Colter Bay

$$ • New American, American, Bars

Hours:
561 Delaware Ave, Buffalo
(716) 436-5197

Customers' Favorites

Colter Bay Reviews

Restaurantji Rating
4 (82)
Restaurantji Rating

Positively amazing, our waitress Julie was the best and only waitress on a Friday night of fish Fry's. She was super busy and attentive at the same time! This establishment is lucky to have a woman of the skill she has. The Manager Christian came to the table several times to make sure everything was good, him and Julie could run the place together!! They are an amazing team! Lastly my old fashioned, my fish fry, and with an astrix, my French onion soup, was hands down the best...read full review

Restaurantji Rating

Incredible food, superb service and great atmosphere. Craft beer selection on tap is well rounded and not to be missed if it's your thing. The wedge salad with buffalo chicken is a knockout! So good!

Restaurantji Rating

Colter Bay was one of the first restaurants I went to when I moved to Buffalo and they made a great first impression for this city's food/bar scene.I have been back multiple times and will be back many times in the future. The staff is always nice, I love the decorations on the wall and the food is awesome.Last time I was there I got the hot chicken sandwich (amazing) and my fiancé loves their beyond burger. They (seasonally I think) have an elk burger that is to DIE for but...read full review

More Reviews(295)

Ratings

Hours

Monday 2PM - 12AM
Tuesday 2PM - 12AM
Wednesday 2PM - 12AM
Thursday 2PM - 12AM
Friday 12PM - 2AM
Saturday 12PM - 2AM
Sunday 12PM - 12AM
Updated on: