Colter Bay
$$ • New American, American, BarsAbout Colter Bay
Customers' Favorites
Spicy Chicken Sandwich
Cheeseburger and Fries
Buffalo Chicken Wings
Firehole Falls Nachos
Vegan Beyond Burger
Short Rib Sandwich
French Onion Soup
Burger with Egg
Vegan Pretzels
Soft Pretzels
Colter Bay Reviews
282 ratings
Share your opinion about Colter Bay
Went here for the first time just to have a few drinks and dinner .. The bartenders were very welcoming. The moment we came in we sat at the bar. Natalie was the first bartender to greet us . They have lots of menu items to choose from a large cocktail list large beer and wine list and the service was amazing. The bartenders were very attentive to us and Natalie took care of us most of the time that we were there and her service was just absolutely amazing. They made really good...read full review
Drinking is ok. But food takes forever, even when it isn’t busy. Fries cold, sandwich lukewarm at best.
Excellent team, great food, awesome atmosphere! Thanks for having us!
Hours
| Monday | 2PM - 12AM |
| Tuesday | 2PM - 12AM |
| Wednesday | 2PM - 12AM |
| Thursday | 2PM - 12AM |
| Friday | 12PM - 2AM |
| Saturday | 12PM - 2AM |
| Sunday | 12PM - 12AM |
Colter Bay is a renowned restaurant that offers exquisite buffalo dishes and a lively ambiance. The bar boasts an impressive selection of beer, cocktails, and a well-curated choice of craft beers on tap. The exceptional staff provides attentive and exceptional service, ensuring a pleasant dining experience.
The menu features delectable options, such as the highly recommended fish fry and buffalo chicken wedge salad. Customers praise the restaurant's impressive drink selection, with a variety of beers and cocktails available. The potato skins and spicy chicken sandwich are also standout menu items.
The restaurant's atmosphere strikes the perfect balance between relaxed and lively, making it suitable for both casual nights out and more special occasions. The food holds its own against the stellar drink selection, with thoughtful menu choices, generous portions, and dishes clearly made with care. The poutine with short rib is a customer favorite, described as "heaven in a bowl."
Overall, Colter Bay is a cornerstone of the Allentown neighborhood and one of the best go-to restaurants in Buffalo, offering a combination of excellent food, drinks, and service.