel sprouts appetizer was excellent. We also started with fried calamari, though small portion, was good. I had a hamburger which was huge with the onions and musrooms. The burger was cooked to perfection. The other two in our party also finished their food. It was very quiet so we were able to communicate easily with our friends.“

“Food and the service was awesome. Reasonably priced. Relaxing atmosphere. Highly recommend.“

“We had an incredible dinner. The service was impeccable and the food delicious.“

“Attended a baby shower this afternoon...food was delicious... lovely venue...would love to return for dinner! Wonderful place for a private party, too!“

“Great food!! Nice staff!! Nice place“

“Love having Natalie back behind the bar! And Chef Ming is an artist. Seriously blew us away with his skills on the most basic dish - his classic cheese pizza. It’s almost what you would classify as classic Neopolitan, but with hardly any flop. He clearly chooses the best ingredients as well. Such an amazing surprise Can’t wait to go back with the family.“

“The meal was delicious. my son and I had the Penne Diane and asked for the chicken to be blackened which was perfect. my daughter had the Pesto Sole and said it was the best and my husband had the Snapper which was perfection.“

“Best pizza in Port Washington.“

“We had my daughter’s communion here with 20 people and it surpassed our expectations. All of the food was delicious, our waitress was terrific and everyone had a great time. The family style food was perfect and we had a wide selection to choose from. I would definitely recommend Porto Fino for a party.“

“Exceptional dining experience! The atmosphere was perfect, and the staff were warm and attentive while providing timely service. The food did not disappoint. Our table ordered appetizers, lobster ravioli, arugula salad with shrimp and veal scallopini. We look forward to our next opportunity to visit!“

“We brought in a great dinner from Rosina’s today. The food was amazing. Fresh and delicious tasting. And unfortunately they forgot one important item in the order and they were so kind to deliver that item to my house. Thank u Rosina’s.“

“This wonderful dinner was incredible!!!! absolutely 💯 delicious and way above other Italian restaurants in the area. They make food with love!!! Everything from beginning ✨️ to end was perfect 🥰 Thank you so very much for the hard work that you put into this! The food is fresh, hot and delicious! Loved the full glasses 🥂 of wine 🍷 too!!!“

“We arrived poorly dressed on a frigid evening without a reservation and were heartily welcomed at the small bar. They were such lovely and hospitable people. The food was amazing, the atmosphere cosy and welcoming, and the bill reasonable.“

“Great staff and great food even during this pandemic. And accommodating“

“used to eat at Café Continental all the time and have not in many years. It did not disappoint. My sister loved her dish and I loved mine. Generous free plate of cheese and salami and wonderful bread. I will be going back again soon and recommending to others. The downside is the many stairs you have to walk to get into the restaurant from the back parking lot and the decor is a tad tired. Neither of those deficits would keep me from coming back.“

“I have been here numerous times and have always had the best experience.All waiters and helpers pitch in to make the service fantastic and have recommended it to all my friends.“

“By far one of the best Italian restaurants I have been to! Excellent service- food made to order. Chicken Scarpiello was so flavorful with a lot of garlic, herbs and a touch of lemon. Penne Ala Vodka one of the best I have ever tasted! Chicken Verde was so tender it melted in your mouth!!“

“Great food, great service! Will be back for sure!“

“Order # 6760 on 7/14/22 was cooked to perfection. Order was ready when i arrived. It was excellent t!!!“

“Ho mangiato bene! Che bella musica direttament Di Modena Claudio Mattioli e Massimiliano Barbolimi. BRAVO 👏🏻 BRAVO 👏🏻“

“Friendly service Excellent food“

“The best Mediterranean food in Westchester. Great for parties, date night, and catching up with old friends. Come in and have a meal. You won't regret it!“

“Food was delicious and the service was great!!! Will definitely return.“

“I was there as a wedding photographer and liked their service.“

“A staple for us. We go here all the time. One of the best plain slices in all of New York City (and state probably!)

Parking: Can park around the corner of spots aren't available on plandome

Wheelchair accessibility: Should be good. I believe there's a double door to enter and at grade - no step up or down to order and for some of the tables in the front.“

“The food is consistently excellent. The team is very professional and makes each guest feel like a VIP! Wonderful and welcoming atmosphere for almost 40 years! La Parma II is a great asset to Huntington!“

“Homemade pastas. Amazing spaghetti and clams.“

“Classic Italian prepared fresh daily.“

“After living out of state for the past 5 years, we needed to find a local place to have a private family luncheon after funeral services for my father-in-law. We met with Sergio on Wednesday and he completely accommodated all of our wishes for that upcoming Saturday in his beautifully appointed private room. We couldn’t have asked for a better four-course meal and the staff provided service that was top notch and utmost respectful under the circumstances. We enjoyed a memorable celebration of life! Thank you Sergio & Staff for making a very difficult day, end with warm hearts and happy bellies 🖤 Until we visit again...“

“Great Italian recipes, with wonderful Desserts. The Service is good, and the Restaurant is kept clean. Have eaten at DiMaggios numbers times. Never disappointed!! Recommended Highly.“

“WOW....this is my new favorite restaurant!!!Our meal was absolutely DELICIOUS. Grilled Veal w vegtable & whipped potatoes literally melted in your mouth! The short ribs on a bed of pasta was a masterpiece. The sauce w linguini & clams cooked & seasoned perfectlySalad with pear & goat cheese ...excellentGrilled octopus was cooked perfectly (not chewy)Apple tart w crepes...again excellent!From drinks to dessert everything was PERFECTION!If you want great food....Franina is the place!“

“Great Quality Food and I can honestly say that as I grew up and live in Manhattan most of my life.“

“Might be the BEST Italian food I’ve had in a long time. Absolutely delicious! Service was excellent also. Highly recommend!“

“Hands down, one of the finest restaurants on the North Shore. Be sure to make a reservation, as it's intimate. Top notch Chef with a staff to match.“

“I bought an apple tort for a New Years Eve family gathering and was very happy! The apple filling was lightly cinnamon and light without too much sugar and no jelled apple. The topping was neatly sliced apples brushed with a small layer of apple jelly. The crust was the short bread variety. Only $30. I was traveling and didn’t have time to bake so this light but tasty dessert was perfect! Worth visiting for hostess gifts! Nicely wrapped cookies, brownies, quick breads are sold there, too!“

“We love Piccolo and have been going for over 30 years. Our apps were fantastic, Edie Isley the linguini with clams; the eggplant and the oysters. Dinners were also very good, with special praise for the lobster special and tuna. Personally I was sad to see my favorite, filet of sole Roberto has been replaced with Branzino Desserts we're amazing, especially the Italian cheesecake“

“The service at Il Mulino is exceptional! They literally fell over each other to serve us. Food was delicious and there’s an intimate feel to the place. They have two menus. They have a prix fixed menu that offers a more affordable dining experience. Something for everyone!“

“Constantino’s makes the perfect pizza. The ingredients are so fresh and the customer service experience is the cherry on top. We went for the soft opening a few weeks back and the atmosphere was so family oriented and welcoming. Some of the best pizza I have had! They have a bunch of different kinds but the grandma pizza and the plain pizza are out of this world! You have to try this place. Mike the owner is absolutely wonderful and knows what really good pizza is.“

“I can’t say enough wonderful things about this restaurant. The food is sensational and the chef/ owner is top notch. This restaurant has the best food around and service is sensational. I would recommend this for any occasion. We will be back next week for another amazing meal.“

“We have been coming to Jonathan's for many years. It is always excellent. There is a reason why they continue to thrive after 3+decades in business. We shared the prosciutto and artichoke with Parmesan appetizer...delicious. I had the cacio e Pepe which was perfect. My husband had the halibut special, which he loved. Try the amazingly fresh crème brûlée for desert. Outstanding meal.“

“One of my favorite Long Island Restaurants. Great food and great service.“

“Have dessert. The Chocolate covered Pistachio Gelato was amazing!“

“We love hanging out at the bar having dinner. The staff is super friendly and the food is always amazing. The owner Sal always makes you feel at home. 10 out of 10!!“

“Nice place food was delicious“

“Every menu item we purchased is delicious. The finest ingredients!“

“First of all, a big thank you to the very wonderful host for accommodating our request to dine on the back patio—it was perfect! The food was outstanding, as always (highly reckoned any of their pizzas or pasta dishes, as well as the cocktails) and the service was top-notch, attentive, and friendly. We're already looking forward to our next visit. Thanks for a memorable evening!“