50 Best Pizza Restaurants near Grand Island

“Just had the most delish chicken finger wrap 🥰👍. I thought they were just pizza but they have much more! Next visit is chicken/bacon ranch wrap“

“Upon entering, I was thoroughly impressed by the elegant dining room. I was promptly greeted, and my order was taken with precision. I selected the chicken finger dinner, while my wife chose the fish fry dinner. Both dishes were exceptional. Unfortunately, my nephew consumed the majority of my meal, though I did manage to enjoy a few bites. We will certainly be ordering from this establishment again.“

“We ordered the loaded nachos with chicken, light on cheese, and a stinger sub and fries last night. Delicious. Loved the food and the cheerful young girl who served us at the Drive thru window.“

“Amazing service and food!“

“First time there. My daughter had the Smokey Eggplant Curry and it was outstanding, I had the Smoked Salmon with Goat Cheese which was incredible. The service is out of this world, and the atmosphere is delightful! If there were ten stars to give, The Lighthouse would surely deserve that.“

“They double cook the pizza like the old Dorchester location and its amazing! Also they got real bacon strips. 24 extra cheese, pepperoni, bacon strips and 4lbs of wings medium saucy is the bomb! *New Thorold Stone location across from Circle K*. They are always consistant and their pizza is the best in the region.“

“A great family oriented and run restaurant. The owner is fun funny and friendly and helpful. Food was great and prices just right.“

“Just left a glowing 5-star review based on JT's pizza. However, JT's wings and blue-cheese dipping sauce were so good, they compeled their own review. Our first Buffalo-destination in July 2025 was a "bar" known for their creation of Buffalo-wings. When we return in July 2026, JT's will be our first Buffalo-destination for wings. Large fully-cooked chicken wing drumettes and flats. The size required 4-5 adult mouth-fulls to get to the bare-bones. Scrumptious, tender, moist chicken meat inside a crispy outer covering, hand shaken in unique inspired sauces. Perfection defined for Buffalo-wings. JT's is a must for those who appreciate the best Buffalo-wing experience. Try them once, you will not find their equal in Buffalo ( or any other place ). LMAO! The JT's wings experience ruined our desire for wings anywhere else. Just saying, save your Buffalo-wing cravings for a visit to JT's.“

“Had the best dinner out in a very long time. Sea Bass special. Not sure I would have ordered it if the dish was written out. Too many things added in that I ultimately didn't know what they were. Not a big pesto fan and the dish came in a bath of creamy green with an odd looking chutney of sorts on top. The green was a fantastic pesto tinged super flavorful sauce and the topping was a grand mix of sweet, savory and nut crunch, a fantastic meal.“

“Tonight was my first time going to sal's pizzeria the pizza is very good and staff is very welcoming ill definitly go back again i recommend sal's to everyone😁😁😁“

“Food is amazing, staff is friendly and attentive...we love it here! Our go to place.“

“Popped in for their one year anniversary where they were offering up dollar slices and I got the New York style and it was solid. Definitely looking forward to visiting again to check out some of their cocktails. I really like their business model and that they are a tip-less establishment because of their practices in paying their employees which is cool.“

“Was at zappis on Saturday September 6th with my husband and son. My husband and I eat at zappi's every March and October as we run a marriage program and usually have 10 people at dinner and have never had an issue with food or service. Yesterday however service was great but when I received my calzone, it had red peppers in it which I didn't order. So the waitress took it back and had another one made for me and gave me 50% off. I did order another one for takeout and as I went to eat it today for dinner, It has green mushrooms in it, which I cannot eat as it affects my stomach. I was so looking forward to my calzone and now I am disappointed I cannot eat it.“

“Authentic Napoli pizza near the tourist strip in Niagara. It doesn’t look fancy from the outside, but the food was delicious. Waitress was very friendly.
My partner and I shared bruschetta and a pizza and we were very satisfied.
A great spot, especially for those looking to avoid the chains.“

“first time and I tell you the pizza was so good and the favor awesome wings were big and delicious ty seeya again“

“Delicious food…!!! Served Hot, exactly as ordered. Only reason for giving 4 stars is coz the girl in front desk did not allow my 12 year old kid to use the washroom. I understand it’s a staff washroom but it’s for a 12 year old kid who needed to use washroom urgently. I would have allowed if it was me.“

“We had a bad experience with the quality of food awhile back but so glad that didn’t deter us from trying again. The food has always been amazing since then. Big portions. The customer service is always good. They make you feel welcomed and so appreciative of your business. They are always our “go to” for pizza and wings. I highly recommend their place for excellent food and atmosphere.“

“This place was so good we went back a second time while on vacation! Great food and service!! 10/10….not sure how people can give this place a bad review. Both times we were there it was nothing but A class service and top notch pizza! I highly recommend.“

“We had a great experience at Papa John's. Nakul was awesome. He was very kind and generous. The pizza and wings were hot, fresh, and delicious. Cooked perfectly. He is the embodiment of execllant customer service. Thanks for a great experience!“

“Just picked up Large Cheese&Pep pizza. Outstanding!! Love the basically double cheese&pep. Also got an order if deep fried mushrooms w/ blue cheese sauce. Highly recommend!! Usually get from Franco's but enjoyed this much better. Crust crispy, thick & chewy. Lately our order from other place has been too well done and bland sauce. Found our new favorite place. Fifteen min away but it's well worth the trip.“

“Don’t hesitate to buy their food products! Pizza, wings, fries, onion rings etc. were all served fresh. Found my local go-to-pizza store here in Niagara!“

“Excellent pizza! Excellent bread! Excellent people!!!! I'd give 10 stars if I could!!!!“

“I love Leon’s but trying to look at your menu is horrendous. I’m willing to bet that you lose business. I’m not creating a login to order a pizza. I just order from other places instead.“

“We recently had the best experience dining at The Pizzeria in Niagara Falls! The food was absolutely delicious! We had pizza and seafood and it was to die for! Service was attentive, fast and very friendly! Very reasonably priced too! Thank you to The Pizzeria for making our family experience wonderful.“

“shout out to your Kenmore location! Super fast delivery today very kind delivery man made my night when he thanked me for leaving him a tip. Tips have become such standard practice for everything it was nice to get a thank you!And as always great food at reasonable prices!“

“I ordered a meat lovers pizza and taco logs. As I was walking out I dropped the taco logs I walked back in to order more and the guy replaced them free of charge. They have fantastic food and customer“

“I wouldn't recommend the Steak Quesadilla as it was extremely salty. However the chicken quesadilla was mighty delicious.“

“Fantastic service, our server Lidia was exceptionally helpful, pleasant and alway had a smile I’ll be back 🥂“

“I visit this pizza store almost every day because their food is truly amazing! They have halal chicken and halal pepperoni, which is a big plus. Their Philly Cheese Steak pizza is one of the best I’ve ever had, and the wings are also delicious. Highly recommended for anyone looking for great taste and quality“

“Everytime I am in the area I make sure I stop. Pizza is always Delicious and amazing. Last time I had a steak n cheese sub delicious of course. ! This is my go to spot !“

“My wife and I ordered a pizza the other day for the first time in a very long time from Mustachios the food was amazing. The service was excellent. The delivery delivery driver was very friendly and very very cordial even had a menu in the car for us fast-forward to Friday night we just ordered fish fries and it was amazing. Thank you.“

“This pizza is the best I’ve had in a long time. The pesto pizza had fresh mozzarella and tomatoes (a treat!) and was served piping hot. The crust was well done, but I can’t think of many people who would call it thin. The bacon and sprout pizza was also really nicely done. Either of those pizzas could have fed two people who weren’t giant pigs. All around great experience.“

“Delicious subs that are huge! We got the 8 inch Cane Corso, great flavor on the slices of steak, perfect with the crispy lettuce. The chicken finger wrap was good, although we'll get it as a sub next time because the bread was so good. Garlic bread has tomatoes, which I love and not a super strong garlic flavor. Hand cut fries we're on point. The soup was gazpacho and if you like your gazpacho blended, it's worth a try. They sell a board game, which is super random, but the staff explained they created the game. I'm not much into the board games, but he was really knowledgeable about it and I gotta say, I'm considering checking it out. Friendly, delicious great prices. Maybe I'll remember pictures next time.“

“Just had a sausage sub, chicken finger sub, and steak sub. Just delicious. Thanks“

“Wow! Does this place do it right!!! I had the old fashioned pizza and it was like I stepped back to my childhood! So flavorful and delicious! The place smelled so wonderful…fresh Italian bread baking all the time! I love the seeded loaf and could eat it by myself! The sandwiches are so fresh and made to order on this Italian bread. They load the sandwiches to the max! I’ve had the caprese and the Philly! I also love the minis. I keep them in my freezer and I get some for my elderly mother because they are a perfect and quick lunch. They are packed with flavor and there are many varieties. Love this place“

“Great food and friendly staff“

“Pizza is very good, order online and ready for when U schedule a time. Food is hot and fresh.“

“Food was good. Fast. Only complaint was I had my family member pick up the food and they only him to get one blue cheese even though I ordered 2. This isn’t the first time this has happened. The last couple of times they did not even tell him to get the blue cheese that was ordered. There needs to be a better process for the cooler items during pick up. Maybe a sticker on the box telling what to get and how many?“

“The pizza is always hot, fresh, and made just the way I like it. The crust is perfectly cooked, the toppings are generous, and the cheese has that perfect stretch. I also love that they offer a wide variety of options, from classic pizzas to wings, garlic bread, and even plant-based choices.“

“always cooked consistently and friendly staff!“

“One of our favourite bars , great owners, staff and friendly regulars. Great music and pizza. Excellent place for music“

“Tried the Kerala-style chicken biriyani at Gamblers Pizza — absolutely amazing! The flavor, aroma, and texture are spot on, honestly better than many Kerala restaurants around. It’s so popular that it sells out fast every time. A must-try if you can get your hands on it!“

“Ordered a Veggie Pizza +ricotta Friday night and it’s been two days since and I’m still thinking about how delicious it was and I want more. Literally the best pizza I’ve ever had in my entire life“

“Consistently excellent! The chicken fingers are huge and tender- and there's an extensive variety of dips/ sauces.“

“I don't know where to start with Mr. Ventrys. It was great on Pierce Avenue, when it was both locations, and it's still going strong solely on The Blvd. I have RARELY encountered a restaurant that is consistent EVERY SINGLE TIME. You crave what you got the last three times? It will be JUST AS GOOD the fourth time you order it. Consistency is so important when running a business; It shouldn't depend on who is working that day, what mood the cook is in, etc... This is how you do it. Serve amazing food, exactly as ordered, every time. I have never been disappointed by Mr. Ventrys, and I had to write a positive review. Thank you!“

“yes. the food is consistent, always good. hot pepper pizza and fried cauliflower might be my favorite. service is friendly, and they go the extra mile. oh.....and they have parking, which is great for the location!“

“We generally avoid chains/franchises, especially when it comes to pizza but we have to say that a recent pie from Domino's was excellent. Certainly not the best pizza we have ever had, but based on the friendly service and value for money, the experience was A+.“

“We were vacationing in Niagara Falls, staying at the Comfort Inn & Suites & asked the front desk who they recommended for pizza. They said Jaco's, which is open on Mondays. We were somewhat hungry & decided to order a calzone. The wait time of an hour was acceptable. The calzone was hot when delivered, HUGE, and very tasty; not over done nor bland sauce. We got 3 meals out of it. Will order again if in the area.“

“ordered take out pizza and chicken fingers tonight in lockport. there was a small miscommunication with our order when we came to pick it up. Scott was amazing and made it right. not only did he offer to make it right but wanted to make sure I was happy with what was offered. "I want to make sure you leave happy" we love papa Leo's food and amazing customer service. keep up the great work!“

“Always great service and quality food. The staff is friendly and always do a great job with our custom order.

Whether we order ahead of time online, or walk in, service is fast.

We always get the BBQ chicken pizza and we definitely recommend it!“