9 Best Pizza Restaurants in Brewster

“This is my fifth time ordering from them, and I have not been disappointed. It’s really nice to finally have a pizza place in Brewster that serves good food and cares about the quality.“

“The best Sicilian in Putnam County. Crunchy bottom, soft and tasty inside. My husband and I get a whole pie, it’s the best fresh out of the oven, we eat two or three slices in the restaurant and take home the rest, freeze for lunches. Bring a devoted Sicilian slice customer I ventured out to a salad, not any salad, their Asian salad. Cold crisp romaine lettuce, crispy chow mein noodles, sliced almonds and mandarin oranges, and the best Asian dressing. Really a very enjoyable salad. A great place for good food and great staff.“

“The food is always delicious. Whenever I order from the place I get so excited. The wings are delicious surprise or delicious although the mozzarella sticks the cheese is a little dry. Everything else is really good. Most of the time they’re on, but the longest they’ve been late is like 20 minutes. I recommend going here.“

“I recently left a negative review. I immediately received a phone call regarding my review which welcomed me to let them know if I was unhappy with my food as well as a credit. I thought that was excellent customer service, not too often found anymore. I went this evening and not only received my credit but an additional pizza as well. The pizzas were much better, so that and that the review was acknowledged go very far, a big thank you to Tony's Pizza!“

“Great Dining experience. Delicious entrees, service and family.“

“Mezzaluna restaurant is a great place to visit. I live in South Carolina and when my wife and I travel to NY we always visit Mezzaluna several times a week. The food and service is always excellent as is our usual waiter, Nick. He is great at his job, very friendly, observant, attentive and knowledgeable about the menu. The owner who we recently spoke with on the phone is very friendly and makes you feel welcome and special. If you are looking for a great place to dine in I highly recommend Mezzaluna Restaurant“

“I went all over town and prices are ridiculous. I found Five Brothers and I was actually able to buy 2 slices for the price of 1. I’ll drive the extra miles, even with the price of gas the way it is.Buy the large, they cut there large pies in 8 slices not 10. Enjoy!!“

“Amazing food..especially Sunday raw bar!“

“A hidden gem. Unlike other Italian restaurants in Brewster, they know how to make a tomato sauce that actually tastes like tomatoes! And is light on the salt, unlike the salt bombs at the most popular Italian restaurant nearby. The food is positively delicious. And their family meals are both delicious and a bargain. We had a last minute family get together, and ordered 5 family meals. It was a huge amount of food, and they had the entire order ready in 30 minutes. On a Saturday night!!!! We were certain that we would have ample leftovers, at least 1/3. But it was all devoured! Because everyone loved the food. It was greatFinally, the owners and the young girls that take the orders are so nice. A true delight.This is truly a hidden gem. Yum!!!!“